Evidence of meeting #21 for Government Operations and Estimates in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was stellantis.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Jennings  Deputy Minister, Department of Industry
Tanton  Assistant Deputy Minister, Innovation Canada, Department of Industry
Bédard  Law Clerk and Parliamentary Counsel, House of Commons

11:10 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Kelly McCauley

I'm sorry, that is our time.

We now have Ms. Rochefort for six minutes.

Pauline Rochefort Liberal Nipissing—Timiskaming, ON

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Thank you, Mr. Jennings, for being present today.

Before we go any further, I'd like to come back to what the contract says in terms of the consent that's required.

Would you be able to read the section in the contract that indicates that consent is required?

11:10 a.m.

Deputy Minister, Department of Industry

Philip Jennings

I'm going to turn to one of my colleagues.

I don't have the actual contract in front of me so I'll turn to Stephanie.

Pauline Rochefort Liberal Nipissing—Timiskaming, ON

Thank you.

It's been in the public testimony before.

11:10 a.m.

Conservative

Tamara Jansen Conservative Cloverdale—Langley City, BC

Are we allowed to read out of the contract then?

11:10 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Kelly McCauley

I suspect Ms. Rochefort was more making a point and not asking for a specific statement from the contract.

Pauline Rochefort Liberal Nipissing—Timiskaming, ON

Correct. Yes.

In general, what does section 16 in the contract on the consent required indicate?

Stephanie Tanton Assistant Deputy Minister, Innovation Canada, Department of Industry

Section 16 of the confidentiality clause in our agreement, and this is standard language in our agreements, includes that each party, so that's both Stellantis and the government, shall keep confidential and shall not consent without the other party's agreement to disclose the information contained within that agreement.

Pauline Rochefort Liberal Nipissing—Timiskaming, ON

My impressions are as well that there are certain acts of government that you are bound to respect.

Would you be able to name some of these acts? As public servants, that is your obligation as you pursue your work to also respect these acts of confidentiality. I was thinking, for example, of the Access to Information Act and so on.

11:10 a.m.

Deputy Minister, Department of Industry

Philip Jennings

Yes, I think that's a good example.

Maybe the best way to answer that is to say that this government takes any obligations it has, in terms of confidentiality, very seriously. That is under all contracts that we have and under all existing federal legislation and laws. Access to information is another example, but it also includes clauses that exist in many agreements we have with companies.

As I outlined earlier, we need this commercially confidential information to be able to do the proper due diligence. At the end of the day, we're essentially trying to ensure that the investments that are made on behalf of Canadians are done with the best prudence possible. In return, the companies trust the government to not share that information without having their consent to do so.

The access to information law is different in terms of how it's structured versus how it is in contract. However, ultimately, the consent of the companies is required to be able to share this information, either publicly in ATIP or in this case with Stellantis with the condition that it be shared with this committee in camera.

Pauline Rochefort Liberal Nipissing—Timiskaming, ON

My understanding as well is that such contracts have terms and clauses that dictate how funds are disbursed, milestones for example.

Would that be the case with this particular contract as well?

11:15 a.m.

Deputy Minister, Department of Industry

Philip Jennings

That is typically how contracts of this size would flow out. At the end of the day, these are multi-year projects. Typically, there would be flows and payments we've made against expenditures that are made by companies.

Pauline Rochefort Liberal Nipissing—Timiskaming, ON

As well, would employment targets typically form part of such contracts?

11:15 a.m.

Deputy Minister, Department of Industry

Philip Jennings

Certainly, it would be typical in terms of what would be there. Benefits, for example, would be jobs, capital expenditure investments, R and D investments, and IP investments. These are the types of things that are typical in contracts.

I hope you'll understand that we seek to maximize the benefits to Canada as we make investments. In addition to benefits we also have clauses related to non-performance against those benefits and they're also typically found in these kinds of contracts.

Pauline Rochefort Liberal Nipissing—Timiskaming, ON

I was satisfied, Mr. Chair, in reading through the contract that those clauses were there. I found that to be a very well-structured contract.

I want to come back to a comment made by Mr. Patzer. I thought he asked an excellent question at one of our last meetings. He asked, “Does clause 16.1 supersede Parliament, or does Parliament supersede clause 16.1?”

Mr. Bédard answered by saying, “Clause 16 in the contract is a typical confidentiality clause”, which we expect our public servants to try to respect as they do their work, but “[t]hose clauses do not override the power of certain bodies, including”—as you pointed out, Madam Jansen—“the courts and Parliament, to compel the production of documents.”

In trying to understand the power, I've gone to look, and it does come with certain obligations. As we have this discussion by reviewing the contract in camera, that is in a sense power being exercised.

My question is directed to Mr. Bédard.

Would that be proper, Mr. Chair?

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Kelly McCauley

Sorry; I should have mentioned that before. I'll pause your time. As I mentioned last time, Mr. Bédard is with us, so feel free to direct questions to him.

Michel Bédard Law Clerk and Parliamentary Counsel, House of Commons

In the contract, as you paraphrased my evidence from the last meeting, those confidentiality clauses do not bind the courts, Parliament or bodies that have the power to send for records. You cannot override a legal power by contract.

Just as with a court, the party can make a request that certain information not be disclosed publicly. A witness or a party before Parliament can request that certain information be kept confidential so that it would be, for example, only for the consideration of members at the in camera sessions, and maybe special safeguards would be put in place for the consultation of the documents, but that is at the discretion of the committee, which has to consent to it.

Ultimately, the committee has the power to send for records and may insist on the production of unredacted documents, and then it's for the committee to decide what it sees fit in terms of distribution.

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Kelly McCauley

Thanks. That is our time.

Mr. Lemire, welcome back to OGGO.

You have six minutes, sir.

Sébastien Lemire Bloc Abitibi—Témiscamingue, QC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Mr. Jennings, as they say, a person can catch more flies with honey than with vinegar. The same applies to the auto industry, and we know that this industry is cyclical. We need only think back a few years to our bidding war with the Americans, who wanted to heavily subsidize their auto industry to attract investments, like the Stellantis investment, over to their side.

I've always been a critic of this kind of one-upmanship approach. What we need instead is to develop an industry, an entire supply chain, based on regional resources, particularly for electric batteries. We need to extract and process lithium, nickel and other minerals close to the resource. Every step is included, from crushing to manufacturing anodes and cathodes. Abitibi-Témiscamingue has sulphuric acid, lithium and more. All of these steps would equip us to produce what could be the greenest battery in the world using a production cell that respects the work, that doesn't impose forced labour, and that meets the highest environmental standards. Quebec's laws are extremely strict in this area. Institutional knowledge can also be leveraged. If we did all that, I think that industries would flock here to Quebec and Canada to build their cars. We would be producing the greenest product with the best traceability in the world. That's what will bring companies to invest here.

Because of the free trade agreement with the United States, the strategy used four or five years ago ultimately consisted of giving money away to attract these companies. It was relatively easy. All of a sudden, however, we realized that we hadn't developed a mining value chain for critical and strategic minerals. Donald Trump's arrival stalled the business momentum and Stellantis ultimately decided to move its Jeep Compass production activity elsewhere. This is problematic, and puts Canada in a very difficult situation.

My first question concerns a number of issues. Stellantis, Honda and Volkswagen were there. We're talking about agreements worth tens of billions of dollars. Quebec didn't need to feel too left out because there was a potential investment in Northvolt. Naturally, as Quebeckers, we know that the small and medium-sized enterprise ecosystem and jobs revolving around the auto industry are exclusively in Ontario. However, Quebec leads in all things related to innovation in the electrification of transportation. Still, we feel robbed.

As far as the Stellantis, Honda and Volkswagen strategy goes, are the contracts similar? Is the Stellantis contract specific to Stellantis? Is each of these contracts developed along these lines?

December 9th, 2025 / 11:20 a.m.

Deputy Minister, Department of Industry

Philip Jennings

The contract with Stellantis isn't limited to electrification only. Volkswagen and NextStar are examples of times when a highly unique structure was implemented in an effort to promote battery production in Canada. It came partly in response to incentives introduced in the United States at the time. It was really about battery production and sales in Canada. The idea was to offer the same kind of subsidy as the one available in the United States. It wasn't put in place until then. At the time, the idea was really to make sure that, despite a bit of lag, the global trend toward electrification would continue. In some parts of the world things were really advanced. Canada wanted to be part of the auto sector of the future. That was the reason for the investments made. In the case of batteries, that's why a unique approach was needed. Production subsidies were a necessity.

For Stellantis, however, it was more of a standard investment for developing car models that would have been built in Windsor and Brampton. The only thing I would add is that it included electric vehicle production. Two electric vehicles are produced in Windsor: the Chrysler Pacifica van and the Dodge Charger.

Sébastien Lemire Bloc Abitibi—Témiscamingue, QC

I appreciate the regret you expressed at the outset, but the fact remains that this, in my opinion, is a global issue.

Obviously, there's the issue of transparency and the Canadian government's wishes in matters of accountability, especially by the Department of Industry. In a global context, however, how might the fact that the rest of the world was watching have affected the decision you made, prior to the regret you expressed? I'm thinking more specifically of multinationals potentially interested in investing in the Canadian and Quebec battery industry, because that's where the resource is and where the clean energy may be. To what extent was your decision influenced by an awareness that the world was watching and by concern over the possible disclosure of trade secrets?

11:20 a.m.

Deputy Minister, Department of Industry

Philip Jennings

I'm not sure that I entirely understand the question, but—

Sébastien Lemire Bloc Abitibi—Témiscamingue, QC

If you make a contract public, other parties interested in signing contracts with you might feel nervous at the prospect of ending up in the spotlight, like Stellantis right now. People doing business don't want to manage a crisis. Still, I think that lessons can be learned from the current situation. Lessons should have been learned after what happened two years ago. Disseminating these contracts is creating a problematic situation again. What message does that send to the rest of the world and to investors?

11:20 a.m.

Deputy Minister, Department of Industry

Philip Jennings

I'll do my best to respond. I hope it will answer your question.

As I've said a few times, we have to strike a balance between the need to provide Parliament with access to the documents it wants to see, and the fact that we're dealing with the very commercially sensitive information of companies. When we process documents with due diligence, companies expect us not to disclose any information that would be damaging to competition. This is a clause that we often discuss with companies to avoid causing long-term, competition-related problems.

We try to protect that right. During previous Parliaments, we had agreements with some committees to share redacted copies of documents with them, but in camera. The most recent example is the Standing Committee on Environment and Sustainable Development. Twenty-three companies took part in the meeting, and we agreed to redact certain information for them all.

11:25 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Kelly McCauley

Thank you. That is your time.

Mr. Patzer, go ahead, please.