Evidence of meeting #41 for Health in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was patients.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Devin Schellenberg  Senior Executive Medical Director, Radiation Therapy and Medical Programs, BC Cancer
Housty  Vice President, Quality, Chief Nursing and Allied Health Officer, First Nations Health Authority
Mooder  Director, Provincial Clinical Innovation, Office of the Chief Nursing and Allied Health Officer, First Nations Health Authority
Sarah Giles  President, Rural Generalist Physician, Society of Rural Physicians of Canada
Carson  Chief Executive Officer, Breast Cancer Canada
Topham  Director, Advocacy and Communications, Canadian Association of Medical Radiation Technologists
Alison Harris  President, Canadian Association of Radiologists

Marie-Hélène Gaudreau Bloc Laurentides—Labelle, QC

As I understand it, we really ought to focus on MRI services for first nations and not on anything else. For the other provinces, there are hospital centres.

So, there you have it. I hope that the next witnesses will provide us with statistics, information on innovation and research, and solutions to ensure accessibility for first nations, but not on the provision of services in our hospitals.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal

Thank you, Madame Gaudreau. The time is up.

We'll go to Dr. Strauss for three minutes and then to Madam Chi for three minutes.

Please go ahead, Dr. Strauss, for three minutes.

11:55 a.m.

Conservative

Matt Strauss Conservative Kitchener South—Hespeler, ON

I'm just returning to Dr. Schellenberg.

I think you've dropped a bombshell here. If I'm a cancer patient in Surrey, British Columbia, and you've asked for me to have a PET scan, but the health authority can't do it in time, I go and pay out of pocket for it. The whole point of the Canada Health Act is that if I've had to do that, the provincial system is supposed to reimburse me because I've paid out of pocket for a medically necessary cancer scan, or the federal health minister is supposed to claw back that funding from the provincial government.

Are you aware that this clawback is happening? You're describing that this happens fairly commonly. Are you aware that this clawback or any part of that procedure, which is the whole basis of the Canada Health Act, as far as I'm aware, is occurring?

Noon

Senior Executive Medical Director, Radiation Therapy and Medical Programs, BC Cancer

Dr. Devin Schellenberg

Can you ask that question again?

Noon

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal

I'll stop the watch. Go ahead, Dr. Strauss.

Noon

Conservative

Matt Strauss Conservative Kitchener South—Hespeler, ON

My understanding of the way the whole Canada Health Act works is if my provincial health coverage plan is not paying for medically necessary, insured services, which includes diagnostic imaging, then if I'm having to pay out of pocket for that because my provincial health authority is not paying for it, the federal health minister is supposed to write a letter to the province and claw back the Canada health transfer.

Noon

Senior Executive Medical Director, Radiation Therapy and Medical Programs, BC Cancer

Dr. Devin Schellenberg

I think the Canada Health Act is paying for medically necessary services. It's just not paying for it at a time point when the patient desires it. Sometimes that's because the patient wants a thing done now—

Noon

Conservative

Matt Strauss Conservative Kitchener South—Hespeler, ON

Can I interrupt you right there? You started your testimony by saying there's a seven-day benchmark, and this is frequently not being met.

Noon

Senior Executive Medical Director, Radiation Therapy and Medical Programs, BC Cancer

Dr. Devin Schellenberg

Yes, it is frequently.... I agree with you there.

Matt Strauss Conservative Kitchener South—Hespeler, ON

Okay, so it's—

Noon

Senior Executive Medical Director, Radiation Therapy and Medical Programs, BC Cancer

Dr. Devin Schellenberg

We are trying to deliver medical care, as best we have, with the scans that we have. We cannot get all people through within seven days. I fully acknowledge that.

Noon

Conservative

Matt Strauss Conservative Kitchener South—Hespeler, ON

Okay. I'm not putting it on you. I'm saying that this is a clear violation of the Canada Health Act, and perhaps the Liberals will want to bring a motion to this effect. I'm just saying it's a bombshell. This is not how the health system is supposed to be doing medically necessary scans, to my understanding of the Canada Health Act and the health care system that we all operate in.

Turning quickly to Dr. Giles, you said something really interesting about a $1-million estimate on savings. Can you just describe that for me again? You went quite quickly.

Noon

President, Rural Generalist Physician, Society of Rural Physicians of Canada

Dr. Sarah Giles

Sure. For patients who need to drive the 1,000 kilometres to Thunder Bay and back for an MRI, they're eligible for a travel grant of up to $800. Also, there's some money available if they were to go to Winnipeg to have the MRI there. We looked at the cost savings from not having those travel grants or having smaller ones for shorter distances.

Noon

Conservative

Matt Strauss Conservative Kitchener South—Hespeler, ON

Why was it on you to do this analysis, or who did this analysis?

Noon

President, Rural Generalist Physician, Society of Rural Physicians of Canada

Dr. Sarah Giles

It wasn't on me. I was able to tap into our hospital's analysis and ask them what information they had that showed that our MRI was helpful to the greater community.

Noon

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal

Thank you very much, Dr. Strauss.

We will go to Madam Chi for three minutes.

Please, go ahead.

Noon

Liberal

Maggie Chi Liberal Don Valley North, ON

Thank you, Chair.

Thank you to all the witnesses for presenting to committee today.

My first question is to Dr. Giles.

First of all, thank you. The whole community of rural physicians, I think, really represents jacks of all trades, for lack of better words. You take on responsibilities in a remote area with limited resources, but you somehow make it work.

Dr. Giles, you mentioned the idea of a central booking system. If you can, help us explore that idea a little more, especially now that we are working with provinces and territories on opening up some of the data pieces, trying to enhance interoperability. Would that help, or what additional measures would be helpful in that sense?

Noon

President, Rural Generalist Physician, Society of Rural Physicians of Canada

Dr. Sarah Giles

Sure. Let's say we have a region where there are four different CT scans. In the past, what we used to see is that a patient would see their doctor, and they would just do a requisition to the local one. Then the patient would come back and say, “Listen, they're saying it's a three-month wait. Can you refer me to another one, and we'll see which one we get first?”, which tends to make waiting lists look longer than they actually are. Then each radiologist is having to duplicate the work of the other by triaging it.

If you had a centralized booking—all four communities used the same booking office—and a patient said, “Listen, I'll drive to any of them, regardless of distance,” or they said, “I don't drive. I'm only interested in the one that's closest to me,” which allows patients to show their preference, this would allow everybody to be triaged under the same lens and prevent duplication through the system.

Maggie Chi Liberal Don Valley North, ON

Thank you so much.

The other point that really was interesting to me is on the innovation front. I think rural physicians had to learn on the spot how to operate some point-of-care devices. Innovation, we do hear, is one of the measures that help with opening up access. I think Dr. Mooder also alluded to that fact.

I want to see from your perspective, either from Dr. Giles' rural and remote perspective or from Dr. Mooder, if there are any additional things that you want to add on that topic.

12:05 p.m.

President, Rural Generalist Physician, Society of Rural Physicians of Canada

Dr. Sarah Giles

For instance, I was talking about remote ultrasound technology. Rather than flying the technologist to a bunch of different communities, you have, for lack of a better word, a robot in a northern community, and the ultrasonographer in the south is holding a probe, moving it through the planes, which the robot in a distant community is doing as well. It provides images that are of great quality without needing the sonographer to travel. For instance, they might do a half day in one community and a half day in the other.

In Saskatchewan, they're doing this with prenatals, and I believe they're also doing some echocardiograms. It's really an interesting way to go about the technology shortage and collapse the distance while not hurting image capture.

The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal

Thank you.

The time is up, though I will give a few seconds to the First Nations Health Authority.

12:05 p.m.

Vice President, Quality, Chief Nursing and Allied Health Officer, First Nations Health Authority

Gary Housty

I was just going to share a couple of words around the opportunity around innovation, similar to Dr. Giles. The question that we're getting on this panel is about what Ottawa can do to continue to transform the system to improve health outcomes.

When I think about remote communities, that is where we've started some innovation, and our opportunity is to scale it.

Dr. Giles did talk a little bit about a Cree nation, as well, with X-ray systems. We want to scale that across British Columbia, in remote first nations communities. The opportunity is to change the legislation with the B.C. College of Nurses and Midwives so that registered nurses can also have that opportunity to be handlers and to take these X-rays. That's the opportunity for us to move the dial and to improve health outcomes as well.

The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal

Thank you very much.

On behalf of the committee members, I would love to thank the witnesses. I'll start with my hometown.

Thank you, Dr. Schellenberg, Dr. Mooder, Vice-President Gary Housty and, last but not least, Dr. Giles. Thank you very much for your valuable input.

With that, I'll suspend the meeting, for the next witnesses to take the stage.

The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal

I would like to call the meeting back to order.

On behalf of the committee members, I would love to welcome our witnesses.

We have with us, from Breast Cancer Canada, the CEO, Ms. Kimberly Carson; from the Canadian Association of Medical Radiation Technologists, Mr. Christopher Topham; and from the Canadian Association of Radiologists, Dr. Alison Harris.

Welcome to the committee.

I would like to first make a few comments for the witnesses.

Please wait until I recognize you. I have leeway here. Once the honourable member is asking questions, you can keep eye contact with the honourable member.

Also, as soon as I raise my hand, I would like you to wrap up and stop speaking at the end of the five- or six-minute round—whatever I've allocated for the members—which means that's the end of that particular round.

Please make sure that you have your mic on, because this is bilingual in both official languages. French and English run simultaneously.

Honourable members, please ask the questions by name and have your stopwatch running. Last time, Mr. Bailey did an excellent job, because he knew that were near the end of the time and he asked the witness for a short answer. That way, I don't have to interrupt when you are speaking. Please, let's try to work together to make sure that we finish the rounds on time.

With that, I will give five minutes for the opening remarks to all three witnesses.

We will start with Ms. Carson for five minutes, please.

Kimberly Carson Chief Executive Officer, Breast Cancer Canada

Thank you very much, Mr. Chair, and thank you to the members of the committee for having me here today.

I am Kimberly Carson. I'm the CEO of Breast Cancer Canada. It's the only national breast cancer organization focused on research, advocacy and education.

This year, as you may know, over 32,000 women will be diagnosed with breast cancer. Over 5,400 of them are going to die from this disease, which leaves us at about 15 women per day in this country. The numbers are still one in eight, and we have not yet seen a huge improvement on the number of deaths, compared to that one in eight.

For almost every one of those, the journey starts with screening and mammography. It's still our first line of defence for this disease. Those images are so important because they tell us where that woman is in the journey, how early on they are, whether or not they're going to need surgery, where their staging is, how accurate it is and how it's going to be treated. It's still very important as our first line of defence in this disease.

I want to leave you with something today. For women with breast cancer, it's not even about the wait to have the screening. It's about the wait through the entire system and what that actually means. It's from the screening and the diagnostics right straight through to the biopsy and the pathology reading. All of these pieces add to the delay and the wait time for a woman. Each one of them compounds the amount of time it takes for a woman to get her diagnosis and start her treatment.

The national data looks like this. The target is that 90% of women should receive a biopsy within seven weeks of that initial abnormal screening. Based on 2020 data from CPAC, the Canadian Partnership Against Cancer—this is the most up-to-date data, which is also a bit of a problem—the only province that's doing it is Alberta. It's a little bit of a problem when we're looking at that entire pathway and that entire screening pathway.

The question becomes, how does Alberta do it? How do we use the best practices here in Canada? Alberta has done it through a centralized diagnostic lab system. It's working. On top of that, we have an eastern Ontario network of 16 hospitals right here in the national capital region that are working together. Again, we're getting the results faster, so there are some Canadian ways that are able to do some of this stuff.

The Canadian Association of Radiologists, which is going to speak today, is saying that one-third of our equipment in Canada is really dated—it's over 10 years old—making that even more difficult to deal with when we're trying to get women through these systems. Then the systems don't talk to each other.

These are all things that we've spoken about, but the screening from mammography really matters. Women are able now to self-refer at the age of 40 in most provinces. We're still asking for the national guidelines to be changed to 40—they have yet to be lowered to the age of 40—to help us work through this system with women, because we know that the sooner we catch it, the better the outcomes.

There are a few things I think we can do at the federal level.

The first is to measure the whole patient journey. Breast Cancer Canada has developed a PROgress Tracker, which tracks the patient's journey from beginning to end. We track them for 10 years. We can certainly scale that up nationally across this country to help with the data and give more timely data. It's the data from patients. It's a self-referred study that patients can enter anywhere and anytime. I'm pleased to say that right now, after running it for a couple of years, we have every province and territory represented in our database. However, it certainly needs to be scaled.

Secondly, we obviously need to invest in more equipment.

Third, we need more innovation. We're looking at new innovation that's coming. We have blood tests and breath tests coming, which may help reduce the burden on the system. If we can do a blood test or a breath test up front and know that a woman needs a mammogram more frequently, or if we can use AI to predict it, then do we actually have to send as many women for mammograms as frequently? I think there's going to be more technology.

Then, obviously, we're looking for the age to be lowered to 40.