I want to be clear, I don't think my threshold is protection. My threshold is the Canadian charter, and that allows the legislator to draft in a number of fashions. Unfortunately, here I think the drafting is pretty clearly going against it.
There are already provisions in the Criminal Code that allow for preventive arrest. I'm not here to say whether they are okay or not okay, but they're already there, and they allow for preventive arrest if the agent believes that the person will commit a crime, and they have to get a mandate from a judge to do so unless they're unable to do so. That's already in place.
Now what we've done is change that threshold. Now I'm translating freely because I don't have the legislation in English in front of me, but it's if the person may commit.... That to me is not about protection; that is really too large. I think it's important to give law enforcement a clear indication of what they can and cannot do. I think what it does is actually create more problems for law enforcement because these will be contested. There will be legal procedures that stem from these, and then that's what the whole issue becomes. It doesn't become about security.
I think that's important when you're doing your work. My work is to see if there's a violation. Your work is to see if it is justified under section 1, and it's to ask what the necessity is to change it. When we're changing that, are we trying to actually stifle dissidents, or is there a risk that that's the way it appears? Are we really in need of it being more efficient? I don't think that demonstration has been made. I think it really goes too far.
