Thank you.
I'm a clinical psychologist and a scientist. I began my career in 1986 at B.C.'s Riverview Hospital during deinstitutionalization. Since 1996, I've helped design and evaluate federal, provincial and territorial initiatives to prevent and treat addiction.
I'm today asking the Government of Canada to build on federal work that anticipated today's crisis and charted a path out of it. That includes the Senate's landmark report, “Out of the shadows at last”, federal investments in collaborative care, and drug treatment courts, as well as the “At Home/Chez Soi” trials, the world's largest randomized trials on homelessness, addiction and public safety. In the trials in Vancouver, recovery-oriented housing cut criminal convictions by 71% and halved the medical emergencies at no greater cost than leaving people homeless.
B.C. has been in a declared public health emergency over drug poisoning for a decade, and more than 18,000 British Columbians have died. There are only two ways out of any public health crisis: stop new cases and treat existing ones. B.C. should by now lead the world in both. Instead, the province adopted policies that were predicted to escalate harm, and harm to public safety, encampments, businesses, families and indigenous communities escalated.
In my view, this happened because the lessons Canadians had already paid for were set aside and because policy was made without adequate safeguards against conflicts of interest. I will offer four examples, each with a question.
First, in 2020, a year after B.C.'s provincial health officer called for decriminalization and safe supply, four of the policy's most prominent proponents announced companies in the same field: a former provincial health officer, a former executive director of the BC Centre for Disease Control, and two leaders of B.C.'s HIV/AIDS research community. The former executive director's company dispensed opioids from vending machines and received at least $4.5 million in federal funding. I am not alleging that any of this was illegal. That's the problem. What federal rules govern senior officials who shape a policy and then build businesses around it?
Second, these policies were never meaningfully evaluated. B.C.'s Auditor General found deficiencies in target setting, evaluation and public reporting on prescribed safer supply. One week after I briefed senior B.C. officials on federally funded research on recovery, the province ordered my university to destroy our entire research database, including data for an approved and funded study of drug-related deaths. Why was the evidence that could have evaluated these policies destroyed rather than used?
Third, federal granting agencies have provided millions of dollars to the BC Centre on Substance Use, the leading academic advocate of safe supply. The centre also receives pharmaceutical industry funding, and the amounts are not publicly disclosed. Should Canadians not know who funds the research that shapes their drug policy?
Fourth, researchers affiliated with that same centre designed an evaluation of the Drug User Liberation Front, the operators of which have since been found guilty of drug trafficking. On July 29, 2022, Health Canada wrote to refuse DULF's exemption request and warned that the model would violate federal law. According to the researchers' own publications, data collection began four days later. When DULF later challenged the federal government under the charter, the judge noted, “Of marked significance, the Crown called no evidence, expert or otherwise, to challenge any of the evidence called by the applicants”. What oversight applies when publicly funded research proceeds after a federal refusal, and why did the Crown call no evidence?
Ending this crisis requires a federal vision of prevention and recovery with meaningful metrics to evaluate progress. It requires mandatory disclosure of pharmaceutical payments to researchers, clinicians and patient groups; conflict of interest rules that cover the move from public office to private enterprise; federally funded research that complies with federal law; and a Crown that defends the public interest in court. It requires the community-based, recovery-oriented care that was promised as a replacement for institutions, care that serves patients and communities together rather than pitting them against one another.
Thank you.
