Thank you, Mr. Chair.
I want to thank our witnesses for taking the journey to come and appear before the committee. I know that asks a lot of people, when you have to leave your communities and come to this place.
Both Chief Day Walker-Pelletier and Chief Laboucan have touched on the heart of the matter before us, in that we have fundamental differences between what we see as an appropriate way to move forward on something that affects people's lives at their community level.
I'm going to read a brief paragraph from page 150 of Thomas Berger's book, A Long and Terrible Shadow: White Values, and Native Rights in the Americas Since 1492. This is with regards to the Nisga'a claim. I'm from British Columbia, and he's talking about some of the challenges. He wrote:
Chief Justice Davey's inability to comprehend the true nature of Native culture and Native claims is widely shared. It results in an attitude toward Native people that exasperates them when it does not infuriate them. This attitude is sometimes manifested in an attempt to preserve Native culture and sometimes in an attempt to eradicate it, but it is always manifested in a patronizing way. It assumes that Native culture cannot be viable in a contemporary context. This is the crux of the matter. Native peoples insist that their culture is still a vital force in their own lives, that it informs their own view of themselves, of the world about them, and of the dominant society.
For me, that paragraph talks about the fact that if governments of all political stripes truly recognized that native peoples have a vital, vibrant culture that has entrenched human rights and that expects to be dealt with on a nation-to-nation basis on matters that are going to affect you in your own community, we would be having a different discussion.
Could you please comment on that?
