Thank you, Mr. Chair.
It's an honour for me to share some thoughts with this important committee.
First, Canada's nuclear energy sector is significant domestically and internationally, Canada is a significant player in the nuclear energy sector. As you know, Canada is the world's second-largest producer of uranium. We are one of the few countries with a clean nuclear technology: the Canada deuterium uranium reactor, known as CANDU. This technology has been exported to several countries. In Ontario in particular, nuclear energy is very big.
In a world that is fighting climate change—unfortunately, we aren't really in that world yet—nuclear energy is indispensable. There will need to be some, because it will be extremely important to replace coal in many countries.
Now that I've made these very positive points about nuclear energy, which I believe and support, we need to take stock of Canada's situation, which is unique. Canada does not have enough opportunities to speak candidly and present the real figures.
First, nuclear energy in Canada and Ontario is particularly expensive. Ontario Power Generation, or OPG, sells its nuclear power to Ontarians for about $110 a megawatt-hour. A look at Hydro-Québec or hydroelectricity production in other provinces shows that this energy is sold at $40 a megawatt-hour. Thus, nuclear power is very expensive for Ontarians.
We also have an interprovincial trade problem. There has been a lot of talk in the last two years about the need to open up trade between the provinces, but there has never been active talk, to my knowledge, about opening up the electricity trade between the provinces further, removing interprovincial barriers so that Ontarians can benefit from hydroelectricity, which is much cheaper in Quebec, and ensure complementarity between the provinces.
Second, the small modular reactors that are being built in Ontario are very expensive. The investment comes to nearly $21 billion for a 1,200 megawatt capacity. Analysis shows that production will cost at least $150 a megawatt-hour, and that is only the capital cost. That doesn't include operating costs. Canadians and Ontarians need to be aware of this cost to be able to make the right decisions.
However, in several Canadian provinces, there is a very poor understanding of electricity prices. Notably, in Ontario, which is the largest producer and consumer of nuclear energy, the price consumers pay for electricity doesn't reflect the costs to generate it. For example, the Ontario electricity rebate reduces the price consumers pay by 15–20% compared to what it costs to generate electricity in Ontario. Consumers aren't aware of this and don't pay the true price for electricity in Quebec, Ontario or other provinces. They pay a price that is distorted by different policies.
That's a problem, because it doesn't send an energy efficiency signal to consumers. Because consumers pay less and taxpayers pay the difference, in Ontario in particular, energy efficiency is not at the level it should be. This is a fundamental problem, because we, in Canada, overconsume electricity and energy in general. We are a country that consumes a lot of energy. When we talk about producing more electricity or energy, as an energy economist or as someone who is interested in energy saving, I always have an issue with that, because we are overconsumers. Before talking about producing more energy, we should do our homework on energy consumption.
I'll close with a final point that relates to what I said about pricing. We have very problematic economic foundations in the electricity sector in Canada. The rates are too aligned with the average cost. In Quebec and in the majority of provinces, the marginal cost of production isn't known. Ontario has a market, so we should be able to know the production cost and market price, but the overall adjustment completely distorts the understanding of prices. Ontario's electricity rebate once again distorts consumers' understanding of pricing.
Furthermore, there's a lack of interprovincial trade and integration between the provinces. If we want to add nuclear energy to Ontario and Canada, we need a far more coherent economic foundation, so as not to invest billions of dollars in a shaky economic foundation, as is the case today.
