Thank you very much for your invitation to address a section of Bill C-14. We are both from the University of Calgary medical school. Whereas I am trained in law with a doctoral degree and called to the bar of Ontario, my colleague Ian Mitchell is, as you have heard, a pediatrician who is a specialist in pediatric respirology and in ethics.
Proposed subsection 241.31(3) concerns regulations about creating, collecting, using, publishing, storing, and disposing of information about requests for and provision of medical assistance in dying generally. We respectfully make two recommendations concerning this subsection, but before we do that we respectfully recommend that this subsection of the Criminal Code should be based on the following two principles. First, all deaths that occur in Canada must be recorded accurately, and second, medical assistance in dying must be monitored scrupulously.
The proper implementation of these principles would foster protection, prevention, health promotion, health planning, and in rare cases, prosecution. Because the field of death reporting and death monitoring is not well known, we presume very briefly to describe it.
First is accurate reporting of death. Vital statistics are valuable only if the reports are accurate. An accurate report of how a person died is required to be contained in the medical certificate of death in common-law Canada, and in the bulletin de décès in Quebec.
Stating how someone dies entails identifying and stating truthfully the cause and the manner or circumstances of death. These two terms are terms of art, which are best understood by experts. It is not unusual for physicians without forensic training to have difficulty distinguishing between cause of death and manner of death, or to have difficulty naming the immediate antecedent and underlying cause of death. Consequently, in many provinces, medical certificates of death, which were originally completed by physicians, even in natural deaths, are routinely reviewed and corrected by forensic pathologists, medical examiners, or coroners, who have sub-specialty training in accurate death reporting.
Coroners exist in all provinces and territories except four. Those four are Alberta, Manitoba, Nova Scotia, and Newfoundland and Labrador. These four provinces have adopted the medical examiner system of death reporting. For our purposes, however, coroners and medical examiners perform the same functions. Sometimes, only these experts are permitted to establish cause and manner of death, and to complete the medical certificate of death.
For example, in Alberta, Manitoba, Prince Edward Island, and Nova Scotia, when a death occurs within 10 days of surgery, only the medical examiner or coroner may complete the medical certificate of death. Such requirements ensure that death is reported accurately.
Dr. Mitchell will discuss scrupulous monitoring.