The intention behind this rating is really to provide consumers with more information when purchasing an appliance.
As for the first part of your question on how to implement it, in France it is displayed at the point of purchase online and in-store. Next to the price, there is a fairly prominent and large rating, or a score from 1 to 10 with a colour-coded scale from red to green. It's quite easy to understand at a glance. If you see a three in red, you know the product may not be of the highest quality. The score is also quite visible online and is displayed next to the price and the product specifications. So we could easily do the same thing here and display it online or on a label in-store.
Would it be a score from 1 to 10 or from A to E? It doesn't matter. We could see what resonates most with consumers here, but the literature shows that a colour-coded system and a score of this kind is easy to understand.
As for penalties, I would say that it is more a case of penalties being imposed if a retailer or manufacturer fails to display the rating, because this display is mandatory. There are penalties for failure to meet this requirement.
Furthermore, what we have seen in France is that this has had very tangible results in terms of product repairability and the availability of more repairable products. It has also created competition among manufacturers. Indeed, some have even changed their practices to achieve a better rating and to achieve a change in colour—for example, moving from yellow to green to make their products more appealing to consumers.
I don't want to spend too much time on this, but some great reports on this subject are available and demonstrate the tangible effects of the index for manufacturers and product design and for consumers.
