Evidence of meeting #46 for Natural Resources in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was gas.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Carter  Committee Researcher
Baiton  President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers
Jenkins  Executive Director, Indigenous Clean Energy
Bowen  Vice-President, Asset Planning and Delivery, Manitoba Hydro
Walker  Director, Institute for Sustainable Finance, Queen’s University, and Professor of Finance, Concordia University, As an Individual
Belliveau  Program Manager, Energy Transition, Environmental Defence Canada
Stirling  Communications Manager, Friends of Science Society
Levin  Associate Director, National Climate, Environmental Defence Canada

11:45 a.m.

Conservative

Jeremy Patzer Conservative Swift Current—Grasslands—Kindersley, SK

I was just looking at a graph produced in The Hub. It shows Alberta's tax burden versus that of the United States. It has the U.S. at between 15% and 16%. It has all the Alberta oil sands at 76% and Alberta's conventional oil at 49%.

When you see a massive tax discrepancy like that between Canada and the United States, particularly given what the Liberal government is doing to our producers, how are our producers going to be able to compete?

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Give a quick answer, if you could, Ms. Baiton.

11:45 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers

Lisa Baiton

The quick answer is that we have come a long way in the last year with some pretty significant regulatory and fiscal changes. We're not there yet. If we really want to compete for global capital, as I said in my opening remarks, there should be alignment with governments across the country to make sure that we have the most competitive regulatory and fiscal frameworks to bring that capital to Canada.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you both.

Mr. Guay, you have five minutes.

Claude Guay Liberal LaSalle—Émard—Verdun, QC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Ms. Baiton, it's good to see you again. The first question is going to go for you.

We've talked a lot about major projects from an export perspective on the LNG side: Woodfibre, LNG Canada phases one and two, Cedar, Ksi Lisims—the list is long. On the oil side, as you pointed out, we just announced Pacific link and there's the upgrade to TMX, so a lot is being done from an export perspective.

Meanwhile, for the last few years, many of your members have been busy reducing debt, buying shares back and receiving dividends, but they have not been so busy on the investment side.

When we talked about investors, you said earlier that certainty is one of the things they need. You highlighted the mega deduction, which should be an amazing incentive for capital investment. You haven't made comments yet, but I hope you will, on Bill C-39, the building Canada strong act, which is really about providing certainty. Talk to us, please, about the environment from a production perspective. While I think we have a great strategy from the perspective of exports and the facilities, I want to know more about where your members sit on the production side of investment.

11:50 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers

Lisa Baiton

Let me start by saying that Canada attracts investment from global capital markets due to the fact that we have high-quality oil and natural gas resources and the ability among Canadian workers to develop them responsibly.

To your question, CAPP member companies are both private and publicly traded. There are large and small oil and natural gas producers that operate in Canada, employing Canadians and generating billions of dollars in government revenues to underpin our health care system, our schools and the social programs on which Canadians rely.

I would also like to point out that there are no direct subsidies on the production or consumption of oil and natural gas in Canada, and that, through taxes and royalties, Canadian oil and natural gas producers have generated $116 billion for governments across Canada in just the last three years alone. Again, those dollars support our health care system, our schools and the social programs on which Canadians rely.

There are instances where it may make sense for government and industry to partner on investments: for example, in the emerging and scaling of new technology. We've talked about carbon capture a lot over this past year, and that's where partnership may make sense to help build a new industry in Canada, to create new jobs and to have that new industry and technology exported to the world.

Claude Guay Liberal LaSalle—Émard—Verdun, QC

If you don't mind, can you...? Have we created the right environment? It sounds like we have a lot of capacity to export. Are we going to fill those pipelines? Are we going to fill those LNG export facilities? That is where I would like you to give us some clarity.

11:50 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers

Lisa Baiton

Canada's largest competitor for upstream oil and gas capital and investment is still the United States. I talked about it in my opening remarks, but the productivity mega deduction closes a significant competitive gap between our two countries in terms of capital cost expensing. With that change, along with recent amendments for oil sands projects in the Impact Assessment Act and the build Canada strong act, Canada is now taking a significant step forward in improving the competitiveness for the oil and natural gas industry and toward becoming one of the best places in the world to invest in energy as we become the world's next energy superpower.

There's still more to do. There have been a lot of terrific announcements, but there's still a lot of work under each of those announcements to make them real. Also, then, as I said to one of your colleagues about a moment ago, we still should look at the entirety of the Canadian federal, provincial and municipal fiscal and regulatory stack, put our heads above the parapet and be unafraid to look at how Canada, cumulatively, is competing for capital with other places where that capital could be deployed around the globe.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thanks to both of you.

Claude Guay Liberal LaSalle—Émard—Verdun, QC

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

That's your time, Mr. Guay.

Mr. Simard, you have the floor for two and a half minutes.

Mario Simard Bloc Jonquière—Hébertville—Pays-des-Bleuets, QC

Thank you very much, Mr. Chair.

In response to my colleague's question, Ms. Baiton, you just touched on the benefits generated by the oil and gas sector and stated that there are no direct subsidies to the oil industry.

Generally speaking, when assessing the contribution of an economic sector, a form of cost-benefit analysis can be conducted. Not long ago, I believe representatives from Unifor appeared before the committee and pointed out that, when one looks at oil production trends, production has increased significantly, but the number of jobs associated with that production has not increased at the same rate. That suggests that, as the sector becomes more efficient, or rather the people in the sector become more efficient, companies are likely investing in automation and process improvements, which I assume is the case.

However, what I cannot explain is why two major infrastructure projects, namely TMX and Pacific Link, were undertaken in Canada using public funds. I do not understand why the oil and gas industry—which has generated record profits, some $131 billion between 2021 and 2024, as I mentioned earlier—is unable to invest in its own infrastructure. Why is it the federal government, the Government of Alberta, or the public that must do so? Ordinary Canadians are effectively being asked to foot the bill for these infrastructure projects.

11:55 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers

Lisa Baiton

I'll just restate that there are no direct subsidies on production or on consumption of oil and natural gas in Canada. I will also restate that through taxes and royalties, Canadian oil and gas producers have generated $116 billion for governments across Canada over the last three years alone. That underpins a big part of our—

Mario Simard Bloc Jonquière—Hébertville—Pays-des-Bleuets, QC

I'm sorry to interrupt.

I understand that very well. I simply want to return to my question. I recognize that all sectors of economic activity pay taxes, contribute to the Canadian economy and help support public services, whether health care or education. The forestry sector, the aluminum sector and all other industries contribute to the Canadian economy. I fully understand that.

What I am asking is why an industry that is generating record profits is not in a position to—

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

That's your time.

Mario Simard Bloc Jonquière—Hébertville—Pays-des-Bleuets, QC

Is it because the Canadian business environment is not sufficiently competitive? Why are these companies not able to finance their own infrastructure projects?

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

I'll allow a quick answer, Ms. Baiton.

11:55 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers

Lisa Baiton

Generally speaking, we should be looking for the most competitive, cumulative, federal, provincial and municipal fiscal and regulatory stack to attract capital so that those investments can be made.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you.

Thank you both.

We move to the vice-chair, Ms. Anstey.

11:55 a.m.

Conservative

Carol Anstey Conservative Long Range Mountains, NL

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Thank you, Ms. Baiton. It's good to see you at committee.

Ms. Baiton, back in April, you said that Canada was still talking about an industrial carbon tax when no other producing and exporting nation does that to their producers. You mentioned the Bay du Nord project. We also had Jim Keating, CEO of the Oil and Gas Corporation of Newfoundland and Labrador, at the environment committee, where he talked about the complexity of our carbon pricing system.

We know that Equinor is moving towards a final investment decision. We know that BP has also sold out its interest to Equinor and that, potentially, they may be looking for more investors. From that perspective, and also given the companies you represent, what does that kind of complexity in our carbon pricing system mean when a company is deciding whether or not they're going to invest in Canada or potentially put their capital to work in other countries?

11:55 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers

Lisa Baiton

Thank you for the question.

I would restate that Canada cumulatively—federally, provincially and municipally—needs to look at the fiscal and regulatory stack to see how it compares to where that capital can be deployed to any other producing region in the world and make sure that we're competitive for that capital, as the first point.

To your question about the industrial carbon tax, I would restate that the new industrial carbon tax improves on earlier proposed versions, yet it still represents a unique cost to Canadian oil and natural gas producers. If the collective goal is to diversify our economy and grow energy exports, then we should not be adding costs, like an industrial carbon tax, to oil and gas production, when no other country that we directly compete with has done so.

To your climate change comment, I would say that Canada can grow its oil and natural gas production and exports in balance with its climate ambition. Producers have been exploring innovative solutions, like replacing tens of thousands of pneumatic valves to lower methane emissions; using drone satellites to monitor, detect and seal leaks in infrastructure; and working to scale carbon capture. We can export a lot of those technologies and advancements—

11:55 a.m.

Conservative

Carol Anstey Conservative Long Range Mountains, NL

Thank you, Ms. Baiton.

11:55 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers

Lisa Baiton

—and help other industries and countries to lower their emissions as well.

Carol Anstey Conservative Long Range Mountains, NL

To put a final point on your comments around the industrial carbon tax, given the importance of the Bay du Nord project to Newfoundland and Labrador, I'm just wondering: What are your thoughts about the government potentially walking back on some of these policies and meeting this important moment for Newfoundland and Labrador on the final investment decision? Would you agree with that?

Noon

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers

Lisa Baiton

I think all major projects are critical. It has been encouraging to see, particularly over the last year or year and a half, how the federal government and the provinces are working together to make sure that the entire system works from coast to coast.