Evidence of meeting #43 for Foreign Affairs and International Development in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was defence.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Cronin  Director General, North America Bureau, Department of Foreign Affairs, Trade and Development
Mondy  Director General, North America Trade Policy Bureau, Department of Foreign Affairs, Trade and Development
Larose  Director General, International Security Policy and Strategic Affairs Bureau, Department of Foreign Affairs, Trade and Development
Andrea Charron  Director, Centre for Defence and Security Studies, University of Manitoba, As an Individual
Meredith Lilly  Full Professor, Simon Reisman Chair in International Economic Policy, Carleton University, As an Individual
Tronnes  Executive Director, Center for North American Prosperity and Security, As an Individual

12:25 p.m.

Executive Director, Center for North American Prosperity and Security, As an Individual

Jamie Tronnes

I'm really not familiar with the number of alleged foreign agents operating in Canada. It may be simply a question of capacity and understanding from the legal side of whether one is required to register, but I really couldn't say.

The Chair Liberal Ahmed Hussen

Thank you very much.

We will go next to MP Sari.

You have six minutes.

Abdelhaq Sari Liberal Bourassa, QC

Thank you very much, Mr. Chair.

I would like to thank the witnesses very much for joining us today, because I see some familiarity in their testimony.

I have many subjects to talk about, but since I have only six minutes, I am going to address only three.

I have an academic background, having taught a lot, and I've participated in a lot of debates on the issue of supply chain integration or economic integration in general. We can talk about a tariff war or a dispute with the U.S., but what lessons can we learn today to better position ourselves on the advantages and disadvantages of having an integrated supply chain with our neighbours to the south?

12:25 p.m.

Full Professor, Simon Reisman Chair in International Economic Policy, Carleton University, As an Individual

Dr. Meredith Lilly

Thank you for the question.

How can we position ourselves better to have integrated supply chains? Is that the question?

Abdelhaq Sari Liberal Bourassa, QC

There were always two schools of thought: one that said we needed good integration with our neighbours and the other that said the opposite. Does this dispute, this tariff war, lead us to clarify our position on this?

12:25 p.m.

Full Professor, Simon Reisman Chair in International Economic Policy, Carleton University, As an Individual

Dr. Meredith Lilly

COVID offered a very good example of the ways to think about this. The conclusion I've come to, for my own thinking, is that we should seek to develop our own supply chains in areas that are vital to our human interests.

The one example that came to light during COVID was when the Trump administration threatened to cut off Canadian access to 3M masks. Our ambassador at the time worked very hard to ensure that didn't happen, but it did create a great deal of concern in Canada that we were dependent on a foreign supply chain. The decision was made by Premier Ford, as well as others, to work with 3M to establish a presence in Canada.

It is more duplicative and, therefore, more expensive, so it's not always desirable. I wouldn't suggest it for all products, but when products are essential for human life and for the security of Canadians, there are times when duplicating supply chains probably makes sense.

Abdelhaq Sari Liberal Bourassa, QC

Ms. Tronnes, I went to Chicago this summer to attend the National Conference of State Legislatures, or NCSL, with several elected U.S. senators. I saw a certain evolution in their position, whether they were Republicans or Democrats.

In a negotiation, there are always two sides. In your opinion, how do our neighbours to the south perceive the negotiations?

12:25 p.m.

Executive Director, Center for North American Prosperity and Security, As an Individual

Jamie Tronnes

It really depends on who you ask.

Abdelhaq Sari Liberal Bourassa, QC

My opinion was simple: What we heard inside the office was different from what we heard outside.

12:25 p.m.

Executive Director, Center for North American Prosperity and Security, As an Individual

Jamie Tronnes

I wasn't inside the office, so I couldn't tell you, but I know it is a question. Whether Canada walked away is not something that the Americans are particularly concerned about. The Americans are concerned primarily with the cost of living, and tariffs are a huge part of that.

I would refer the committee to a poll done by the Cato Institute's Scott Lincicome. I have a copy of it in front of me outlining how concerned people are about the tariffs. Seventy-four per cent of respondents said tariffs raised prices at the grocery store; 53% said tariffs weakened the U.S. economy, and 49% said tariffs made their own lives worse.

I think that Americans are generally not concerned with who said what and who walked away from whom. They're concerned with the average everyday cost of living and whether they're going to be able to build a house or afford to stay in their current house. Those sorts of things are fundamental right now.

Abdelhaq Sari Liberal Bourassa, QC

Thank you very much for your answer.

I would like to talk about another important element in a negotiation. I hear my colleagues on the other side of the room talk about negotiations focusing a lot on tariffs or retaliatory tariffs, which are certainly very important. However, in these negotiations, there is another very important element: sovereignty. I would like to hear your thoughts on that. Dr. Charron can weigh in as well.

In the agreement we are looking for, it is not just about what percentage of tariffs we can give up; it is also about sovereignty, particularly in economic and digital terms, but in all respects. That is also important. It's about being able to make our own decisions without having to consult our neighbours.

12:30 p.m.

Executive Director, Center for North American Prosperity and Security, As an Individual

Jamie Tronnes

Yes. On that, I would say, before deferring to Madame Charron, that it is important for Canadians to remember that our sovereignty is important to us and that we are a G7 country. We should not be treated as a state. I think most Americans understand that and respect us in terms of being a foreign country. I can't think of another time when Canada was talked about in such a varying degree of terms: as a neighbour, as a country and as a place that, of all places, America should certainly be getting along with.

I'll yield some time to Madame Charron.

Prof. Andrea Charron

Thank you for the question.

When it comes to the defence relationship with the U.S., it's important that Canada have the capabilities to defend itself and that it can leverage partners, allies and the relationship with the United States. This is essentially what the NORAD agreement requires. We're broken into three regions. Canada is a complete region, and we decide nationally what capabilities we give to NORAD in support of Canada-U.S. North American defence.

What we need urgently is for many of the NORAD modernization projects, such as the Arctic over-the-horizon radar system, to come online immediately. Because the north warning system is coming to the end of its operational life, even with the Arctic over-the-horizon radar system there are still parts of Canada in which we are going to be essentially blind. We are stronger together, assuming that both parties do their part to defend their own homeland.

The Chair Liberal Ahmed Hussen

Thank you very much. We'll go next to MP Brunelle-Duceppe.

You have six minutes.

Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe Bloc Lac-Saint-Jean, QC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

My sincere thanks to the witnesses we have with us today.

Ms. Lilly, earlier Mr. Mantle asked you what opposition members could do to help with the negotiations. While we may have a lesser role, since we unfortunately aren't at the table, we can still make recommendations. However, we aren't necessarily in the know about what's happening at the negotiating table.

There is an area, though, where we could play a larger role, and that's what my question is about. Until such time as negotiations resume and a deal is signed, shouldn't the government's priority be to find the best way to support the industries most affected by the tariffs?

You talked about those who lose their jobs and struggle to find new ones. Shouldn't that be the government's priority right now? Shouldn't it be focusing on the sectors hardest hit by the tariff war?

October 5th, 2026 / 12:30 p.m.

Full Professor, Simon Reisman Chair in International Economic Policy, Carleton University, As an Individual

Dr. Meredith Lilly

Thank you for the question.

Absolutely. The government should be focused on businesses and workers affected by the tariff war.

I know they have rolled out a series of supports. The Government of Canada is very large and employs thousands of people, and I'd like to think they can do several things at once. While my comments were about the restarting of negotiations, I would hope that they are spending their full time and energy on this. Of course, opposition members need to do that as well. You all represent your individual constituencies of different political stripes.

Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe Bloc Lac-Saint-Jean, QC

Thank you for your answer.

Can you tell us whether the oil and gas industry is currently subject to the U.S. tariffs?

12:30 p.m.

Full Professor, Simon Reisman Chair in International Economic Policy, Carleton University, As an Individual

Dr. Meredith Lilly

The U.S. has placed tariffs, but most of those tariffs are considered CUSMA-compliant, so there are exemptions for that.

Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe Bloc Lac-Saint-Jean, QC

That means there are no tariffs on oil and gas products.

Can you tell us who owns the majority of oil and gas companies in Canada? Who are the shareholders?

12:30 p.m.

Full Professor, Simon Reisman Chair in International Economic Policy, Carleton University, As an Individual

Dr. Meredith Lilly

This is not a question I can answer.

Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe Bloc Lac-Saint-Jean, QC

Can anyone tell me?

12:30 p.m.

Executive Director, Center for North American Prosperity and Security, As an Individual

Jamie Tronnes

I believe most of them are in what we call—or what they refer to themselves as—USMCA companies. In them, the ownership, such as that of Cenovus, is between two countries, and they consider themselves to be of both Canada and the United States.

Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe Bloc Lac-Saint-Jean, QC

Our documentation shows that 60% are owned by American shareholders. That has been verified. That's published information.

Are you able to tell us which country buys most of the oil and gas products? It's probably the United States, right?

What I'm trying to say is that we, as opposition members, are called upon to support the industries most affected by the tariffs. Meanwhile, the Canadian government is supporting the oil and gas sector, which isn't subject to the tariffs, is largely American-owned, sells most of its products to Americans and is projected to generate $90 billion in profits this year, 2026.

We paid $40 billion for Trans Mountain, and we're going to pay for Pacific Link, even though it doesn't have a private proponent. The money is going to come from taxpayers. What's more, the government has extended tax credits for the oil and gas industry until 2040, which will collectively cost us $100 billion in tax credits. Then we're being asked to support the industries hardest hit by the tariffs.

Here's what I wonder, as an opposition member: Shouldn't I denounce the fact that most of the support for affected economic sectors goes to the oil and gas industry, not the forestry or manufacturing industry, for instance?

Isn't it a gross error on the government's part to use public money that way, instead of supporting the hardest hit industries?

12:35 p.m.

Executive Director, Center for North American Prosperity and Security, As an Individual

Jamie Tronnes

They're going to get their steel to build the pipeline from Canada. They're going to get the aluminum to build the pipeline from Quebec. They're going to get a lot of their domestic production from Canada. It's going to be Canadians who will build the pipeline, and it will be Canadians who profit from it.

It is our resource. It's about time that we started using it for soft power, to heat our own homes and to give ourselves a discount at the pump, perhaps.

It's so that we're no longer, particularly in Quebec, reliant on shipping our oil and gas down through the United States, only for it to come back up and be reimported back into Canada to heat the east. That is absolutely ridiculous.

We are a sovereign nation. We should act like it. We need to build more pipelines in order to guarantee our own sovereignty in our own country.

Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe Bloc Lac-Saint-Jean, QC

In your view, then, we should invest in a product for which global demand will drop in the next 50 years and in infrastructure that won't be ready for another 12, 13 or 14 years, when the tariff war is happening now. That's what I can't wrap my head around.

Forestry workers are losing their jobs now, and the government isn't supporting their industry. How do we justify spending billions of dollars of Quebeckers' taxes on an industry that isn't currently helping to protect jobs in forestry communities in Quebec's regions?

Do you think the use of Canadian steel justifies that spending? Is that the sole justification?