Thank you.
Good afternoon, Mr. Chair and honourable members of the committee.
My name is James Hamilton. I'm the executive director of the Used Car Dealers Association of Ontario. We represent and advocate for nearly 5,000 motor vehicle dealers, new and used, lessors, recyclers, rental companies and associate members across the province of Ontario, with some members outside of Ontario as well, across Canada.
As this committee studies the Canada Border Services Agency's role in maritime trade and port practices, we want to address a critical security gap, speaking to a data piece. That's vehicle identification number cloning and revinning. Some of you have likely read about or heard about this in the media as a growing phenomenon. It's likely the result, frankly, of organized crime pivoting away from the ports, where we've seen some success in stolen vehicle intervention. They're simply shifting to other means. This is a scam in which thieves will use legitimate vehicle identities to disguise a stolen or salvaged car, making it appear legal to sell. Essentially, criminals create fake VIN, plate and ownership documents to match a similar vehicle in another jurisdiction, or at least with a VIN that decodes as a real VIN. They can then sell that stolen vehicle with a cloned VIN to an unsuspecting buyer here in Canada. Oftentimes, those buyers are our members, the dealers, who are often on the front line of the transaction. Ultimately, the consumer is the one who's going to be harmed, however. It can lead to innocent buyers being denied insurance in the event of an accident or when they have to make a claim, or the vehicle being confiscated by law enforcement because it is, in fact, stolen and eventually the law enforcement folks track it down.
CBSA maintains a database of the VINs of every vehicle exported from Canada. In order to help law enforcement identify stolen vehicles and reduce the flow of revenue to organized crime groups, our association is presently seeking a data-sharing arrangement with CBSA to make use of that data. This would enable our members, for example, to search whether a VIN on a vehicle they're thinking of buying has already been exported, which would be a red flag to them that it's likely a clone or a revinned stolen vehicle. They wouldn't, of course, buy it. Instead, what they would do is alert law enforcement officials to a potential problem car.
VINs from exported vehicles are particularly useful. The reason is that they're real VINs on a vehicle that really existed and is no longer here in Canada, so it's ripe for use on a stolen car. It's not unlike using a deceased person's identity to create identity theft or fraud, because it's an identity that's real. The VIN was real; it's just not here anymore, so they're ideal. We have seen instances where these VINs are appearing on vehicles that are being purchased by dealers. We think this is yet another way for dealers to have a data source to protect against that. It's not going to solve all the problems. As was mentioned earlier in this session, auto theft is a complicated and complex issue, and there's no one single solution. Whenever somebody suggests that there is, that's probably misleading, but this is another piece, and it's easy to do because the data is there.
Currently, the CBSA is sharing that data, the very data I speak of, with private foreign-owned entities and insurers, but they deny it to Canada's own registered dealers through our association, the very people who could flag these ghost vehicles at the point of trade-in and before resale.
The UCDA attended the federal auto theft summit held in Ottawa in February 2024. This was at the height of the auto theft crisis, which was particularly virulent in Ontario and Quebec at the time. The port of Montreal featured prominently as a focal point of concern at that time as well. Much has been accomplished, as I mentioned, since then, and auto theft numbers have been going down, thanks in large part to efforts to make illegal export more difficult for criminals at the ports. Équité, who some of you may know are very active in the auto theft file and have a lot of good data, have suggested that auto theft in Ontario is down 20%, but we need to be cautious about celebrating too much, because auto theft in Canada still represents approaching a $1-billion loss to insurers in 2025.
Criminals are nothing if not flexible. Revenues derived from stolen vehicle activity account for the third-largest source of revenue for organized crime after drugs and guns, and they use that money to fund drugs and guns anyway. They are not going to forgo that revenue just because one avenue is closing to them. They'll simply pivot. They're doing this by focusing more intently on the domestic market for stolen cars.
It is still the case today that a VIN on a stolen car could be registered in Ontario with an exported VIN. That's because the MTO in Ontario doesn't know that VIN was exported, as it's not getting that data from the CBSA either. At the summit in 2024, the CBSA agreed that data is a major tool in the fight against auto theft. We agree, and we would like to be a partner with the CBSA in protecting consumers in Ontario.
Thank you.
