Good afternoon, and thank you to the committee for this opportunity to share the perspective of Environmental Defence on Canada's electrification, energy self-sufficiency and domestic energy future.
In general, Environmental Defence welcomes the Government of Canada's recognition that electrification is central to Canada's climate goals and its pursuit of energy and economic sovereignty. Canada's wind energy, solar energy and energy storage sectors will provide the power an electrifying and growing economy needs. However, we are deeply concerned that the strategy as presented risks entrenching Canada's dependence on fossil fuels rather than accelerating our transition away from them.
The discussion paper the government released earlier this year, “Powering Canada Strong: A National Strategy for an Electrified Canadian Economy”, positions natural gas as “strategic” and “essential” to Canada's electricity future. This is wrong on two counts. First, it's wrong as a matter of climate policy, and second, it's wrong as a matter of economics.
Canada's electricity sector is already approximately 80% non-emitting, a global advantage we must build on and not squander. The path forward must prioritize wind, solar, energy storage, demand-side management and grid modernization, not a prolonged reliance on natural gas justified by short-term cost or reliability concerns that can be directly addressed through clean alternatives.
In fact, surging emissions from gas-fired power plants, which have doubled in the last decade to 40 megatonnes in 2024, have already erased half of the gains made by cleaning up Canada's electricity sector by phasing out coal. Natural gas is a fossil fuel, most of which is fracked in Canada. A full life-cycle analysis of the emissions of natural gas, which is how its impact would be best measured, demonstrates that gas can be just as polluting as coal, given the huge volumes leaked in extraction and transit.
The latest data on the cost competitiveness of energy sources demonstrates that gas is more expensive than renewable energy, even when compared with renewables paired with battery storage. This was further supported by the outcomes of recent procurements in Ontario. Adding greenhouse gas abatement technology like carbon capture would only serve to make gas significantly more expensive while almost certainly failing to reduce emissions to near zero, which must be Canada's overarching goal.
Independent analysis from Environment and Climate Change Canada, which commissioned five modelling firms and was presented in October 2024, demonstrates that a near-zero-emissions electricity grid by 2035 is achievable and economically viable across most of Canada. The modelling shows that all scenarios result in substantial emissions reductions under the clean electricity regulations, with collective reductions ranging from 182 to 588 megatonnes of CO2 equivalent between 2025 and 2050 across all five models.
The average cost of abatement across all models is $58 per tonne over the 2025 to 2050 period, which is well within the range of cost-effective climate action and far below the social cost of carbon. All models built grids that respected the policy constraints of the CER without any rupture in the ability to supply energy and capacity. The modelling confirms that the primary driver of cost in achieving near-zero emissions is not the regulations themselves but the pace of transmission build-out and the availability of flexible resources like storage, interties and demand response. The answer to grid reliability concerns is more investment in clean flexibility, not more gas.
The proposed amendments to the clean electricity regulations, as articulated in Canada's discussion paper, represent a dangerous and unacceptable rollback of Canada's most important regulatory tool for grid decarbonization. If the government moves forward with these changes, it will undermine the regulatory certainty needed for clean energy investment, delay the transition away from fossil fuels and create serious stranded asset risk while damaging Canada's international climate credibility.
Canada has a diverse electricity supply mix, including one of the best hydro power resources in the world. Canada has other abundant clean energy resources, from solar to offshore wind and geothermal. Coupled with existing clean energy resources, they can be used to deliver the goal of a net-zero electricity grid. In fact, few other countries are better positioned to achieve this goal than Canada.
Once again, thank you for this opportunity. I look forward to your questions.
