As you are well aware, Bill C-3 is about Canadian citizens by descent. They are born Canadian. Their status is from their Canadian parent. They become citizens at the moment of their birth, automatically, by operation of law. Imposing language proficiency and knowledge requirements as well as security requirements as conditions of acquiring, maintaining or retaining their citizenship status as proposed by this amendment would be impossible to operationalize, as such status is conferred by operation of law at the moment of their birth.
Furthermore, from a technical perspective, there is reference to inadmissibilities in IRPA. In the Citizenship Act, we do not have IRPA sections. Our own prohibitions are different from inadmissibilities. IRPA is about foreign nationals, while the Citizenship Act is about people acquiring citizenship.
In addition to the impossibility of being able to operationalize these requirements, it could lead us down a path of actually creating more lost Canadians. The bill is to restore citizenship to lost Canadians. It's the reason we're here today. With this type of requirement, we could potentially create another cohort of lost Canadians.
