Thank you, Madam Chair, for the opportunity to speak.
It wasn't my intention, but I happened to listen to yesterday's meeting and thought that I had some things to contribute and misunderstandings to correct. I have distributed notes, because I have quite a few things to explain about a very complicated system of education, training, licensure, certification, residencies, fellowships and the difference between various categories of physicians that we need badly in Canada.
My own story is that I attended McMaster University a long time ago, in the first class of their medical school. I stayed there for my training in internal medicine and hematology. I practised first in Calgary, but while I was there, several colleagues were going off to Saudi Arabia to a fabulous hospital. My wife and I and two young boys left for what we thought would be a year or two but turned out to be 15 years of a marvellous experience. I was the only hematologist in Saudi Arabia when I went. I had recruited 12 into the department by the time I left, and we were very busy with a program for the whole kingdom.
I returned to Canada in a quasi-administrative role in Kingston at the cancer centre there. I moved to Nova Scotia as the head of cancer programs in the province. I then moved to the Royal College, where I was the CEO for almost 15 years. Since I sort of retired in 2020, I have been building a medical school at Toronto Metropolitan University in Brampton on an interim dean basis. Then I will hand it over to Dr. Teresa Chan. I'm now working with the American Canadian School of Medicine, the only not-for-profit private medical school in the Caribbean.
Visa trainees are a particular interest of mine because, in 1978, when I was newly at King Faisal Specialist, the first four Saudi graduate physicians from King Saud University came to the hospital to ask about Canada and doing their training there. I told them what I could. They asked about Winnipeg, Toronto, Vancouver and other places. The first one actually turned out to take his training in Halifax. They liked it very much. They were treated very well, and many of their colleagues started following.
By 1990, there were literally dozens of Saudi trainees in Canada. That program then started a visa trainee program, which now has 1,100 Saudi physicians taking training at various stages in Canada. However, it's a misconception to think that those positions the Saudis are filling, if vacated, would provide spaces for Canadian students or those who are immigrating into Canada with an MD. These positions for visa trainees are extra and in excess of those provided through provincial funding, which is matched against what are the perceived needs in Canada.
If those 1,100 positions disappeared, we wouldn't actually have any new positions for other trainees, including Canadians studying abroad, unless the provincial government provided salary support for those positions. In which case, those visa trainee positions would disappear, because they're offered by the universities in terms of having excess capacity only. Currently, out of the 1,100 visa trainees in Canada, only about 120 are in entry-level positions. Twenty-five or so are in family medicine, but even there, they're in their second or third year of training, so, again, their absence or disappearance would not actually create some space.
I'll turn to the problem of our workforce. Our problem in respect of Canadians studying medicine in Canada is that we don't have enough medical schools. I participated, as I said, in opening a school in Brampton that took in 94 students this September and 105 resident positions in postgraduate training. That's only the 18th school.
In comparison, Saudi Arabia, which has the same population, has 38 medical schools. Many of them are private. I have a consulting position to help a new medical school start up in Saudi Arabia, and they're looking for their colleague physicians who did their training in Canada, because they're so highly regarded in that country.
Our problem for Canadians studying abroad in the Caribbean or Australia, as you heard yesterday, is that they can't or even don't apply for residency positions because they feel they won't get them.
That's not as true as it was 10 years ago. Provinces are making designated positions available, and in the match this year, something like 638 international medical graduates were given residency positions at the entry level.
It isn't quite the same problem as it was. Those who apply from outside Canada actually have an 80%-plus chance of getting a residency. The problem is, in the Caribbean, Canadian students—there are 3,500 around the world and about 1,200 to 1,500 in Caribbean medical schools—don't even apply because their schools give them clerkships in U.S. hospitals. The U.S. hospitals find them residencies nearby, because they want them to practise there, so they feed the U.S. hospitals with patients. In Canada, we don't tend to view patients as a revenue source. We see them as a cost and try to reduce the number, but not in the U.S.A.
Many of our Canadian students, who pay their own way to medical school, end up practising in the U.S. I think that's unfortunate. It could be reversed if we provided clinical clerkship positions in Canadian hospitals where those undergraduates would be able to find a clerkship and residency in Canada, because they would audition and create a network that would help them do that.
Thank you.
