Evidence of meeting #33 for Public Safety and National Security in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was cbsa.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Read  Director General, Marine Policy, Department of Transport
Grenier  Director, Marine Analysis, Department of Transport
Paquet  Partner, Aviseo Consulting
Hamilton  Executive Director, Used Car Dealers Association of Ontario
Tod  Vice-President, Operations, Eastern Canada, VIN Verification Services Inc.
Chartrand  Senior Consultant, Aviseo Consulting

Sima Acan Liberal Oakville West, ON

Thank you.

UCDA has an interest, as you also mentioned to us today, in having a data-sharing arrangement with the CBSA. Your organization, as I mentioned, represents approximately 5,000 dealers of new and used vehicles. I know that the CBSA mentioned to you, Mr. Hamilton, that privacy concerns surrounding the VIN's personal information are considered customs information under the Customs Act. In addition, CBSA shares some information with two organizations, Équité and Carfax, but not all the information. They share only a certain amount of information.

Could you please elaborate on what a collaborative data-sharing arrangement between your organization and CBSA would look like in practice? Specifically, how would your organization's data-handling protocols help bridge this information gap while ensuring that the privacy and security standards are strictly maintained?

5:20 p.m.

Executive Director, Used Car Dealers Association of Ontario

James Hamilton

Speaking for our organization, we're already familiar with the security protocols that are required for the handling of that kind of data, because we receive from the Ministry of Transportation in Ontario plate registration data, data on vehicle ownership and the names of people who own the vehicles, and we get lien search data from the Ontario government through the different ministry that provides it. They all have us requiring security, cyber-protection and privacy protocols whereby we purge data on a regular basis. We don't hold it longer than we need to. We're sensitive to those issues. I would have to say that we would be as cognizant of those concerns as Carfax is.

Sima Acan Liberal Oakville West, ON

Thank you very much for your answer.

Mr. Tod, one of the steps in combatting vehicle theft is our ability to scan and improve the ability of our ports of entry to process containers. Unfortunately, criminals present themselves as legitimate importer-exporters, act like brokers, or say that they are in the used car business when exporting through our ports. Could you speak to the importance of intelligence sharing as a tool to catch fraudulent actors or stolen vehicles?

5:20 p.m.

Vice-President, Operations, Eastern Canada, VIN Verification Services Inc.

John Tod

I could speak to it a bit, not being in the policing and intelligence community anymore. I think that the more information that's shared, the better. There's no doubt about it.

I think there are some safeguards that have to be put into place, particularly when you're dealing with a private sector company in that type of environment, whether it's part of the insurance industry or not. Definitely, the greater the information sharing, the better. It helps to build that network of information that goes back to put cases together long before they reach the ports, for sure.

Sima Acan Liberal Oakville West, ON

Thank you very much.

The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos

Thank you, Ms. Acan.

I'm sorry to interrupt again.

Mrs. DeBellefeuille, you have the floor for two and a half minutes.

Claude DeBellefeuille Bloc Vallée-du-Haut-Saint-Laurent, QC

Two and a half minutes is short.

Mr. Paquet, speaking from an economic standpoint, to create wealth, would the government be well advised to invest and support small and medium-sized specialized ports to diversify and enhance supply chain fluidity? Did your study draw that conclusion?

5:20 p.m.

Partner, Aviseo Consulting

Mathieu Paquet

The study drew the same conclusion that there were gains in terms of productivity, tax revenues and gross domestic product for Canada, Quebec and Ontario. It also spoke about modestly diversifying and expanding Canada Border and Customs Agency services at the six ports studied.

I would also like to say that we're talking about relatively focused investments for all the projects considered, not billions of dollars. These investments could have an impact fairly quickly, depending on when the port projects reach maturity.

Claude DeBellefeuille Bloc Vallée-du-Haut-Saint-Laurent, QC

The agency has challenged the $54,000 in costs to bring two officers to the Port of Valleyfield to clear a few containers a month and has said that the cost would be much higher.

You have said that even if it's higher, it is a cost-effective project. Is that correct?

April 21st, 2026 / 5:20 p.m.

Partner, Aviseo Consulting

Mathieu Paquet

Yes. I'll come back to the ratios. If you multiply $54,000 by 10, you get $540,000. The study came up with very conservative assumptions, or $2.1 million per year for the federal government. From an economic standpoint, these ratios make a lot of sense. If you look at real gross domestic product per year, we're talking about $5 million.

Even if we were far off the mark, this is still a good project.

Claude DeBellefeuille Bloc Vallée-du-Haut-Saint-Laurent, QC

The agency confirmed to the committee that mobile radiation portals are legal and that they met the requirements of the agreement with the United States. Saint‑Bernard‑de‑Lacolle and Lacolle municipalities are quite close to Valleyfield and strategically close to the Port of Valleyfield, which could have the services of customs officers.

How would you explain that reluctance to support a project such as the one in Valleyfield?

5:25 p.m.

Partner, Aviseo Consulting

Mathieu Paquet

You'd have to check with the government of Canada. We only looked at the economic side of things. As the study shows, this project makes a lot of economic sense.

Claude DeBellefeuille Bloc Vallée-du-Haut-Saint-Laurent, QC

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos

Thank you very much for this discussion.

Mr. Gill, you have the floor for five minutes.

5:25 p.m.

Conservative

Sukhman Gill Conservative Abbotsford—South Langley, BC

Thank you to all the witnesses who are testifying here today. It's been a pleasure to listen in on the discussion today.

My first question is going back to the used car dealerships and those dealers. How often are they coming across cars with these VINs that are compromised? Could you expand on that, please?

5:25 p.m.

Executive Director, Used Car Dealers Association of Ontario

James Hamilton

It is increasingly common. It isn't to the extent where it's every other deal, for sure, but we mentioned the pivot that organized crime will engage in. As it becomes harder for them to easily export stolen cars out of various ports, they're going to pivot. One of the ways they pivot is in the domestic market.

They're not going to necessarily seek to send a car to Dubai. Now, they're going to try to sell it to someone in Brampton. Inevitably, our members are going to and are seeing this more commonly. They learn about it usually as a result of a police officer attending to seize the vehicle or take it from one of their customers.

John Tod mentioned salvage parts. That's a growing concern. Again, organized crime has realized that the constituent parts of a vehicle are worth quite a lot of money. You have catalytic converters and airbags, and these things are worth a lot of money. Revinning or cloning can also feed into the salvage and recycle market, and that is a growing concern for that market as well. This has many different tendrils.

5:25 p.m.

Conservative

Sukhman Gill Conservative Abbotsford—South Langley, BC

Mr. Tod, would you like to expand on that?

5:25 p.m.

Vice-President, Operations, Eastern Canada, VIN Verification Services Inc.

John Tod

I can add some numbers and context to that.

In Alberta and Saskatchewan, where we provide the service on behalf of those two governments, we're finding a stolen or revinned vehicle among roughly every 80 to 90 vehicles, depending on the province.

Translate that over to Ontario with its population, and with one million vehicles entered into the registry every year. If we're talking 1% to 2% of those vehicles having a fraudulent, problematic, cloned or stolen VIN—whatever you want to call it—it adds up, very quickly, to a large number of vehicles going into the registry, being legitimized and being sold to unsuspecting consumers. The only way you can identify them is through a physical examination.

5:25 p.m.

Conservative

Sukhman Gill Conservative Abbotsford—South Langley, BC

We see how this organized crime thing pivots to ships. We see, in the research, how the police and all the services there are trying to make sure they can get on top of it.

You mentioned some pivots. What is your biggest worry factor, given how organized crime is playing out?

5:25 p.m.

Executive Director, Used Car Dealers Association of Ontario

James Hamilton

In a perfect world, I'd like to see a national registry, where all the registries—Alberta, Ontario, Quebec and B.C.—are linked in such a way that they can easily determine whether a VIN is registered in a certain place at a certain time, and whether that VIN isn't appearing in, say, two jurisdictions at the same time. Believe it or not, that happens. You could run a search on Carfax. If it showed a registration being used in Quebec and B.C. at the same time, everyone would go, “Well, that's a clone.” If we saw the same VIN in the U.S. and Ontario....

I suppose what I'm saying is that we have the data. It's there. It's just a question of how it's used.

Interestingly, when we went to the 2024 federal summit that got this discussion kicked off—it was quite successful in that regard—there were people in the room who could really make a difference. The RCMP, I learned, were not providing VINs on the CPIC database to Interpol. They had been asked to do that for many years, but they just weren't, for whatever reason—privacy or otherwise. Within two weeks of that conference in February 2024, the RCMP started sharing those VINs with Interpol. It was as simple as throwing a switch. It was low-hanging fruit. Not all data solutions are going to be that easy, but Interpol found thousands of vehicles in Europe that came from Canada as a result of that sharing.

It can be meaningful, and it can cost very little to nothing. It's just a question of will.

5:30 p.m.

Conservative

Sukhman Gill Conservative Abbotsford—South Langley, BC

I also recall your mentioning how crucial it is that CBSA data be shared with all organizations like yours. I want to understand why that is being delayed to this extent.

What can we do to make sure we are taking advantage of the information we collect? You follow all the measures. You follow all the protocols. What are the roadblocks here?

5:30 p.m.

Executive Director, Used Car Dealers Association of Ontario

James Hamilton

That's an excellent question to which I wish I had an answer.

One of the surprises, I suppose, when we embarked on this was.... We thought we were on the side of the angels with the request we were making to CBSA. I stand somewhat surprised at how difficult it has proven to be to get them to see the advantages. They have never told us why they've chosen to share it with Équité and Carfax but not with organizations like ours.

I'm not suggesting that Carfax and Équité shouldn't have it—quite the opposite. I think more should, if they are proper users and can show they have legitimate reasons.

The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos

I'm sorry, MP Gill. Thank you for that great conversation.

5:30 p.m.

Conservative

Sukhman Gill Conservative Abbotsford—South Langley, BC

I just got started.

The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos

Thank you, Mr. Hamilton.

We'll now turn to MP Ehsassi for five minutes.