Evidence of meeting #46 for Natural Resources in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was gas.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Carter  Committee Researcher
Baiton  President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers
Jenkins  Executive Director, Indigenous Clean Energy
Bowen  Vice-President, Asset Planning and Delivery, Manitoba Hydro
Walker  Director, Institute for Sustainable Finance, Queen’s University, and Professor of Finance, Concordia University, As an Individual
Belliveau  Program Manager, Energy Transition, Environmental Defence Canada
Stirling  Communications Manager, Friends of Science Society
Levin  Associate Director, National Climate, Environmental Defence Canada

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Colleagues, I'd like to call this meeting to order.

Welcome back, everyone. I hope you had a great week connecting with your communities, with your constituents.

Let me acknowledge, as we always do, that we are meeting on the unceded territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe nation.

Welcome to meeting number 46 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Natural Resources. Today's meeting, as you know, is taking place in a hybrid format, pursuant to the Standing Orders. Members are attending in person in the room and remotely by using the Zoom application.

I'd like to remind participants of the following points: Please wait until I recognize you by name before speaking. For those participating by video conference, click on the microphone icon to activate your mic, and please mute yourself when you are not speaking. For those on Zoom—and we have three Zoom witnesses today—at the bottom of your screen you will see the selection for the appropriate channel for interpretation: floor, English or French. For those in the room, you can use the earpiece and select the desired channel. I remind you that all comments should be addressed through the chair. For members in the room, if you wish to speak, please raise your hand. For members on Zoom, please use the “raise hand” function. The clerk and I will manage the speaking order as best as we can, and we appreciate your patience and understanding in this regard.

Colleagues, if I could, I'll just give you a bit of an update. This is our last meeting on the energy security study. At the next meeting, as I think you already know, we will be giving drafting instructions to our amazing analysts. For the second hour, we will be in camera for committee business. We have a number of matters to discuss, including topics for new studies. We look forward to getting everyone's input on that and to having a good conversation on where we go next.

The forestry report draft, which we've been anticipating and our analysts have been working very hard on, is being sent to all of us tomorrow, I think. You'll have this week and the following constituency week to take a look at that, to dive in and to come back with your thoughts. Then we'll launch right into the forestry study. We'll be interested in your recommendations and your thoughts on the draft. We never know how long those will take, but we'll take as much time as we need.

Laura, for the energy export study, are we thinking November sometime?

Laura Carter Committee Researcher

I believe so, yes.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

We may, again, get another week to dive in on that during the Remembrance Day break.

That was a bit of an update before we launch into today's proceedings.

Pursuant to Standing Order 108(2) and the motion adopted by the committee on Thursday, April 23, 2026, the committee is resuming its study of Canada's electrification, energy self-sufficiency and domestic energy security.

I'd like to welcome our witnesses. We have, from the Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers, Lisa Baiton, president and chief executive officer; from Indigenous Clean Energy, James Jenkins, president and chief executive officer; and, from my home province, Dave Bowen, president and chief executive officer of Manitoba Hydro.

All witnesses appearing virtually have conducted a mandatory witness onboarding test.

I'd like to make a few comments for the benefit of the new witnesses. I think you already heard my spiel. Do wait for me to acknowledge you before speaking and, again, address all comments through the chair. You will each have five minutes for your opening remarks, after which we will open the floor to questions.

Ms. Baiton, we're going to start with you. You have the floor for five minutes.

Lisa Baiton President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers

Good morning.

Thank you, Mr. Chair and members of the committee, for the opportunity to once again appear before you today and contribute to your study.

Since the launch of this study, much has transpired, so I'm going to focus my comments today on energy security.

First, there are some lessons we can learn from what others globally have been experiencing.

Russia's invasion of Ukraine demonstrated that concentrated dependence for energy can become a critical vulnerability. Despite a monumental effort to pivot to other supplies and suppliers, energy security in Europe remains in jeopardy. The U.S.–Iran conflict demonstrates that even resource wealth does not provide strategic autonomy. The gulf states, with their massive energy resources, are in crisis with the closing of their major shipping routes.

Countries around the world are learning lessons on the importance of energy security. The response has not been economic separation from other nations and a retreat to domestic supply. The lesson really has been all about resiliency: multiple energy suppliers, alternative transport routes, stronger industries and broader diplomatic partnerships.

The future of energy security will be determined not only by those who have abundant oil and natural gas resources and can sell at the lowest cost but also by those who can reliably bring the product to global markets. What customers are looking for is trust, and that places Canada in a really enviable position. As other countries seek to develop their energy security and identify trusted partners, the world is turning to Canada for its energy security needs.

Canada possesses some of the largest untapped oil and natural gas reserves in the world. We have a highly skilled workforce and world-class companies with decades-long track records of responsible operations and growth. We have a model of indigenous participation in resource development, and that's viewed as a global benchmark. It's creating partnerships that deliver long-term economic benefits to communities while advancing meaningful economic reconciliation.

Canada is becoming an LNG exporting power. The first phase of LNG Canada staked out a position for Canada in the global LNG market, while the second phase of the project, along with Cedar LNG, Woodfibre LNG and Ksi Lisims LNG, represents the next wave of investment and growth. In recent offtake agreement announcements for the Ksi Lisims project, the CEOs of the U.K.'s Centrica and Germany's Uniper both cited Canada's reputation as a stable and reliable energy partner as a reason for their investments.

Canadian oil has a similar story.

Growing demand, combined with increased concerns about energy security, is driving sustained investment in Canadian oil. The Japanese prime minister recently celebrated her country's first shipment from the Trans Mountain pipeline by declaring, “This procurement of crude oil is a concrete success story of cooperation between Japan and Canada in the field of energy security...and it is a matter of great joy”.

Geopolitical storms have created our opportunity, and the trade tensions with the United States are really driving Canadian public support for action. An Ipsos poll earlier this year showed that a staggering 83% of Canadians support growing oil and natural gas exports to customers outside the United States.

Canada's answer to energy security is to build.

I've spoken a lot about projects in western Canada, but last week I was in Atlantic Canada, where Nova Scotia and New Brunswick are taking steps to restart their oil and natural gas industries. In Newfoundland and Labrador, Equinor is nearing a final investment decision on its Bay du Nord project, which could be Canada's next big source of oil production growth. Recently, Quebeckers have been considering the future of natural gas in their province.

The government's recent direction really recognizes both the scale of the Canadian opportunity and the urgency of Canada acting on it.

The productivity mega deduction; amendments to the physical activities regulations removing specific types of energy projects from the Impact Assessment Act project list; measures introduced in Bill C-39, the building Canada strong act; and the designation of the Pacific link pipeline as a project of national interest all represent meaningful progress towards improving Canada's competitiveness, accelerating major-project delivery and narrowing the investment gap with the United States.

Taken together, these changes send a strong signal that Canada is back and Canada is serious about building.

The scale of the opportunity before Canadians is national, and realizing it will require alignment and ambition from coast to coast. Canada has always been at its best when governments, industry, indigenous communities and workers are moving forward with a shared objective.

Thank you for giving me the opportunity to present to the committee today.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you, Ms. Baiton.

We're going to go on to Mr. Jenkins for five minutes.

Mr. Jenkins, please go ahead.

James Jenkins Executive Director, Indigenous Clean Energy

Thank you, Mr. Chair and members of the committee.

Indigenous Clean Energy is an independent not-for-profit organization. We support capacity building, career training and mentorship for Inuit, Métis and first nations in the clean energy sector, and our programs are present in every region of the country.

Our intent is to ensure that this committee and government are informed of the proven impacts of indigenous participation and leadership in the energy sector and the importance of more efficient and tailored supports for diverse contexts.

Our mission at Indigenous Clean Energy is to achieve a collaborative, community-driven clean energy future, led by indigenous peoples. Our vision is an energy future that leaves no one behind. Understanding the co-operative approach of government, the time is now to integrate priorities and supports across jurisdictions and contexts.

I would encourage you to review the national survey that we published in May. It is called “Regenerative Energy”, and it highlights the growing and accelerating role of indigenous communities and businesses in ownership of the clean energy sector. We're tracking over 250 medium-sized to large clean energy projects that are post-construction, as well as another 100 projects that are either far into the planning process or under construction. The level of indigenous equity continues to grow each year, and with the new phase of construction, we're seeing more indigenous ownership and an exponential growth curve in the number of projects.

Today we're looking at the government's goal to catalyze energy infrastructure development and recognizing that this requires local capacity. Looking back at the number of federal programs that have been utilized by indigenous proponents for capacity, we see that the track record has been fairly positive. A key development is that many of these programs are sunsetting in this fiscal year, in March 2027, so the upcoming federal budget will be a very key turning point.

In terms of our programs, we find that our national capacity-building and mentorship programs are consistently oversubscribed and that there is high demand for region-specific connected programming. This was highlighted in a number of directional gatherings that took place across the country last year.

The conclusions and recommendations from our national survey are in three parts. We have three buckets of recommendations to continue to accelerate the indigenous role in the clean energy sector moving forward.

One of them is to review the funding and targeted programs that have been available from the federal government and to renew those programs that have been most effective. We have some recommendations in our report, but grant-based programs that are able to be utilized in early-stage project development have been very effective. We find that this is the highest-risk phase of both community-focused and utility-scale projects.

We're also recommending further investment in healthy energy housing. Indigenous housing is an area where there could be a very high return on investment for energy savings, dollar for dollar, and it has very positive social and health outcomes as well.

We've also identified the importance of a northern remote communities fund, with some of that funding currently under review. It has been enormously important for growing the capacity of indigenous communities in remote locations and in the territories. We also have some recommendations with regard to a continued focus on job skills and training.

Finally, we have a number of recommendations regarding technical and system supports. There's a growing role for indigenous communities and businesses in the larger grid system in electricity systems planning, so we want to make sure that there is enough capacity for that role to be meaningful.

We're also seeing a growing role in Canada's global partnerships and the role that indigenous communities in Canada have taken in becoming leaders on the global stage, demonstrating how indigenous leadership in clean energy can take place in a meaningful way. We're recommending further growth in that area.

Renewable energy microgrids are one of the three main areas and opportunities that we would like to highlight. We are starting to see some successful combined battery and renewable storage microgrids in places like Labrador, Nunavut and Yukon. We would like to highlight the potential for those, and also the passion and willingness of those communities to move these kinds of projects forward.

As well, grid-connected renewable energy projects of medium size, about 50 megawatts, will be increasingly important in such places as the Atlantic region, the west and the north.

Finally, there is community-scale energy efficiency, where there is the potential to significantly reduce costs and electricity consumption while also providing all those other benefits to social and health outcomes.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you, Mr. Jenkins.

Mr. Bowen from Manitoba Hydro, you have five minutes.

Dave Bowen Vice-President, Asset Planning and Delivery, Manitoba Hydro

Good morning, Mr. Chair and members of the committee. Thank you for the invitation to appear today.

My name is Dave Bowen. I'm a vice-president at Manitoba Hydro.

Canada's energy transition presents significant opportunities and practical challenges. We must balance affordability, safety, reliability, economic development, indigenous reconciliation, socio-economic impacts and environmental outcomes. These trade-offs shaped our most recent integrated resource plan, or IRP, and the recent general rate applications. Although not yet endorsed by our provincial government, our IRP balances reliability, affordability and environmental and socio-economic outcomes while supporting Manitoba's path to net zero.

I'd like to focus on a few areas where Manitoba's experience may help inform the committee's work.

The first is clean electricity technologies. Manitoba starts from strength. Roughly 97% of our generation is hydroelectric, providing some of Canada's lowest-emitting electricity, but demand growth and competing objectives mean that the next stage requires a portfolio of technologies. Our recommended plan within our IRP begins with efficiency and demand shifting to reduce peak-driven system expansion. It also includes up to 600 megawatts of indigenous majority-owned wind, enhancements to existing hydro assets, a small-battery pilot and 750 megawatts of combined combustion turbines initially fuelled by natural gas but with the potential use of renewable fuels as technologies and supply chains mature.

Natural gas remains critical for reliable and affordable home heat. On the coldest days in Manitoba, the gas system delivers one and a half times the electric system's capacity, accounts for 5% of Manitoba's GHG emissions from home heat and carries about one-fortieth of the electric system's debt. We cannot neglect this critical resource in the energy transition. We must, therefore, address peak-system needs and not simply substitute one energy source for another.

Second, Manitoba is winter-peaking, with energy demand about 40% higher in winter. Hydro generation averages about 32 terawatts an hour, but can range from a low of about 20 terawatt hours in severe drought to more than 40 terawatt hours in high-flow years. The operational challenge is dependable energy and capacity on the coldest days, not annual energy alone, and our dependable capacity surplus is shrinking. Meanwhile, we must meet NERC and MISO requirements. At the same time, our generating assets need life extension, and transmission and distribution infrastructure needs renewal. Tightening capacity margins makes the outages required for this work harder to schedule and increases customer risk. The response is an integrated one: conserve energy, manage peaks, sustain existing assets, modernize the grid and add capacity when needed.

Third, governments can strengthen economic development and Canada's energy security through the electrification supply chain. Utilities nationwide procure similar equipment, such as transformers, switchgear and circuit breakers, creating opportunities to align electricity investment with domestic economic development. There's an even bigger opportunity when we couple electricity investment with economic development.

Fourth, utilities are essential to Canada's net-zero objectives, but they cannot deliver them alone. Utilities should help develop practical solutions across electricity and natural gas systems, while governments, businesses, educators, skilled trades and customers coordinate implementation. Electrification should target the highest economic and environmental value. In Manitoba, transportation is a logical starting point.

A fifth point is that affordability and financial capacity matter for both Manitoba Hydro and its customers. Renewing this system while preparing for growth requires major investment. Federal programs are most valuable when they improve reliability, affordability and sustainability for utilities and customers.

Finally, energy security does not necessarily mean energy isolation. Manitoba has benefited from interconnections, particularly with the U.S., where intertie capacity is nearly seven times the combined capability with Ontario and Saskatchewan. These links support lucrative exports during surpluses and vital imports when conditions require. Additional interprovincial connections may improve energy security, but their business cases must resolve who pays when the benefits are regional or national rather than confined to one utility's customers.

I would be remiss not to mention our biggest constraints—people and capital. We need a specialized workforce and the financial capacity for large, long-lived investments. We need alignment among governments, regulators, utilities, indigenous partners and industry on the highest-value investments.

For Manitoba Hydro, success means a safe, reliable and affordable energy system that improves sustainability, advances reconciliation and enables economic growth towards a net-zero future. Utilities, governments, industry and customers must pursue these objectives together.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you, Mr. Bowen.

Thanks to all our witnesses for the presentations. We will now go to questions and comments.

We'll start with you, Mr. Kelly, for six minutes.

11:20 a.m.

Conservative

Pat Kelly Conservative Calgary Crowfoot, AB

Thank you.

My first question is for you, Ms. Baiton. It says on your website, “We heard loud and clear this week...that Canada must move faster to advance projects that can get our oil and natural gas to global markets and seize a once-in-a-generation opportunity to make Canada a true energy superpower.” You were referring to something that I think the head of the International Energy Association said.

Where do we get this “once-in-a-generation”? What about the last 11 years, when we could have been building major energy infrastructure, including, for example, the pipeline that this government cancelled within the first month it was elected in 2015?

11:25 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers

Lisa Baiton

Thank you for the question. The answer to Canada's energy security is to build and to grow our production and exports and global customers, just as other countries are looking to diversify supply. You know, Canada is now meeting the moment in diversifying our customers. We have come a long way in the last couple of years. The government's recent direction recognizes both the scale of this opportunity and the urgency of acting on it.

The next test will really be on execution—clear implementation, efficient and predictable approvals, and achieving that expanded market access. Importantly, a durable policy across all governments will really be critical to converting that momentum into more projects, jobs and prosperity.

11:25 a.m.

Conservative

Pat Kelly Conservative Calgary Crowfoot, AB

A durable situation, a durable set of regulatory approvals.... I would think a durable one wouldn't rely on ministers having to hand-pick or cherry-pick which projects they refer to the Major Projects Office. Would it not be better to just peel away and get rid of all the regulations and laws they passed before that rendered it impossible to get a major project approved? Would that not give investors better regulatory certainty?

11:25 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers

Lisa Baiton

I think two things can be true at the same time. I think it's really important that, after a lost decade, we can demonstrate to the global capital markets that we can put points on the board. It really is important to have major projects the world can see that demonstrate that Canada is back in the business again.

You mentioned the head of the IEA and his recent quote when he came to Canada. It was his quote, not mine, on the generational opportunity. I think what he said was that Canada has a reputation for being one of the most reliable and trusted trading partners in the world, but he also said that Canada has a reputation for being slow to act and slow to build, and if we miss this opportunity this time, it's a generational opportunity that will be lost. Those aren't the exact words, but that's the thrust of it.

I think it's really terrific. I cited a lot of those major projects in my opening remarks. It's really important for the global capital markets—

11:25 a.m.

Conservative

Pat Kelly Conservative Calgary Crowfoot, AB

I have only a little bit of time left and I have many questions.

11:25 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers

Lisa Baiton

Okay. I'll just quickly say that regulatory certainty across the board absolutely will be the second thing that's also true. We do need the regulatory to be stable through multiple decades. People are going to deploy large-scale, long-dated capital in the billions of dollars, and they need certainty across decades.

Thank you.

11:25 a.m.

Conservative

Pat Kelly Conservative Calgary Crowfoot, AB

Right. I did support Bill C-5—talking about doing two things at once—because we need to have some kind of a path forward, but it would be better, in my view and the view of many, to actually repeal the laws that prevent projects from getting built.

Perhaps I can ask about the investment gap, as you mentioned, during this lost decade that I think we can both acknowledge has happened. Can you describe the scale of this? Can you describe the investment deficit or the gap between what's invested in oil and gas in Canada and the United States or other competing producers?

11:25 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers

Lisa Baiton

What I would say is that we have some catching up to do, but I've listed a lot of things that have happened, even in the last year, which are profoundly helpful. Bill C-39 is a significant step towards providing speed, certainty and predictability to build major projects in Canada. Any measures to streamline federal reviews, establishing—

11:25 a.m.

Conservative

Pat Kelly Conservative Calgary Crowfoot, AB

I have only a few seconds left. I need a quick yes or a no. Have any major projects actually been approved yet?

11:25 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers

Lisa Baiton

We've just seen the Pacific link pipeline added to the major projects list. We've had LNG Canada 2 reach FID last week, which was profound. On the offshore, we're hoping to get to first production on west White Rose in 2027, and, hopefully, FID also—

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you both.

Mr. Hogan, you're up for six minutes.

Corey Hogan Liberal Calgary Confederation, AB

Thank you, Chair.

Thank you to the witnesses.

I'm always glad when there's a Calgarian on the panel, so thank you, Ms. Baiton, for being that Calgarian today.

On October 1, the government declared the west coast oil pipeline, now known as Pacific link, a project of national interest. It's an exciting project, celebrated by the Premier of Alberta, communities across Canada and, of course—as I know—many people in this room, as my colleagues across the way had asked for this in a motion on June 2. At the time, we'd said it was already the government's intent but that Alberta had not yet submitted a proposal. They have. We reviewed it. We accepted it. There will be shovels in the ground this year, so I think that is something we can all be excited about.

It is, of course, part of a broader MOU that commits the governments of Canada and Alberta to a number of additional actions—including reaching net zero by 2050, meaningful methane reductions, an industrial price on carbon backed by contracts for differences, significant investment in carbon capture—creating that durable foundation for both conventional and renewable energy projects that we seek.

Last week also saw final investment decisions on LNG Canada phase two. The week before, it was the introduction of Bill C-39, the building Canada strong act, which we've already been talking about. This just continues on a list of projects, many of which are already under construction, such as sunrise and Coastal GasLink. It's an exciting time for energy in Canada and energy security.

Ms. Baiton, in thinking about energy self-sufficiency and domestic energy security, you said that the scale of the opportunity is national, and I do agree. The national opportunity is driven by international demand and, as you said, our reputation as a trusted supplier.

Mr. Bowen, you talked about the security opportunity that integration with the United States unlocks.

I wonder whether you can both expand on the intersection, opportunities, tensions and risks between international opportunities and domestic energy security.

Ms. Baiton, maybe we can start with you.

11:30 a.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers

Lisa Baiton

Sure, and I'll recap some of the remarks I've made prior to this.

I think there's been a real wake-up call, globally and geopolitically, about how critical energy security is to our continental security, to our national sovereignty, to our domestic energy security and to our economic security. You've seen that in public opinion. You've really seen a profound understanding, in real time, of what that looks like.

The response by team Canada, federally and provincially, to really ensure that we protect our sovereignty and our energy security.... It's time to build and grow our production and our exports and meet that global demand. We're really starting to see some pretty significant milestones in taking down the regulatory and fiscal stack that was repelling capital over the last decade. There's still a lot more to do, but it's profound. It's a major step forward in rebuilding that investor confidence and getting people to look at Canada again.

Corey Hogan Liberal Calgary Confederation, AB

Mr. Bowen, what are your thoughts on the integration and how integration might present both opportunities and risks to energy security?

11:30 a.m.

Vice-President, Asset Planning and Delivery, Manitoba Hydro

Dave Bowen

In the Manitoba context, I think we're similar to other major hydro provinces. We've had interties with the U.S. for the better part of three decades. I noted that with the predominantly hydro system, there's almost a range of...low to high is about a factor of two.

The marketplace in the U.S. is probably 10 times larger than the marketplaces to the east and west of us, and there are different products that are available, such as diversity agreements. In the U.S., for MISO, there's summer peaking or winter peaking. We have an exchange—basically, about one-tenth of our system is in diversity contracts. It's a free issuance of megawatts to the U.S. in the summertime, and then we get those megawatts in the wintertime. There are huge benefits to that. Energy security is a real issue we need to think about, but we would be remiss to dismiss the U.S. relationship and the value it provides for us, both for affordability and reliability in the future.

When we think about interties to Saskatchewan and Ontario, the interties that we've developed over the years have had a generation play with the transmission play. When we think about how we make that work for Canada, we should be thinking about those same things in the future.

Corey Hogan Liberal Calgary Confederation, AB

Thank you.

I think the integration of electricity is similar to the integration of crude and petroleum products. There is a lot of north-south connection that both countries have benefited from.

Ms. Baiton, you talked about being a model of indigenous participation and how Canada is viewed as that. I'm hoping that you can expand on that, on what that looks like and how it might support energy security.