Hi and good afternoon. I am Elene Lam, executive director of Butterfly. We work with over 5,000 migrant sex workers in Canada.
I am shocked that the committee did not consult any migrant rights, racial justice or sex workers who are directly impacted. Many scholars on violence again women and racial justice and human rights organizations have already shown their opposition to this bill, and have shown concern that they are not having the opportunity to tell you how this bill is harmful.
The claim is that the bill will help charge traffickers and bring them to justice. It will not. As Sandra will explain, this bill will lead to more human trafficking charges laid against migrants, Black and racialized people, sex workers and those who are providing support services to others. It will take away their livelihood, make them live in fear and drive them to work even more underground.
The concern was already expressed by some of the committee members that this bill does not differentiate sex work from human trafficking. It cannot differentiate as to whether people have asked another person to organize the work or whether they are being forced or exploited. Both of them will be charged with trafficking, no matter the nature of the relationship. It is wrong to assume that all third parties are exploiting and human trafficking. Poor, racialized migrant sex workers rely on community support to stay safe. They help each other access transportation, food, medical care, translation and a safe work environment. If Bill S-224 passes, anyone who helps sex workers stay safe, particularly Black and migrants, will be charged as human traffickers. People will be too afraid to be associated with sex work, and that will make sex workers more isolated and vulnerable.
Advocates against sex work have long used anti-human trafficking campaigns and policies to further their racist anti-migrant agenda. They promote moral panic, racial discrimination and hate against the sex industry. By calling for the criminalization of sex work and increased policing, the goal of anti-trafficking campaigns is often not ending trafficking but ending the sex industry. It's not protecting sex workers but ending sex work.
You are all here today because you care about the rights and safety of vulnerable people. You should listen to the community and what many racialized, Black and migrant sex workers will tell you: “Don't take away my agency. We cannot let Bill S-224 pass. Bill S-224 does not protect us. It puts us into danger.”
I will now give Sandra the time to explain more.
Thank you.