I see.
I imagine you read the amendments we submitted just yesterday or the day before. That means you'll be supporting—
Evidence of meeting #37 for Health in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was industry.
A video is available from Parliament.
Bloc
Marie-Hélène Gaudreau Bloc Laurentides—Labelle, QC
I see.
I imagine you read the amendments we submitted just yesterday or the day before. That means you'll be supporting—
Conservative
Blaine Calkins Conservative Ponoka—Didsbury, AB
Can I get Madame Gaudreau to start over? I did not hear the translation at the start of the question.
Liberal
Bloc
Marie-Hélène Gaudreau Bloc Laurentides—Labelle, QC
Thank you for being forthright about the fact that there is an interpretation delay. The interpreters do a great job, but the conversation moves quickly at times, especially when you're speaking English, and they miss things. Thank you for your vigilance.
Here's my question. If I understand correctly, you're going to support our amendments to your bill. Is that right?
Conservative
Blaine Calkins Conservative Ponoka—Didsbury, AB
That would be a question that you should ask my colleagues who are the voting members of the committee, but I would suggest to you, Madame Gaudreau, that as long as the amendment and the wording of the amendment made sure that natural health products stayed in their lane and were in no way considered therapeutic products, it would probably be something I think the industry, the broader Canadian public and, of course, my Conservative colleagues could reasonably support.
Bloc
Marie-Hélène Gaudreau Bloc Laurentides—Labelle, QC
I'm surprised I have a minute left. I thought my five minutes were up.
Actually, that's all I need. That will be all, since I need to speak with the member's colleagues.
Liberal
The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal
Thank you.
We'll go to Ms. Konanz for four minutes.
Please go ahead.
Conservative
Helena Konanz Conservative Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay, BC
Thank you, MP Calkins, for all the work you've done on this bill. I can tell you that my office has heard from not only members of the industry and our local stores but also everyday people, just like all of us around this table, I'm sure, who would like to continue to buy Canadian and continue to have products offered in our local stores.
You mentioned in your introduction that Canadian businesses are presented with stiff competition and challenges right now. My riding has six border crossings and, of course, Amazon, so industry is really nervous that this is going to make it even tougher to get Canadian products.
Can you tell me what you've heard about how this is going to affect Canadian businesses, Canadian products and the Canadian natural health industry?
Conservative
Blaine Calkins Conservative Ponoka—Didsbury, AB
We've already heard from one of the witnesses here, who said that she started up her business three years ago in the United States because it was easier and quicker to get her business up and going and get a revenue stream than it was here in Canada.
I'm not suggesting that we don't have a pre-approval process here in Canada, but the one thing that the industry certainly can't withstand—and I think Mr. Chen from the Traditional Chinese Medicine Association identified this as well—is the massive fees that were planned, when Bill C-47 was passed, to get a site licence and get an approval.
It's not fair, realistic or even plausible for a mom-and-pop shop to have to go through the same type of regulatory framework for approvals that a company like Pfizer, Bayer or some other massive company would have to go through as an approval process. To equate the two as being the same thing is ridiculous.
I'll add a comment, because I wasn't able to fully answer Mr. Eyolfson's question. There are foods.... You can buy turmeric, which he talked about as a health product. It's also food. You can go buy it from the spice rack in the grocery store. You can go buy a grapefruit and it'll do the same thing. It'll interfere with medication that might be prescribed by a doctor. The pharmacists where I live are smart enough to put a little sticker on the bottle saying not to eat grapefruit while you're taking the medication.
The natural progression, if the logic being used is that anything that interferes or potentially interacts with a therapeutic needs to become a therapeutic product, is that pretty soon everything in the grocery aisle is going to be a therapeutic product.
Conservative
Helena Konanz Conservative Similkameen—South Okanagan—West Kootenay, BC
Thank you.
As you mentioned, the United States doesn't have the types of requirements for products that we do, not even currently. What about labelling? I've walked into local stores while doing my research on this, and they're showing me the extensive labels that need to be on these tiny bottles. It's becoming more and more difficult.
Why would there be such labelling requirements when Health Canada already had that requirement before 2023?
Conservative
Blaine Calkins Conservative Ponoka—Didsbury, AB
Everybody reasonably wants accuracy in the labelling. They want to know that what's on the label of the bottle is actually what's inside. I think that's the case right now. If it's found not to be the case—again, I was interrupted going through the list of powers that Health Canada has—Health Canada can mandate a label change. They can add a warning, for example, or require a company to add a warning. They can inspect any site licence they want to at any point in time and inspect that site and location and conduct an audit.
As a matter of fact, the producer, the manufacturer or the shipper must provide space for Health Canada officials to come into the business and inspect it. They can inspect any product they want. They can ask for the product. They can send it to a lab. They can pull it off a shelf and send it to a lab and ensure that what's on the label is what's in the bottle.
They approve every natural product number that's out there. It's a pre-market approval process. You don't get an NPN until you're cleared by Health Canada to put the product on the shelf, so everything should be known about it at that particular point in time. If somebody is acting as a bad actor, Health Canada can stop the sale, as I said, and they can even withdraw or remove the NPN that was granted in the first place.
Health Canada already has tremendous powers to keep Canadians safe.
Liberal
The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal
Thank you. You were 22 seconds over, so we'll go to Mr. Sawatzky for four minutes, please.
Liberal
Jake Sawatzky Liberal New Westminster—Burnaby—Maillardville, BC
Thank you very much, Mr. Calkins, for being here today.
I want to use my time to understand what problem this bill is trying to solve and also what protections we would be giving up in the process.
First, just to focus on something we've heard throughout this discussion about the risk associated with natural health products, some of the testimony we have heard has left the impression that these products are essentially risk-free—that because we're talking about vitamins and supplements rather than prescription drugs, the safety concerns are somehow theoretical or non-existent. In fact, we've had witnesses put on the record that there are no risks associated with some of these products, which is not accurate.
I absolutely recognize that natural health products are generally lower-risk products. They're not prescription pharmaceuticals, and I don't think anyone is suggesting that they should be regulated in the same way, but I do think that it's important for everyone to understand that lower risk does not mean no risk. We have Canadian examples of products that have been contaminated with lead and of labels that have not accurately reflected what was in the product, and people have experienced serious adverse reactions.
There is also the fact that risk doesn't come solely from something being wrong with the product itself. A product can be manufactured exactly as intended and still interact with another medication. On Monday, we were discussing the example of St. John's wort and the various interactions that can happen.
If we accept that natural health products can cause adverse reactions, can have clinically significant interactions with prescription medications and, like other products, can sometimes be contaminated, then why would we want fewer tools available to protect Canadians when risks are identified after those products are already on the market?
Conservative
Blaine Calkins Conservative Ponoka—Didsbury, AB
Other than recall, tell me what new powers you're actually granting Health Canada. What you're doing is granting Health Canada the ability to create more onerous regulations and costly bureaucratic steps in the process. You're not actually adding anything that they didn't already have as powers in the first place.
Any Canadian can go out and harvest St. John's wort and go home and make tea with it if they want to. You can just pick this stuff. You can go out and harvest some. The notion that we need to treat food as medicine is noble in the sense that we want to have healthy diets and we want to have good nutrition, but to suggest that we need to have a natural product number or a drug identification number on every natural health product and every piece of food.... That's the natural flow of where your logic goes, Mr. Sawatzky.
The industry isn't saying it doesn't want regulation. It's just saying that the juice isn't worth the squeeze.
When Mr. Buckley was here, he said that your chances of having one of these negative interactions are lower than your chances of being struck by lightning. Deloitte did an audit of the Health Canada claims used to initially put forward these proposed changes in power that they claimed that they needed, and the report debunked virtually every one of the claims that Health Canada made.
Have you had a chance to read that Deloitte report, Mr. Sawatzky?
Liberal
Jake Sawatzky Liberal New Westminster—Burnaby—Maillardville, BC
Thank you, Mr. Calkins. I'd like to ask another question here.
Liberal
Jake Sawatzky Liberal New Westminster—Burnaby—Maillardville, BC
Do you think the government should have the power to stop the actions of non-compliant companies if there is an immediate risk to human health, yes or no?
Conservative
Blaine Calkins Conservative Ponoka—Didsbury, AB
Health Canada has had that ability even prior to Bill C-47. This was back in 2023. They can stop the sale. They can seize the product. They can revoke a site licence for a manufacturer, a packager and labeller, or an importer. They can mandate a label change if there's a problem. They can inspect any of the sites and locations for good manufacturing practices at any time. They can inspect any product that they want at any time, and they can revoke a natural product number if they want to.
What more powers do you think they need, Mr. Sawatzky? That seems like a lot of power to me.
I frankly feel completely safe when I go into a natural product store or a health food store and buy healthy food or a jar of vitamins off the shelf. Just as it is with medication, the reality is that the usual adverse reactions have nothing to do with the contents in the bottle. They occur because the users are not using the product as directed. It's the same problem. That's not going to be fixed by these powers, Mr. Sawatzky.
Liberal
The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal
Thank you very much. That was 18 seconds over.
We'll go to Madame Gaudreau for two minutes.
Marie-Hélène Gaudreau Bloc Laurentides—Labelle, QC
Oh, I get bonus time.
I want to follow up on the amendments and my previous question.
If I understand correctly, all the parties had come to a consensus on the previous bill in the last Parliament. You knew that from the get-go. You knew that the minister needed to keep their recall power. Admittedly, it's a last resort, even though there is currently a firewall. Why didn't you include that in the bill from the start?
Conservative
Blaine Calkins Conservative Ponoka—Didsbury, AB
I don't know how I can be more clear. I was satisfied in the last Parliament, which was a minority Parliament, and there wasn't consensus at the table in the last minority Parliament. As a matter of fact, it was the NDP, the Bloc Québécois and the Conservatives who basically supported Bill C-368. The Liberal government of the day and the Liberal MPs of the day were all adamantly against Bill C-368, which seems to be their posture today, even though they all voted in favour of it at second reading in the House of Commons. It's an interesting change in tactic.
I believe it was the Bloc Québécois amendment on recall that was accepted. I'd have to go back to review. I was satisfied with allowing somebody here at this table to come up with that solution. We would have that debate. We're prepared to have that debate.
Again, as I said, the concern from the industry is that it does not want to be enveloped in the web of Vanessa's Law. Vanessa's Law was a bill brought forward by my former colleague, Mr. Young. I support Vanessa's Law, but it's about drugs—not natural health products. I'm glad that we have a chance for the Bloc Québécois to move an amendment.
Liberal
The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal
Thank you very much, Madame Gaudreau.
Thank you very much, Mr. Calkins. Your time is up now, so we will go to the next panel. Thank you for appearing.
I'm going to suspend to make time for the panellists to take their seats.