It's an excellent question. Bear with me.
When it comes to the enforcement of the Competition Act, for a very long time, it was predominantly the Competition Bureau that brought the vast majority of cases. The private access route, more often than not, is taken by a business as opposed to an individual, and the standard for them to bring a case was quite high. You basically had to be going out of business and then decide to take on a bunch of legal fees, which was not a particularly attractive path. In 2023 and 2024, they opened the path to private access and also included, correctly, as you note, the provisions around refusal to deal around repair and diagnostic information.
This is a great example of the value of upfront standards and a framework as opposed to an investigatory and adjudicative tool. It is true that you could bring that case either to the Competition Bureau in the form of a complaint or to the Competition Tribunal, but the fact that it originates from the Competition Act means that it would have to actually have an impact on competition to then begin the process of either investigation or litigation. Again, we are talking about something that, to date, even with the expanded access, only a select number of Canadian businesses have engaged in.
I'd be happy to elaborate on that further—
