Thank you very much for that discussion.
Mr. Lloyd, you have the floor for five minutes.
Evidence of meeting #10 for Public Safety and National Security in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was privacy.
A recording is available from Parliament.
Liberal
The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos
Thank you very much for that discussion.
Mr. Lloyd, you have the floor for five minutes.
Conservative
Dane Lloyd Conservative Parkland, AB
Thank you.
I'll start with Mr. Dufresne.
Will you be providing recommended amendments to committee to address the concerns you have laid out today?
Privacy Commissioner of Canada, Offices of the Information and Privacy Commissioners of Canada
It's been requested in the exchanges, so we'll follow up with specifics.
October 30th, 2025 / 12:05 p.m.
Conservative
Dane Lloyd Conservative Parkland, AB
Thank you.
You were the Parliamentary law clerk and counsel for a number of years. Is that correct?
Privacy Commissioner of Canada, Offices of the Information and Privacy Commissioners of Canada
Yes.
Conservative
Dane Lloyd Conservative Parkland, AB
You also served on the Human Rights Commission as legal counsel?
Privacy Commissioner of Canada, Offices of the Information and Privacy Commissioners of Canada
I did.
Conservative
Dane Lloyd Conservative Parkland, AB
That was for many years, so it's fair to say that you have a lot of experience in this.
We've had a chance to ask the department about the powers that have been provided to the minister in proposed section 15, specifically about the authority to compel the telecoms to remove services for a specified person. They gave assurances that the scope of the legislation doesn't pertain to free speech or content that otherwise poses no threat to the integrity of the telecommunications system.
Do you believe that the scope and the reasonableness requirement that has been outlined in this legislation is clear enough to restrict the potential abuses of these legislative powers?
Privacy Commissioner of Canada, Offices of the Information and Privacy Commissioners of Canada
In terms of the section that you're referring to as it relates to the order-making power under the Telecommunications Act in proposed subsection 15.2(3), there has been an addition to require that it must, “in scope and substance, be reasonable in relation to the gravity of the threat, including that of interference, manipulation, disruption or degradation.”
I think this doesn't use the words “necessity and proportionality”, but there is that sense of balance, so I would find that achieves my goal of making sure that you have security and privacy. It's a balance and we don't want to have a zero-sum game, where you go too far in limiting the agency's power to protect Canadians, or you go too far in harming Canadians' privacy. I am comfortable with that clause.
It's the other clauses, in terms of some of the other powers, where we're talking only about necessity or about relevance, that I would want to see strengthened to bring in this key concept of proportionality.
Conservative
Dane Lloyd Conservative Parkland, AB
Can you elaborate further on what you just spoke about—where we would want to see further strengthening?
Privacy Commissioner of Canada, Offices of the Information and Privacy Commissioners of Canada
When we look at necessity and proportionality at my office, it's a little bit of the same test as under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. It balances the fundamental rights with the important public interest imperative. You need to ask yourself these things: What is your goal? What is your objective? Is it important enough? What is your measure? Is your measure effective?
Conservative
Dane Lloyd Conservative Parkland, AB
Can you be specific about these measures in the bill that you're talking about?
Privacy Commissioner of Canada, Offices of the Information and Privacy Commissioners of Canada
In that context, we have the power to ask an organization not to use a certain provider. There may be a national security concern with a specific company linked with a specific country. Looking at that, then you're going to look at the measures that you're putting in place. Are you overreaching? Are you doing something that just goes too far, relevant to the threat?
If you have a major threat, you're going to be able to have a higher measure. If the threat is smaller, more contained, you need to make sure that you're not doing collateral damage.
Conservative
Privacy Commissioner of Canada, Offices of the Information and Privacy Commissioners of Canada
I think it has been incorporated in the section on the order-making power. I don't think it's been incorporated elsewhere in terms of information requirements or on the cyber side.
Conservative
Dane Lloyd Conservative Parkland, AB
Okay. Thank you.
I'm going to move on to the intelligence commissioner.
You raised some really interesting concerns about warrantless search and seizure, and you talked about content. I know the department took pains to assure us that they're not really concerned about the content that's going through the pipes; it's about whether or not an action is a threat to the pipes themselves.
Can you elaborate on your concerns about warrantless search and seizure and about content? Could you give us some more clarity on that?
Intelligence Commissioner, Office of the Intelligence Commissioner
With regard to the warrantless search and seizure, it really triggers section 8 of the charter. It's evident for any judge. It stands out, more so when there are penalties provided for that in the act. That triggers more—and that's the Supreme Court saying that.
If you look at what you have in this bill now, you don't have anything.
Conservative
Dane Lloyd Conservative Parkland, AB
Can you provide an example of when that section 8 right could be triggered by this legislation? Can you provide a specific example?
Intelligence Commissioner, Office of the Intelligence Commissioner
In any search and seizure, if they go into an office and open up, without a warrant, and start searching, it's evident that there's an intrusion being done.
There are two ways to go into an office. One is that you go in and say, “Would you mind giving the following documents?” The other way is that—
Conservative
Intelligence Commissioner, Office of the Intelligence Commissioner
—we're going in because we want to go and get that document. Usually, the police force needs—
Conservative
Dane Lloyd Conservative Parkland, AB
Don't they have other legislative tools in Canada to do that anyway?
Intelligence Commissioner, Office of the Intelligence Commissioner
Under the Criminal Code, there are certainly some provisions on that, but if you look at the Criminal Code, you will see that a warrant will be required.
Liberal
Liberal
Sima Acan Liberal Oakville West, ON
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
I will be sharing my time with Ms. Dandurand, if there's any left.
Thank you for coming today.
My question will be for Mr. Stupak.
Thank you for your testimony and for speaking on the importance of this bill.
I echo your point on the implications of a cyber-attack on our infrastructure from monetary and security perspectives. Under Bill C-8, designated operators will be required to adopt comprehensive cyber programs and report incidents essential for baseline protections.
You have expressed strong support for Bill C-8. Given your experience and extensive knowledge on similar laws in Europe or the Five Eyes, particularly in the U.S., when it comes to federal policy and workplace development, you have experienced what worked and what didn't work.
With two questions, I would like to focus on implementation capacity and professional standards. First, how prepared is Canada's current cybersecurity workforce to meet the compliance and technical demands that Bill C-8 introduces?
Second, from your international perspective, how does Bill C-8 align with similar frameworks in allied jurisdictions, and where should Canada prioritize harmonization to reduce compliance challenges for global firms?