Evidence of meeting #43 for Citizenship and Immigration in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was employers.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Antoine Gagnon  Committee Researcher
Finch  Professor, Mount Royal University and Research Director, The Productivity Project, As an Individual
Chatoor  Director of Research and Strategic Foresight, Labour Market Information Council
Wagner  Managing Director, TalentLift Canada
Webb  Executive Director, Labour Market Information Council
Christidis  President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Nuclear Association
Khatib  Impact Director, Refugees, Northpine Foundation
Carmona  Director of Public Affairs, Ontario Chamber of Commerce
Singh Vig  Senior Manager of Policy, Ontario Chamber of Commerce

The Chair Liberal Julie Dzerowicz

I call this meeting to order.

Good afternoon. Welcome to meeting number 43 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Citizenship and Immigration.

Today's meeting is televised and taking place in hybrid format.

Before I have the pleasure of introducing our first panel of guests, I want to alert members to this: Regarding the study of Canada's immigration system, version two of the draft report is expected to be distributed to members this Friday. This committee is scheduled to examine the draft report next Tuesday, November 3.

Mr. Deschênes, do you have a question?

Alexis Deschênes Bloc Gaspésie—Les Îles-de-la-Madeleine—Listuguj, QC

Yes, Madam Chair. I wanted to get a head start. Regarding the report on the distribution of asylum seekers, given that the legal no-objection notice has been received, can we also have a date for the first draft of this report?

The Chair Liberal Julie Dzerowicz

Do we have a date? Yes. The analyst has something to say.

Philippe Antoine Gagnon Committee Researcher

Thank you, Madam Chair.

The report on the distribution of asylum seekers will be in your hands on Wednesday, November 18, if all goes well.

The Chair Liberal Julie Dzerowicz

If there are no other questions.... I may have another announcement at the end of our meeting, but right now I'm anxious to get into this exciting conversation. We are currently studying attracting and empowering global talent to strengthen Canada's economy.

For the first panel, we have the following witnesses.

Online, as an individual, we have Dr. David Finch, professor, Mount Royal University and research director, the productivity project. From the Labour Market Information Council, we have Rebecca Webb, executive director, and Ken Chatoor, director of research and strategic foresight. From TalentLift Canada, we have Dana Wagner, managing director.

I extend a warm welcome to all of you. Thank you for being here with us today. We'll begin with five-minute introductions. Each organization will get five minutes, after which we'll proceed with rounds of questions.

Dr. David Finch, we'll begin with you.

David Finch Professor, Mount Royal University and Research Director, The Productivity Project, As an Individual

Thank you very much.

Good afternoon.

Madam Chair, vice-chairs and honourable members of the committee, my name is David Finch. I'm a professor at Mount Royal University and the research director of the productivity project.

This committee has been tasked with a critical question: How can Canada attract and empower global talent? We believe this question should be considered as part of a much larger labour market challenge: How can we unlock Canada's potential by recognizing its invisible talent?

Consider these numbers. Canada spends roughly $168 billion annually on education, training and workforce development, and 64% of Canadians between the ages of 25 and 64 have a post-secondary credential. This is 23% higher than the OECD average. However, in 2026, 71% of employers state they have difficulty finding the skills they're looking for, and a full one-third of new Canadians with post-secondary credentials are underemployed.

This is Canada's talent paradox. We develop talent, but much of it remains invisible. This matters because hiring is a risk management exercise. Employers lack verifiable, comparable evidence of a candidate's competencies. As a result, they're forced to rely on weak proxies such as academic credentials, references or prior employment. These signals may have value, but they don't verify what a candidate can do and they aren't comparable. This information asymmetry harms market efficiency.

To unlock its economic potential, Canada must build the infrastructure that makes human capital visible, verifiable, comparable and portable. Only then will the labour market be a true marketplace.

This starts by unlocking not only the invisible competencies of learners, but also the invisible learning pathways that underpin them. We all acquire knowledge and skills throughout our lives. Much of it is in communities and at the workplace, and a fraction of it is in a classroom. We recently completed an audit of Calgary's learning ecosystem and identified 30,000 unique programs being delivered in the city. Only 8% of those programs are leading to some form of certification and recognition. This is an opportunity for Canada.

Learning involves three dimensions: teaching, assessment and recognition. Canada's labour market ecosystem remains tethered to a 19th-century model of what's called “closed recognition”. Closed recognition integrates teaching, assessment and recognition as a single process. This was critical in the 19th century. It allowed policy-makers to scale public education to deliver universal literacy. Today, we argue that it does the opposite. Closed recognition throttles labour market efficiencies, suppresses innovation and negatively impacts Canada's productivity and global competitiveness.

We all remember the rise and fall of BlackBerry. BlackBerry failed not because of technology. It failed because it failed to recognize a paradigm shift. As it kept perfecting its BlackBerry, Apple and Google redefined the market through open innovation, unlocking the latent value of millions of innovators.

The global labour market is undergoing a similar paradigm shift. Open recognition will underpin this new paradigm. Open recognition decouples learning from assessment and recognition. Open recognition doesn't judge where or how a competency was developed, but rather focuses solely on making it visible, verifiable, comparable and portable.

In the 19th and 20th centuries, Canada unlocked its value by building shared infrastructure between the federal government, the provinces and other partners. These included railways, highways, seaways and energy corridors. To unlock its potential in the 21st century, Canada must build a shared labour market infrastructure, so our human capital—whether it be a young Canadian seeking their first job or a professional desiring to immigrate to Canada—is visible, verifiable, comparable and portable.

As per our brief, we recommend a three-pronged strategy to deliver this: Develop a national Canadian competency framework. Develop a Canadian labour market passport, and develop a Canadian labour market navigator.

Thank you. I look forward to your questions.

The Chair Liberal Julie Dzerowicz

Thank you so much, Dr. Finch.

Next, we'll go to the Labour Market Information Council.

Who would like to go?

Mr. Chatoor, please go ahead.

Ken Chatoor Director of Research and Strategic Foresight, Labour Market Information Council

Thank you, Chair and members of the committee. I am Ken Chatoor, director of research and strategic foresight at the Labour Market Information Council, or LMIC. I'm joined by our executive director, Rebecca Webb.

LMIC was created by the Forum of Labour Market Ministers to address gaps in Canada's labour market information system. Our work with provincial and territorial labour ministries, ESDC and Statistics Canada gives us a pan-Canadian perspective that recognizes regional differences.

Canada's labour market is facing several compounding pressures. Youth unemployment reached 13% in September compared with a pre-pandemic average of 10.8%. At the same time, business closures have outpaced openings for six consecutive quarters, while businesses continue to navigate economic uncertainty, changing immigration levels and trade pressures. Canada's workforce is also aging. LMIC's analysis shows that the age replacement ratio, which compares older workers with younger workers, is particularly pronounced in the skilled trades, raising concerns about future workforce replacement.

These pressures come as governments pursue major investments in defence, mining, natural resources, the green economy, infrastructure and a sovereign AI strategy, all of which require skilled workers. Provincial and territorial labour ministries tell us that these pressures compound long-standing regional challenges related to labour mobility, retaining skilled workers and demographic change, making regional and sector-specific workforce needs especially important. Meeting Canada's workforce needs requires reliable training and immigration systems, but attracting skilled workers is only part of the challenge. Newcomers must also be able to use their qualifications.

That brings me to foreign credential recognition, or FCR. In 2025, LMIC published a report looking at information gaps and barriers in foreign credential recognition. Despite two decades of reviews and reforms, significant barriers remain. Most participants in our study were unaware of FCR before arriving in Canada. Many encountered unclear requirements, difficult-to-use digital tools, inconsistent or outdated information, lengthy processes and significant costs. Some participants completed assessments only to find that employers did not understand or recognize the results, especially in non-regulated occupations. This raises questions about the practical value of these assessments and highlights the need to better understand how employers use them when making hiring decisions.

Canada also lacks comprehensive, comparable and publicly accessible data on foreign credential recognition participation and outcomes. We need to know who applies, how long recognition takes, what it costs and whether applicants ultimately work in their fields. Some information is collected across jurisdictions, but it is not consistently available or linked to longer-term employment outcomes. We cannot evaluate what we cannot measure. Good policy depends on good information. At a time when reliable labour market data are essential, Statistics Canada has had to discontinue the Canadian survey on business conditions, which had its final release in August 2026. Through our work with labour ministries and chambers of commerce, among others, we hear how valuable this type of labour market information is for understanding changing workforce needs. Maintaining a strong labour market information system is essential to making informed decisions.

We want to offer three recommendations. First, improve FCR information and processes. Provide prospective newcomers with clear information about documentation requirements, timelines and costs before they arrive in Canada, and embrace digital and improved digital services. Ensure consistent guidance while maintaining the professional standards we need. We also need to understand how employers interpret and use credential assessments. Improving the efficiency of FCR will improve the flow of skilled labour into the labour market and help Canada achieve its ambitious domestic agenda.

Second, we need to strengthen the collection and evaluation capacity of FCR and labour market data. Federal, provincial and territorial governments, FCR regulators and Statistics Canada should work together to improve information on FCR participation, processing times, costs and longitudinal employment outcomes while also protecting statistical capacity. This will require dedicated funding and resources to build and maintain the necessary data collection and evaluation capacity.

Third, immigration policy should reflect regional and sector-specific workforce needs. The federal government should consult provinces, territories and relevant sectors before making significant changes to immigration levels, using reliable labour market information to inform those decisions. Labour ministries and sector-focused bodies across Canada produce occupational projections of labour demand at a jurisdictional and sometimes even local level that can be leveraged to make very targeted decisions.

Finally, Canada's ability to attract global talent must be matched by its ability to recognize and fully use the skills that people bring. Better information, stronger coordination and more accessible recognition processes are essential to achieving our national goals.

Thank you. I look forward to your questions.

The Chair Liberal Julie Dzerowicz

Thank you, Mr. Chatoor.

Next and finally, we have Ms. Wagner from TalentLift Canada.

Your five minutes start now.

Dana Wagner Managing Director, TalentLift Canada

Thank you.

My name is Dana, and I'm the co-founder and managing director of TalentLift. We're a Canadian charity that supports employers hiring internationally from within refugee populations. There are many talented people who are living internationally as refugees, and my remarks are about how to attract them using economic immigration pathways.

I'll begin with why we should attract this population. It's because the talent is real and it's unique. In our talent platform alone, there are 46,000 displaced people. Among them are 1,600 engineers, 3,100 welders and mechanics, and 1,600 nurses and paramedics. It goes on and on. They are a deeply creative community. Many of the professionals we support learned a new language, a new trade or a new national industry, while in precarious and underpaid work where they're living as refugees.

A second reason is moral. If it were us, how would we want another country's skilled visas to work? Imagine a hostile takeover here in Canada. If Passport Canada didn't function and bank accounts were frozen, we'd want Germany, South Africa and Colombia to recognize our skills and accommodate our displacement.

The economic mobility pathways pilot, or the EMPP, did this. It let someone apply without a passport and without funds in a bank account—not because they were displaced but in spite of that. The EMPP is a really extraordinary policy innovation, and that's why we need to improve it.

In its latest form, the EMPP had several flaws. The most fundamental and structural was that only a narrow set of economic immigration programs had EMPP accommodations, and none of those were work permit pathways. The EMPP had two streams, as you'll know, a regional stream and a federal stream. The regional stream extended accommodations to some PR pathways, including participating PNPs, the AIP and the former RNIP, but it did not apply to express entry or any work permit pathway, among others. Meanwhile, the federal stream created a dedicated pathway with its own human capital criteria.

We argue that the regional stream was too narrow, and the federal stream was actually too broad, so the emphasis should flip. I'll share two recommendations for how to do this.

First, we recommend extending an accessibility layer like the regional EMPP, with displacement accommodations, across the economic stream. TalentLift and the global migration institute at TMU identified 12 common and non-human capital barriers for displaced talent within our economic immigration programs. There are reasonable accommodations for all.

These accommodations—like accepting alternatives to a passport, alternatives to savings in a bank account and alternatives to sealed transcripts from a home university—should apply to every economic pathway and to a large segment of temporary work permits. These should include nomination-supported work permits, the global talent stream, high-wage LMIA work permits and others that position someone to have a credible pathway to PR.

If we get this broad access to the economic stream right, a separate, dedicated EMPP pathway could still add immense value to attract above and beyond for specific workforce or political goals such as responding to a crisis.

Second, we recommend implementing this accessibility layer immediately, with an interim public policy, and not wait two years or longer for a permanent EMPP program. That's because qualified people living as refugees are waiting right now to fairly compete for in-demand roles, and often, just one criteria can restrict their eligibility. We're supporting an autobody technician displaced from Venezuela with a job offer in B.C. who meets all of the B.C. PNP criteria except for a valid passport.

To close, accommodations for displaced talent across the economic stream would solve so many issues. They would solve how to balance accommodations with low immigration levels, because accommodations don't require new space. It's about levelling the field within existing space. They would also solve the utter failure of EMPP permanent residence processing times, which ballooned from a six-month service standard to a four- to six-year standard in December 2025. Instead, like any other skilled worker, displaced talent could get here quickly with a work permit or through express entry.

The EMPP is not the fastest, best route for employers to hire the skills they need. It very rarely has been. It's not the best for tech talent, agriculture talent or francophone talent. We painstakingly design so many economic programs for in-demand talent, and it's time that we let displaced folks into them.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Julie Dzerowicz

Thank you so much to all three of you for your excellent interventions.

Now we begin the rounds of six-minute questions.

We'll begin with Mr. Jackson.

3:45 p.m.

Conservative

Grant Jackson Conservative Brandon—Souris, MB

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Thanks to the witnesses for being here.

Dr. Finch, much of your research is focused on productivity, education, workforce development and skills. We know unemployment among youth is too high. In the month of September, 68,000 Canadians lost their jobs. You mentioned a statistic in your opening remarks about the percentage of your graduating students who are having a hard time finding employment. Can you repeat that for the committee?

October 27th, 2026 / 3:45 p.m.

Professor, Mount Royal University and Research Director, The Productivity Project, As an Individual

David Finch

It wasn't in my opening remarks.

Certainly, when we look at macro-level data, it's very discipline-specific and degree-specific. We've been seeing the impact of AI on what's called “task compression” over the last three to five years, and we're starting to see a significant drop-off of what I would call traditional entry-level jobs, which supported conversion. They probably dropped off, in some disciplines, by up to 50%.

3:45 p.m.

Conservative

Grant Jackson Conservative Brandon—Souris, MB

I share your concerns regarding AI. I respect your position on that, for sure.

I'm also concerned about skills. Do you think post-secondary institutions are keeping up with the changing labour market? What is the impact of that on job market accessibility for your graduating students? Do you think post-secondaries are keeping up?

3:45 p.m.

Professor, Mount Royal University and Research Director, The Productivity Project, As an Individual

David Finch

They weren't designed for speed. Adaptability and agility were not in their original design. Culturally, it's difficult to move quickly. We've seen that. It is not news.

I would argue that the most important skill, moving forward—the only skill, moving forward—is adaptive capacity: the capacity to learn how to learn. As we shift towards more technical degrees that have immediate monetary value in the labour market, we start removing some of those foundational skills from the learning process. Again, this shift may set a learner up for the first few years after graduation, but as the value of those tasks declines and depreciates, they're going to have a challenge reinventing and reimagining themselves in the future. We've seen this in the marketplace.

3:50 p.m.

Conservative

Grant Jackson Conservative Brandon—Souris, MB

Do you think adding competition for those jobs would be a problem or a positive for graduating students?

3:50 p.m.

Professor, Mount Royal University and Research Director, The Productivity Project, As an Individual

David Finch

Here's the challenge: information asymmetry. I think all panellists today have identified the challenge of data.

My background is in marketing, so I look at this as a consumer purchasing exercise, fundamentally. The fact that we can go to Safeway and compare six cans of beans more easily than we can compare six random graduates.... It is a terrible place for most employers to be in. If we adopt the risk management lens that employers do, we have to create a mechanism that identifies the best candidate available, regardless of who they are and where they are. Right now we're making guesses, at best.

3:50 p.m.

Conservative

Grant Jackson Conservative Brandon—Souris, MB

Sure. However, broadening the pool would logically be a more challenging proposition than if you prioritized a certain group—perhaps Canadians who are trained in a job. It would be easier to solve that problem, from a comparative analysis perspective, before adding in competition with foreign-trained professionals from different universities with different standards.

Am I correct?

3:50 p.m.

Professor, Mount Royal University and Research Director, The Productivity Project, As an Individual

David Finch

There is no question that with the $60 billion plus we invest every year in post-secondary education, graduates of those programs, who incur significant debt as individuals, should absolutely be given an efficient pathway to be successful. The pathway from school today, which we call the off-ramp, is terrible. We're not setting them up for success in their final year as they look for an off-ramp into the labour market.

3:50 p.m.

Conservative

Grant Jackson Conservative Brandon—Souris, MB

Removing the labour market impact assessment for certain high-paying skilled jobs, in your view, would make it more challenging, not less.

3:50 p.m.

Professor, Mount Royal University and Research Director, The Productivity Project, As an Individual

David Finch

We need to make transparent data available for the key decision-makers—the individuals, the investors and often their parents—when they're deciding where the opportunities in the future are and where they should make that investment, whether that is inside or outside accredited post-secondary institutions.

As I said, I'm a big believer in the untapped capacity outside the system. This introduces a whole layer of internal compression and learning as you move forward to unlock the entire learning system.

3:50 p.m.

Conservative

Grant Jackson Conservative Brandon—Souris, MB

What other steps could you recommend to post-secondary institutions as they prioritize addressing that gap? Should they be doing it with government support, if necessary?

3:50 p.m.

Professor, Mount Royal University and Research Director, The Productivity Project, As an Individual

David Finch

The government historically falls back into structured work placement programs. In theory, that sounds wonderful. Let's put co-op into every program. The challenge is that it creates a significant administrative burden on post-secondary institutions, meaning that you're, in fact, hiring a co-op coordinator to manage a cohort. You've added an administrative layer.

My argument is that we need to recognize that when these young people graduate, they have to have agency and control of their futures. We need to create opportunities through that degree or diploma—and prior to it, frankly—where they are given the tools to understand where they should invest in their future and to support their decisions from a career perspective so that it's their future, not somebody else telling them where to go on a Friday afternoon.

The Chair Liberal Julie Dzerowicz

You have 20 seconds.

3:50 p.m.

Conservative

Grant Jackson Conservative Brandon—Souris, MB

I'll cede my time.