This is the old notion that social policy and social justice are a zero-sum game. I could ask you--you cut the GST, which I support one hundred per cent--can you tell us how cutting the GST helped poor people? We know we did it to help poor people because low-income people pay a higher percentage of their income in the GST. It was a good policy. I support it.
A whole bunch of people will ask what other programs we could not do because we cut the GST. And our response, which I support one hundred per cent, has been if you help people in their day-to-day lives stay involved economically, there will be returns. If the people who stayed in the workforce, because they could afford to, invested in some home renovations, that generated jobs and return.
We're making the very same case here. We're saying that if people who now live below the poverty line--costing a huge amount to the welfare system and to the criminal justice system and to the health care system and to the prison system--are left where they are, the burden on the taxpayer will get larger over time. And demographics will make it worse.
Our proposition, with respect, is that we should cost out very carefully the net benefits of what has transpired with existing methods. That's why we're calling for a green paper from the government that points to the issues you're raising, which I think are very constructive, so we could take a look at the net benefit and the net return.
When the Minister of Finance brought in the WITB program, it had a cost. But it also had a huge benefit to the economy, in my judgment. When the minister brought in expansion to the employment insurance program, it had a cost but also a real benefit to the economy.
We're of the view that nothing in this report should go forward unless it produces a benefit to the economy. And we do not think we should be spending any more money.
