Mr. Chair, I refer you to page 453 of Marleau and Montpetit, where it says:
An amendment is out of order procedurally, if... it is the direct negative of the main motion and would produce the same result as the defeat of the motion.
This refers to decisions of the House made on June 6, 1923, October 16, 1970, August 11, 1988, and October 29, 1991.
Mr. Chair, do you still maintain the same ruling?