Thank you, Mr. Chair.
While the term “confidentiality, integrity or availability” sounds protective, it is, in my opinion, dangerously overbroad in the technical sense. The term “availability”, specifically, is a major issue. If the government orders a company to replace faulty or vulnerable equipment, that process might temporarily take a system off-line, which technically impacts the availability. These amendments could be used to legally block the government from requiring the removal of high-risk equipment, such as from Huawei, or from fixing legitimate security flaws because the act of fixing them causes a temporary disruption.
My questions will be for the experts and are technical.
If the government identifies a piece of hardware in our network that has been compromised by a foreign actor or others, it's immediately replaced. Would the inclusion of the legal ban on impacting availability prevent us from acting if the replacement process requires a temporary service outage?
