Evidence of meeting #41 for Health in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was patients.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Devin Schellenberg  Senior Executive Medical Director, Radiation Therapy and Medical Programs, BC Cancer
Housty  Vice President, Quality, Chief Nursing and Allied Health Officer, First Nations Health Authority
Mooder  Director, Provincial Clinical Innovation, Office of the Chief Nursing and Allied Health Officer, First Nations Health Authority
Sarah Giles  President, Rural Generalist Physician, Society of Rural Physicians of Canada
Carson  Chief Executive Officer, Breast Cancer Canada
Topham  Director, Advocacy and Communications, Canadian Association of Medical Radiation Technologists
Alison Harris  President, Canadian Association of Radiologists

11:25 a.m.

President, Rural Generalist Physician, Society of Rural Physicians of Canada

Dr. Sarah Giles

We have a radiologist who works nine to five, Monday to Friday. On off-hours, a group out of Toronto reads virtually for us.

11:25 a.m.

Conservative

Burton Bailey Conservative Red Deer, AB

I know you talked about Joe a little bit, but right now, for rural patients and urban patients, the national wait times are 84 days for MRIs and 66 days for CTs. What is the existing system not providing? I know you said that 24-hour service might increase it. Are there any other things that would help speed up these wait times?

It will have to be a very short answer.

11:30 a.m.

President, Rural Generalist Physician, Society of Rural Physicians of Canada

Dr. Sarah Giles

One thing would be centralized booking, as I said, to maximize triage efficiencies and to give patients the choice of where they want to go. Many patients would be willing to drive several hundred kilometres to get a scan faster.

11:30 a.m.

Conservative

Burton Bailey Conservative Red Deer, AB

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal

We'll go to Dr. Jaczek for six minutes.

Helena Jaczek Liberal Markham—Stouffville, ON

Thank you so much, Mr. Chair.

Thank you to all of our witnesses.

My first question is for Dr. Schellenberg.

Towards the end of your presentation, you talked about specific areas where the federal government could assist in terms of diagnostic-imaging capacity. I think we need to bear in mind, of course, that the delivery of health care is the responsibility of provinces and territories. We know that our Minister of Health, Marjorie Michel, is working very earnestly in terms of the Canada health transfers and working together agreements. Could you just expand again a little bit on what else the federal government in particular could do?

November 2nd, 2026 / 11:30 a.m.

Senior Executive Medical Director, Radiation Therapy and Medical Programs, BC Cancer

Dr. Devin Schellenberg

Thank you.

For us, there are a couple of issues. All three of us at this meeting have talked about HHR in different formats, and I think that is where the federal government could help, either with bursaries or—with regard to Dr. Giles, I think—with the return of service agreements with rural physicians. Getting people to train outside their home communities is a necessity, but they need to come back to their home communities or to rural communities. That's outside of cancer care, but I definitely see the expansion of slots for both medical professions in radiology—the people running the ultrasounds and running the CT scans—and the physicians reading those as a wonderful investment in terms of giving good jobs to Canadians.

I think the other aspect is....

I'm sorry. I'll let you speak.

Helena Jaczek Liberal Markham—Stouffville, ON

Carry on. I'm really interested in this aspect.

11:30 a.m.

Senior Executive Medical Director, Radiation Therapy and Medical Programs, BC Cancer

Dr. Devin Schellenberg

The other aspect is infrastructure. I feel that medical infrastructure is important infrastructure for Canada, and we lag behind in terms of the number of PET scans we have across various provinces outside Quebec, and also with CT and MRI. As our population ages and as we grow as a country, having that kind of infrastructure is very important. It's almost as important as roads and bridges. As Dr. Giles said, if we don't have that infrastructure, someone has to take three bridges just to get to the nearest CT scan.

Helena Jaczek Liberal Markham—Stouffville, ON

I concur. The only issue is that, in many cases, federal ministers of health have tried to connect the transfer payments to the provinces with specific areas—in this case, it might be medical technology—and this hasn't always actually resulted in those areas being concentrated on by the provinces and territories. There's been quite a dilemma in terms of that. However, hopefully they would agree when it comes to diagnostic-imaging capacity.

Now, very much like MP Bailey, I think we've been quite astonished by the increase in the number of scans being done across the country. We have some statistics. In the last 15 years, the number of scans has doubled. Our population clearly hasn't doubled. You specifically mentioned staging cancer and the requirement for far more frequent scans, and I can see that this would be part of the reason that we're seeing so many more scans in general.

However, we've also heard that there are private clinics doing whole-body MRIs for, primarily, reassurance of the patient, presumably. You're with BC Cancer, but are you aware of anyone studying whether some of these scans are, in fact, medically necessary? Are there any statistics related to this that you're aware of?

11:30 a.m.

Senior Executive Medical Director, Radiation Therapy and Medical Programs, BC Cancer

Dr. Devin Schellenberg

No. I don't know; if you're speaking about private clinics, I think the private clinics, at least in B.C., are often doing medically reasonable scans for people who want a scan earlier than they can get in the public system. I don't think a lot of people are just getting scans for reassurance purposes. Unfortunately, I think they're serving a need that a patient perceives is not being met in the public system. I think that's very unfortunate.

Helena Jaczek Liberal Markham—Stouffville, ON

I think it would be an interesting area of study by somebody.

Dr. Giles, I was really impressed that you were able to get the equipment you needed in Kenora. You've been very clear on the cost avoidance in terms of travel, and even the use of paramedic services in transportation, etc. Now that you have the scan you need, I'm extremely interested in the whole issue of personnel required to operate, to interpret and so on. You alluded to the remote staffing use of AI. Could you expand a little bit on how that is being operationalized?

11:35 a.m.

President, Rural Generalist Physician, Society of Rural Physicians of Canada

Dr. Sarah Giles

Thank you very much.

Our fabulous community and our summer guests who come from Winnipeg as our cottagers raised $8 million to bring an MRI to Kenora. They must be commended. Local people went and got training to be able to run the MRI. In Kenora they're mostly young women, so we do run into some difficulty sometimes when people have to go on maternity leave or miss for other reasons.

Most of our MRIs are read in town by our radiologists during the day. Some of the more specialized scans are read by others at times. We don't currently have any AI, that I'm aware of, reading our MRI scans. We have AI helping us in the ER. It looks at our musculoskeletal images. I had a gentleman, for instance, who fell off a ladder and hurt his foot. I looked at it and thought, “Oh, that calcaneus doesn't look good.” It agreed with me. We were both on the same page. But sometimes AI and I will have a difference of opinion. That causes you to take another look. It's not perfect, but I'm not perfect either. It's a double-check that is helpful.

We do know that there's technology out there to read—

The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal

Thank you very much. We have gone way over time.

Next is Madame Gaudreau.

Madame Gaudreau, you have six minutes.

Marie-Hélène Gaudreau Bloc Laurentides—Labelle, QC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Thank you, witnesses.

You know, health is precious. Obviously, it is entirely legitimate to raise questions about health care. However, I must be clear: the organization and delivery of health care services are the responsibility of the provinces.

Here, we are talking about delivery. My aim, of course, is to ensure that the federal government does its job and that the provinces can do what they do best: manage magnetic resonance imaging, or MRI, particularly in Quebec. This is invaluable. There is even a foundation that has been set up in a small town to acquire an MRI scanner, because more than 20,000 people have to drive two hours to access services.

In 2026‑27, the budget of Quebec's Ministry of Health, Prevention and Seniors stands at around $60 billion. However, Quebec's total program expenditure amounts to approximately $134 billion. This means that 45% of Quebec's program expenditure goes towards health and social services.

The federal government, for its part, is responsible for providing the necessary funding to the provinces—the so‑called health transfers—for ensuring compliance with the Canada Health Act, for regulating medicines and medical devices, for supporting research and innovation, for taking action on public health—as we have seen in recent years—and for providing certain services to populations under its direct jurisdiction.

I met with the minister—not to say “our minister”—who was the first to say that, given the fine line involved, it is important to ensure that efforts are maximized.

So, I would like to ask you, honourable witnesses: if Ottawa wishes to invest in MRI, why not channel funds down to the provinces rather than managing or setting up new programs? The provinces often have different criteria and different administrative structures. Should Ottawa provide the provinces with what they need?

You may take turns to reply.

The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal

We'll go to Dr. Mooder, then Mr. Gary Housty, Dr. Giles and Dr. Schellenberg, in that order.

Go ahead, please, Dr. Mooder.

11:40 a.m.

Director, Provincial Clinical Innovation, Office of the Chief Nursing and Allied Health Officer, First Nations Health Authority

Karen Mooder

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

I'll preface my comments by saying that I don't know if I'm entirely qualified to comment on this question. It's such an important one.

There is a critical role for the federal government. It could bring all the provinces and territories along in a coherent strategy for health, given that it is responsible for the transfer of health funding to each province and territory. However, it is up to the provinces and territories to determine how they are going to best design services when using those funds to their fullest potential. One of the things the Truth and Reconciliation Commission upheld was the importance of the federal government in ensuring that provinces and territories are aligned with the calls to action.

In terms of B.C.'s position, despite DRIPA and commitments made to the Truth and Reconciliation Commission's calls to action, we still aren't seeing profound action to lift up those principles of reconciliation when it comes to health service delivery.

I'll end my comments there and pass it to my colleague Gary.

11:40 a.m.

Vice President, Quality, Chief Nursing and Allied Health Officer, First Nations Health Authority

Gary Housty

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

What I was reflecting on while listening to the question—as well as to my colleagues' presentations and questions— was the work of the First Nations Health Authority. The core mandate is to improve health outcomes for B.C. first nations. The challenges our regional partners have in the province—I heard Dr. Schellenberg share those, as did Dr. Giles, nationally—are compounded when we send our community members to urban centres for diagnostic services. There's a double challenge encountered.

In terms of a rural and remote lens, the first nations population in B.C. is the second-largest, after Ontario's. That's from census 2021. In the geography of British Columbia, these communities are situated remotely and quite far from urban centres, as we've been describing. Often, clients have to travel up to 800 kilometres to get to an urban site and to an X-ray, an MRI or a CT scanner.

The one challenge I would add is that, in our remote sites, we often call nursing stations “outpost nursing stations”, because—

The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal

Thank you very much, Mr. Housty. The six minutes are up.

Because we went about 30 seconds over on the Liberal side, I'm going to give 30 seconds to the Conservative side and to the Bloc. I'll give Dr. Giles and Dr. Schellenberg 15 seconds each.

Please go ahead.

11:40 a.m.

President, Rural Generalist Physician, Society of Rural Physicians of Canada

Dr. Sarah Giles

Very quickly, the federal government has a responsibility to first nations and Inuit health, but this has traditionally been massively underfunded. They could, for instance, grant a one-time catch-up for infrastructure through a massive investment in this portfolio.

The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal

Thank you.

Dr. Schellenberg.

11:45 a.m.

Senior Executive Medical Director, Radiation Therapy and Medical Programs, BC Cancer

Dr. Devin Schellenberg

I feel underqualified to answer this question.

Targeted funding might be an option. Certainly, try to use the MRIs and CT scans more on a 24-hour basis. Target funding to rural communities. Mobile CTs could, as Dr. Giles alluded to, help indigenous and rural communities.

The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal

Thank you.

We'll go to Dr. Strauss for five minutes and 30 seconds.

11:45 a.m.

Conservative

Matt Strauss Conservative Kitchener South—Hespeler, ON

Thank you, Chair.

Dr. Schellenberg, I was really interested in your testimony about this seven-day benchmark that exists for priority cancer scans and how it takes 43 days to get 90% of such scans done. Obviously, the benchmark is not being met at all.

I was also very interested when you said that hospitals are partnering with private clinics, but that sometimes it seems that patients are partnering with private clinics without the hospitals. As you were giving that testimony, I put “private MRI” into Google Maps. I was searching in Vancouver. I found 20 clinics immediately. I clicked on one called “Priority MRI”. It's offering to do my brain MRI at 3T for $750 to $850.

Could you walk me through how one of your patients at a Surrey cancer clinic would decide to go to Priority MRI or one of these other private clinics to get their MRI done? Do you have to give them the recommendation? How does that conversation go? Do you inform them that it's going to take up to 43 days to get their urgent cancer screen done? I'm wondering about the human aspect on the patient side and how that goes.

11:45 a.m.

Senior Executive Medical Director, Radiation Therapy and Medical Programs, BC Cancer

Dr. Devin Schellenberg

I want to clarify one thing before I go forward.

The stats I quoted were not for cancer. These are general stats for CT scans. We don't have stats for cancer-specific wait times for a CT or an MRI. We don't have that sublevel of accuracy. This is just a general diagnostic scan, coded as to be done within seven days, that is taking 43 days to do 90%, as you alluded to.

I treat lung cancer. I treat gastrointestinal cancer. The cancers I treat grow fairly rapidly, so my patients need to be prioritized. I am not asking them to go privately. I am advocating for them in my local health authority. I do have patients, particularly at scan. I don't have patients getting private MRIs.

I hope your brain is perfectly fine and you don't need one. I would not advocate that you go that way either. I'm advocating, all that I can, within the public system.

Occasionally, in my experience, when patients feel that the wait for a PET scan is long, then they do seek out the private PET institution and go there directly. Basically, if it comes up, I will tell them where it is, but as you say, there's Google Search and they know before I even inform them of what is out there in terms of options.