Evidence of meeting #43 for Citizenship and Immigration in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was employers.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Antoine Gagnon  Committee Researcher
Finch  Professor, Mount Royal University and Research Director, The Productivity Project, As an Individual
Chatoor  Director of Research and Strategic Foresight, Labour Market Information Council
Wagner  Managing Director, TalentLift Canada
Webb  Executive Director, Labour Market Information Council
Christidis  President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Nuclear Association
Khatib  Impact Director, Refugees, Northpine Foundation
Carmona  Director of Public Affairs, Ontario Chamber of Commerce
Singh Vig  Senior Manager of Policy, Ontario Chamber of Commerce

Amandeep Sodhi Liberal Brampton Centre, ON

Thank you.

Ms. Wagner, I will just go over to you. TalentLift connects Canadian employers with skilled refugees and displaced people through employment opportunities and immigration pathways. You believe this approach allows employers to address skills needs while giving people who have been displaced the opportunity to build their lives and their careers.

Can you share an example of how this model has helped a Canadian employer meet a workforce need while creating a meaningful opportunity for a skilled refugee and potentially their family as well?

4:15 p.m.

Managing Director, TalentLift Canada

Dana Wagner

There are so many examples. I'll highlight one where we partner with a national roofing manufacturer. They have facilities across Canada, so they were looking for different engineering and industrial mechanic skill sets for their plants. When I say “across Canada”, I mean primarily in B.C., Alberta and Ontario, all outside of major cities. They're in Ashcroft, B.C., for example, and Madoc, Ontario.

We supported them to hire more than 30 folks with engineering backgrounds who were displaced from Venezuela. About two-thirds of them have now arrived in Canada, and they're working across the country. These are folks who, in this case, have arrived with PR with their families and are in the Canadian workplace. I think that of everyone who's arrived, only one person is no longer working because of an unfortunate health issue. We have really strong retention. Employers are finding the candidates they need.

On some of the discussion around immediate workforce needs versus future needs of employers, I agree with what my colleagues have been saying. I think also surveying employers in terms of their future hiring intentions is a really excellent way to also get a temperature check on forthcoming needs that we wouldn't see currently in vacancies.

Amandeep Sodhi Liberal Brampton Centre, ON

Beautiful. Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Julie Dzerowicz

Thank you so much, Ms. Sodhi. That's perfect.

Mr. Deschênes now has the floor for two and a half minutes.

Alexis Deschênes Bloc Gaspésie—Les Îles-de-la-Madeleine—Listuguj, QC

Thank you very much, Madam Chair.

I have some questions for you, Ms. Wagner. I understand from your pilot project on economic mobility pathways that it aims to help facilitate the settlement in Canada of skilled workers from refugee communities around the world. However, we have carried out a study here on the possibility of distributing asylum seekers amongst the provinces.

Before looking abroad, is it current practice to check whether there are asylum seekers within Canada who have qualifications? Many do. We could try to match their presence in one province with the needs in another province. Is this being done?

4:15 p.m.

Managing Director, TalentLift Canada

Dana Wagner

I believe colleagues on the panel right after us will be speaking to this directly, but our organization does not do this. I don't believe that there's a broad, systemic way to do this currently, to match asylum seekers who are currently in Canada with other opportunities, apart from civil society undertaking those operations. Because we're working under economic immigration programs, we're essentially bound by the same requirements in terms of labour market testing, recruiting locally, showing efforts of posting jobs and trying to fill vacancies with local talent first before hiring internationally.

I will say that we have had examples where employers thought they needed to hire internationally. They've posted, and they've had local applicants. We were like, “Our job's done here. That's great.” The system is not perfect, but it is working generally across federal and provincial programs that have labour market tests.

Alexis Deschênes Bloc Gaspésie—Les Îles-de-la-Madeleine—Listuguj, QC

A project like the one you’ve been working on, but carried out within Canada—do you think that would be useful?

4:15 p.m.

Managing Director, TalentLift Canada

Dana Wagner

I do, yes, very much.

Alexis Deschênes Bloc Gaspésie—Les Îles-de-la-Madeleine—Listuguj, QC

What would that enable us to achieve?

4:15 p.m.

Managing Director, TalentLift Canada

Dana Wagner

It would hopefully provide visibility for those asylum seekers in terms of opportunities where their skills may be really needed. It would provide them with an opportunity to align their skill set with a well-paying job. If there were some type of infrastructure to support relocation and get them settled in a new community with the support of an employer, that would be an excellent model. We know people don't always land where their skill sets are immediately needed.

The Chair Liberal Julie Dzerowicz

Thank you, Ms. Wagner and Mr. Deschênes.

Mr. Menegakis now has the floor for five minutes.

Costas Menegakis Conservative Aurora—Oak Ridges—Richmond Hill, ON

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Thank you to our witnesses for appearing before us today.

I'd like to start with you, Mr. Chatoor.

Did the Liberal government ask the LMIC, prior to expanding these policy streams, to conduct an independent assessment on how the surge of temporary residents would impact domestic youth employment? You mentioned that, nationally, it's 13%. In the greater Toronto area, it's actually closer to 17% and maybe even higher in York region, where I'm from.

4:20 p.m.

Director of Research and Strategic Foresight, Labour Market Information Council

Ken Chatoor

LMIC is an arm's-length agency. We're funded by each of the provinces and territories, as well as by the federal government. We don't work directly with the political side of government.

4:20 p.m.

Conservative

Costas Menegakis Conservative Aurora—Oak Ridges—Richmond Hill, ON

The government does not ask you for any research or information, as such. Okay.

From a straightforward economic perspective, did the rapid increase in temporary immigration expand the labour supply in a way that lowered wage growth and reduced job availability for young Canadians available to work?

4:20 p.m.

Director of Research and Strategic Foresight, Labour Market Information Council

Ken Chatoor

I don't have that information directly in front of me, and I don't want to give you inaccurate information.

I believe some studies have done some economic analyses, looking at the rate of immigration and potential negative impacts on wages. I can look for those research reports and share them with you.

4:20 p.m.

Conservative

Costas Menegakis Conservative Aurora—Oak Ridges—Richmond Hill, ON

Thank you. If you could share them with us, it would be greatly appreciated.

I'll go to you, Dr. Finch, if I may.

Sir, based on your research on the collapse of entry-level employment, to what extent has the Liberal government's policy of letting large corporations exploit the temporary foreign worker program directly displaced young Canadians from their very first jobs?

4:20 p.m.

Professor, Mount Royal University and Research Director, The Productivity Project, As an Individual

David Finch

It's not a new thing. It's been happening over the last 30 years. What we have seen is the social contract between young people and employers dramatically change. Prior to 1990, large organizations were prepared to invest heavily in the training and development of young people. They played what I call that conversion function.

We've now seen a significant reduction. At this point, young people are in that precarious gig environment. If they're in a large organization, they get limited training and limited recognition of that training. Preparing young people to be successful is a much more challenging issue. It's really about supporting them as they transition to the workforce.

4:20 p.m.

Conservative

Costas Menegakis Conservative Aurora—Oak Ridges—Richmond Hill, ON

As you know, entry-level jobs pay modest wages. If we combine suppressed wages with Liberal-driven population growth that pushes housing and rent out of reach, isn't the government effectively pricing young Canadians out of their independence?

4:20 p.m.

Professor, Mount Royal University and Research Director, The Productivity Project, As an Individual

David Finch

One of the challenges, certainly, that young Canadians are facing today is lack of confidence in being given the same opportunities their parents had. I see this all the time. Look at the number of young people—I think it's a third of people under the age of 35—still living at home. That reflects some of those challenges, and it's not good for anyone.

We have to create opportunities, build confidence and build that agency earlier in the system.

4:20 p.m.

Conservative

Costas Menegakis Conservative Aurora—Oak Ridges—Richmond Hill, ON

When Liberal temporary foreign worker policies allow corporations to bypass local youth—bypass Canadians—for low-wage labour, what long-term damage is being done to an entire generation's career trajectory and earning potential?

4:20 p.m.

Professor, Mount Royal University and Research Director, The Productivity Project, As an Individual

David Finch

We all have to reflect on our first jobs. Our first jobs were not just jobs to make minimum wage. In fact, they allowed us to understand the workplace—how to work with peers and how to take constructive or maybe not-so-constructive feedback. They were part of an important transition into the labour market.

That's a challenge I've certainly seen my students have. They're walking out of a gymnasium where a thousand students are writing a multiple-choice exam. They're not prepared for their first job because they didn't have many of those same opportunities that were embedded in us as young people in Canada.

4:20 p.m.

Conservative

Costas Menegakis Conservative Aurora—Oak Ridges—Richmond Hill, ON

Thank you for that answer.

In a normal, healthy market, a labour shortage forces businesses to raise wages and invest in training young domestic workers. Has the Liberals' deliberate decision to flood the entry-level market with TFWs artificially suppressed Canadian youth wages and stripped employers of any incentive to train local talent?

4:20 p.m.

Professor, Mount Royal University and Research Director, The Productivity Project, As an Individual

David Finch

I can't comment on the data and the suppression of wages tied to immigrants, but I can say that a general trend we've seen over the last few decades is that, I believe, the employer is a critical part of our education system, and they need to take greater accountability. The supports need to be given to them to be more accountable to train their people to lift all the boats in the community.

They're disincentivized right now, because what it shows is that you hire a new graduate, and they're going to last about three years at that new employer. The employer asks, “Why would I train them if, by three years' time, they're going to be moving to my competitor?” We have this cycle that's emerged in the last 20 to 30 years where, in Canada, we've seen a decline in this commitment to training young people because we have such a fluid youth labour market.

The Chair Liberal Julie Dzerowicz

Thank you so much, Dr. Finch.

Thank you, Mr. Menegakis.

Our last five minutes go to Mr. Chang.

Your five minutes start now.

Wade Chang Liberal Burnaby Central, BC

Thank you, Chair.

Ms. Wagner, in your opening remarks, you mentioned that refugees bring incredible skills and professional experience; however, their economic contributions are often overlooked. Based on your experience, how can attracting skilled refugees help Canada build greater economic resilience and address our labour shortage issues?