I apologize for the general nature of this answer. I've been part of the Government of Canada since 2018 and obviously joined at a point after much of the original concern with Phoenix had been realized. The questions have, I believe, been asked historically, and I believe that the government has indicated...or that accountabilities have been realized but that these are confidential HR matters.
I don't believe that I have specific additional information that I can share with the committee about the events of 2016, 2017 and 2018. I apologize for not having this information. I don't know if others may have additional information they can share, but I believe this is covered by the broad confidentiality provisions of employment law.