I don't want you speculate on it. I'm just wondering, in case law, how a section like this.... If I were to clip it and use it in the future, or if it were to be added to any other amendment before the committee.... Can we give people a right or a grant to citizenship and then say they don't have any of the benefits of citizenship? That's the way I read this: It would cause a person to have it but have none of the benefits of it.
“Citizenship by right or by grant” means something. You have the right to vote. You can stand for public office. You are expected, as a duty, to pay taxes. When old age security and the Canada pension plan were created, you paid into them. You have a right to those things you pay into. This would basically imply that you are a citizen but don't have any of those rights. Potentially, a section like this could be applied to any group of lost Canadians out there: They get the citizenship but don't have the benefit of it.
I'm wondering whether this is has ever been done before. The legal opinion of the Department of Justice Canada.... Is this even defensible? To me, it looks as if a judge would knock it down immediately. I don't see how you can give someone citizenship but say they have none of the benefits of citizenship.
Am I wrong?
