Mr. Chair, members of the committee, thank you for inviting me to appear.
Before I begin, allow me to briefly introduce myself. I am a professor of physics at the University of Montreal and Scientific Director of the Trottier Energy Institute at Polytechnique Montréal. Among other things, my remarks draw on the work we are conducting at the Institute on transforming Canada's energy system within a global context of energy transition based on the accelerated electrification of energy services. This work includes our flagship publication, Canadian Energy Outlook, from the Trottier Energy Institute.
The global energy crises of recent years, caused largely by Russia's war against Ukraine and the attacks by the United States and Israel against Iran, coupled with global efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions—which are continuing despite Canada's marked setback in this area—and the emergence of new electricity-intensive sectors, have reignited interest in nuclear power worldwide. This trend, as you know, is very positive for Canada. I'd like to raise three specific points on this matter.
First, let's consider the strengths and weaknesses of nuclear energy. The strengths of nuclear energy are significant: a small footprint, a high capacity factor, low greenhouse gas emissions and, in the case of Canadian nuclear reactor technology, or CANDU, a wholly domestic industry. However, nuclear power continues to suffer from high costs at a time when the price of renewable technologies, particularly solar and batteries, continues to fall. It also lacks the flexibility to respond swiftly to major fluctuations in demand, particularly in the context of the electrification of heating, has a long deployment time frame—often exceeding a decade—and faces uncertainties regarding related technologies, including, among others, small modular nuclear reactors.
Thus, it is important not to be blinded by the industry's sweeping promises, but to properly understand the true role of nuclear power in a rapidly electrifying world.
First, despite its costs, nuclear power ensures a basic energy supply and public safety while reducing the public's exposure to global crises. However, its lack of flexibility means it cannot directly support intermittent renewable energy sources or manage seasonal peaks in demand. Therefore, the share of nuclear power must remain relatively small within the electricity generation mix in order to keep costs down while still providing a reliable service.
Then, if Canada wishes to maintain an industrial sector, it must prioritize technologies it already owns rather than importing American technologies.
Finally, we must draw on lessons learned from the refurbishment of CANDU reactor cores when planning new builds, as this will reduce some of the risks associated with reactors during the construction of new units.
That was my first point about nuclear energy.
Second, we must not forget to support research in the nuclear sector by allocating funds to it. If Canada is serious about developing the nuclear market, both at home and internationally, we must focus on training the workforce, which requires substantial and sustained support for fundamental and applied research. But support programs come and go, which greatly complicates the recruitment of lecturers, the development of training programs and the recruitment of students.
Although it is possible, in the world of research, to receive support from non-targeted funding, it is absolutely essential that, in a context that seeks to deploy nuclear power, sustainable research and maintenance funding be established to ensure the training of staff, but also to ensure access to the high value-added knowledge that requires.
Finally, Canada cannot be content merely to support the nuclear sector in the electricity or energy fields—it must also explore and support other cutting-edge sectors. Photovoltaic solar and wind power technologies are already mature, so there is little room for further gains in those areas. However, in other sectors, such as large-scale, long-term energy storage, for example, technologies are still being developed. Canada, given its climate, has a direct interest in this area. It therefore seems urgent to me that Canada identify sectors beyond nuclear power where its contribution could also be significant, and that it make efforts similar to those that led to the creation of the CANDU reactor.
Those are my three points. I'll stop there.
Thank you very much. I'd be very pleased to answer your questions.
