Good morning, Mr. Chair and members of the committee. Thank you for giving me this opportunity to appear today.
My name is Julie‑Christine Denoncourt and I'm an analyst in source reduction at Équiterre.
Équiterre is a Quebec-based environmental organization that has been active for over 30 years and has just over 22,000 members. One of our priorities is to accelerate the transition toward a sustainable, circular economy. That's why we have been working on access to product repair and durability for several years.
For example, in 2022, our organization published the first Canada-wide study on access to repairs for home appliances and electronics. The study revealed that appliance breakdowns are common for Canadians, and that 63% had experienced at least one appliance failure in the previous two years, and only 19% of them had their appliances and electronics repaired. The main barriers to repair cited were product design, repair costs and access to replacement parts, tools and repair information. We are therefore pleased to see that a federal bill is attempting to tackle these various barriers.
A second report published by Équiterre in 2024 shows that a durability index could be developed and rolled out in Canada, modelled on and drawing from the model adopted in France. This report included our recommendations for this index's adoption in Canada.
Finally, our latest report on this topic was published in May this year. The report revealed that the durability and repairability of electronic products and home appliances have a significant influence on Canadians' purchasing decisions. It also revealed that Canadians are interested in seeing these characteristics labelled.
Were therefore believe that it is appropriate for the government to address these issues. That is why Équiterre welcomes the overall objective of Bill C‑267 to promote the repairability and durability of electronics and home appliances. However, we would like to point out that we believe the government could, and should, go further, because the bill under consideration has not introduced any concrete measures or requirements, or a timeline for implementing such measures and requirements. In short, we fear that in its current form, Bill C‑267 does not provide a meaningful right to repair or meaningful access to durable products. That is why we recommend adding requirements regarding some of the elements set out in the bill.
First, we recommend including a requirement to make parts, tools, information and software updates available for a reasonable period of time and at a reasonable price. This reasonable period and price could be determined by looking at the practice in other parts of the world or according to the literature. A number of countries have already done so, and so have some U.S. states for certain products. Quebec has also introduced such a requirement, although it is not perfect.
We also recommend prohibiting certain design practices, as Europe has recently done. Examples including bundling parts, matching components and the common practice of welding or gluing together critical components, such as a device's battery. These practices make repairs more expensive and more difficult and, in some cases, impossible.
Finally, based on our recent work on this issue, we recommend that the bill include the mandatory display of a durability index for electronic products and home appliances. The format and criteria could be modelled on what has been developed in France, while including certain improvements. Équiterre strongly recommends an index displaying a rating or score rather than useful life, as mentioned in the bill, because displaying useful life could create more confusion with existing provincial legal warranties, or even worse, could be misunderstood as the minimum lifespan of a product.
In closing, I would note that many of the manufacturers operating in Europe, who are subject to multiple European requirements also operate here, and they are therefore accustomed to these kinds of regulations.
I would be happy to answer your questions. Thank you
