Actually, I do.
The history of the navy shows that the fleet maintenance facilities are vitally important in the maintenance of the fleet, keeping it ready, rectifying short-notice deficiencies, things that have to be fixed if the ship is going to get out on time to do the assigned task.
This is irrefutable. Those facilities are vitally important. Just do the simple math. With a fleet of 12 frigates, if one of them suddenly goes down, what's the percentage of your lost capability as the ship sits there and waits for a commercial contractor to show up, do an assessment, during business hours, by the way, and then send off his report of findings to the head office, which may be a European company?
I have a son who is a naval reservist and is working on one of the reserve ships. They're now well into their twenties in terms of age. They are a maintenance nightmare. The contracted service support people have less and less interest in meeting their contractual obligations to keep those ships repaired and operating, simply because the effort that's required to maintain old ships escalates very rapidly.
I highly recommend a SPAR study—a company out of Annapolis, Maryland—that shows in the last three or four decades of life, the maintenance costs for old ships escalating by about 400% a year. You can understand why contractors will back away from those kinds of ships and not be interested in doing that work, whereas the navy absolutely must maintain the capability to handle it at short notice.
