In part 2 of the act, one of the challenges that occur with CPC-40 is that it creates significant confusion as to the way personal information would be administered under the act. This arises from the commingling of the definition of personal information with confidential information.
I'm happy to give you an example here. Personal information under the Privacy Act is accessible by Canadians. There's a requirement to retain that personal information for two years. Canadians can request that information, can seek to correct that information and can seek recourse based on that information.
The confusion here arises because that information would now need to be treated as confidential, so it creates an interpretive question: If somebody requested that information under the Privacy Act, what would happen in that case? Would we need to keep it confidential, or could it be disclosed?
What exacerbates this challenge is that, in part 2 of the act, we have several organizations administering this act—not just Public Safety but regulators as well—so it certainly, at a minimum, creates a risk of conflict with the Privacy Act.
There's also a potential challenge in the administration of the act. If personal information has to remain confidential, there is a question as to how that could be interpreted when a regulator tries to exercise their regulatory power.
