Believe me, I do not believe that the Carter decision from Saskatchewan was very helpful in telling us what a community of interest was. As an electoral boundaries commissioner, I've found no guidance from that. Regarding which constituencies should get special treatment, if any are going to get special treatment, I really believe it's up to Parliament to decide that.
I was never elected to anything. All I was supposed to do was to work with the numbers and to try to take into account some idea of communities of interest. If Canadians want certain parts of Ontario, or certain parts of Newfoundland, to get special treatment, it should not be decided by one judge and two electoral boundary commissioners. You people should be deciding what those areas are.