Thank you for both of those questions. They're extremely pertinent.
On the workforce question, Canada has a very robust workforce. You have an impressive workforce that has the tools and capabilities to implement Bill C-8.
I will be honest. We all need more. We need more professionals within this space. We need more people who have certifications that indicate they have the necessary skills in order to do the work that needs to be done. This is important. Too often, we are focused on education and whether someone has the necessary degree, but what we're really looking for are the skills in order to do this work.
There are efforts under way under the NICE framework, for example, to define what those functions are that every role within cybersecurity should have, and then how you meet those functions. This is being developed. I think this is something that is not robust enough across borders, but the point is that you do have the capability to begin implementing. You are going to need to do more education. You are going to need to do more training. You're going to need to do more certification.
On the question of international frameworks, because you do take the sectoral approach and it is directed at a particular sector, I think you are very well aligned with the United States and how we have historically done this—by looking at each sector and what needs to be done within that sector. Not all sectors are equal. Bluntly, the water sector within my country is not at the same level as financial services. You do need to have that approach, because not everyone is ready to do the same thing at the same time.
I would compare this also to the NIS2 standards from within the European Union. That is not how I would recommend to do this. There, they take much more of an auditing perspective, and it's impossible to audit all critical infrastructure as frequently as you need to. Moreover, the compliance regime is simply not mature enough or robust enough yet to comply with NIS2.
I appreciate that this bill takes more of a sectoral approach, which is more like the United States and a little less like the European Union.
