Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Mr. Calkins, I congratulate you on your work, particularly in removing nicotine products from this exemption. As a member of the 80% of the public who take natural health products, namely high-dose vitamins C and D on the advice of my cardiologist, I do understand. I shouldn't need a prescription for vitamin C or D, and I don't.
I've heard from a couple of witnesses that natural health products are not medicines and they do not make claims to be medicines, but we discussed several examples that contradict this.
I spoke of this in the last meeting: St. John's wort. This is a natural health product. It's marketed for the treatment of depression and for symptoms of menopause. The active ingredient has the same mechanism of action as common anti-depressants similar to the class of fluoxetine, better known as Prozac. This product also has a similar risk of serious interactions with a number of prescriptions and over-the-counter medications. This product also has an additional effect similar to an older form of anti-depressant known as MAO inhibitors, which, themselves, are now very rarely prescribed because they can have serious interactions with medicines, as well as with a number of foods.
This is a medicine. It claims to be a medicine. It claims to have a therapeutic effect. It has the same mechanism of action and side effect profile as prescription medications.
We have other examples of this—turmeric, a natural health product for joint inflammation. This has been linked to some very serious liver conditions. Even vitamins, as much as I'm not advocating for a prescription for them, are low risk but not zero risk. If someone was taking the anticoagulant warfarin to prevent strokes and certain conditions, if they take vitamin K, it counteracts that and gives an increased risk of stroke. In fact, when I'm practising medicine, vitamin K is actually the treatment of choice for someone who comes in and their blood is too thin due to too much warfarin.
Considering that these products make these medical claims and have substantial risks like medicines, it doesn't make sense to me that removing the same safeguards for the public as prescription medicines would be in the interest of public safety.
This is my first question: If a prescription medication is, for any reason, found to have a risk to the public, Health Canada regulations permit the timely suspensions of the availability of these products to protect the public. If a natural health product is found to pose a similar risk, why would we not want to afford the public the same ability to suspend its distribution and recall it for public safety?
