Thank you, Mr. Chair.
My name is Josh Dehaas. I'm counsel with the Canadian Constitution Foundation. The CCF is a non-partisan charity dedicated to defending Canadians' rights and freedoms through education, communications and litigation. The CCF is most famous for successfully challenging the invocation of the Emergencies Act in February 2022. The Federal Court found that the invocation was ultra vires the statute and violated the rights to freedom of expression as well as security against unreasonable searches and seizures.
The CCF has serious concerns about one particular aspect of Bill C-8. Proposed section 15.2 would allow unconstitutional limits on freedom of expression, peaceful assembly and association. Proposed subsection 15.2(1) would give the Minister of Industry a dangerous new power to order telecommunications service providers to cut individuals off of Internet or phone services based on “any threat” to the telecommunications system, which includes all of Canada's Internet, phone and radio infrastructure. This need not be a systemic or even a serious threat.
Proposed subsections 15.2(5) and (8) would allow the details of the minister's orders to remain secret under the threat of huge fines. While there may be circumstances where the minister requires the power to order malicious servers to be cut out of the system, it's dangerous to civil liberties to allow the minister the power to cut off individual Canadians without proper due process and to keep that secret.
Consider, for example, a protester whom the minister believes may engage in a distributed denial of service, or DDOS, attack, which is a common form of civil disobedience employed by political activists. Using proposed section 15.2, the minister could order that this dissident's Internet and phone services be cut off and require that the decision remain secret. That individual's only recourse would be to hire a lawyer at great expense to contest the minister's order. That order would remain in place unless and until a court hears the case and orders restoration of the services. The person affected may not even be aware that they're entitled to judicial review, because the statute does not require that they be informed of their right to challenge that order in court.
To be clear, DDOS attacks are genuine cybersecurity risks. They are a criminal offence. However, somebody merely suspected of planning to participate in such civil disobedience could be silenced. Without the Internet or phone, they would be effectively cut off from all online expression. They would be prevented from constitutionally protected political activities, including speaking out in opposition to policy or meeting with others online—violating expression, assembly and freedom of association.
While the statute appears to be a good-faith attempt to prevent and stem cyber-attacks, it does not include proper safeguards to prevent abuse. Statutes passed in good faith are often used to violate rights, particularly in periods of political and social unrest. For example, the federal government ordered financial institutions to freeze hundreds of accounts without due process during the invocation of the Emergencies Act. This left some protesters and their domestic partners unable to pay bills in the middle of a very cold winter and violated their rights under section 8 of the charter. The government also used the act to block protesters from simply standing on Parliament Hill with the Canadian flag or a placard opposing vaccine mandates, violating their right to expression.
In other words, we can't just trust governments with this sort of power. There must be better safeguards built into the bill.
The CCF has five proposed amendments that would reduce that civil liberties risk.
First, the CCF proposes that proposed subsection 15.2(1) be modified to clarify that the power to cut off services may only be used in cases of serious systemic risks.
Second, the CCF proposes that the statute make explicit that judicial review is available and that services may be restored immediately by a judge.
Third, the CCF proposes that the statute limit the secrecy of any order by requiring that it be published in the Canada Gazette within 90 days unless the minister obtains an order from the Federal Court prohibiting the disclosure of some or all of its contents.
Fourth, the CCF proposes that such orders may only be kept secret where a Federal Court judge is satisfied that there are reasonable grounds to believe that the disclosure of some or all of the order would be injurious to international relations, national defence or national security or endanger the safety of any person.
Finally, the CCF proposes that where the judge is of the opinion that it is necessary to protect the fairness of proceedings for an individual impacted by such a decision, they may appoint an amicus curiae to assist that individual.
Thank you for your time. I'd be happy to answer any questions.
