Evidence of meeting #35 for Public Safety and National Security in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was visa.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Gary Anandasangaree  Minister of Public Safety
Lena Metlege Diab  Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship
Gallivan  Deputy Minister, Department of Citizenship and Immigration
O'Gorman  President, Canada Border Services Agency

Gary Anandasangaree Liberal Scarborough—Guildwood—Rouge Park, ON

Ms. Kirkland, I completely appreciate the work you've been doing, especially with CBSA.

I want to clarify the role of CBSA.

First of all, it's an independent agency, which means that political interference is not something that is part.... I'm unable to direct CBSA on a range of issues, because it's independent.

Second, any time there is an issue of danger or issues that will pose a risk to Canadians' safety and are not in line with IRPA, it is the strictest prerogative of CBSA to enforce its provisions through the Immigration and Refugee Board or through other mechanisms. It is not a routine process. I would be fully surprised if, under any circumstances, a minister's office from IRCC is able to override.

Having said that, there are specific provisions that enable me to provide stays. You would have seen some of the stuff in the media. I have provided stays on occasion. There are a number of cases in Quebec where there was a misinterpretation and families were being separated. I immediately intervened and issued stays, and President O'Gorman gave further direction to her officers.

There is a very specific, narrow set of circumstances in which there could be ministerial discretion, but that's used sparingly, and it's not used in any way from a political perspective. I have been tracking the stays I've issued. I've issued stays to a number of Bloc MPs' constituents, and I believe even to a Conservative MP's constituent, but they are used sparingly in the interest of ensuring fairness and equity. I want to just clarify that for the record.

Marcus Powlowski Liberal Thunder Bay—Rainy River, ON

Minister Diab, do you have anything you want to add, or do you, Deputy Minister Gallivan?

Lena Metlege Diab Liberal Halifax West—Peggy’s Cove, NS

Yes, just to clear up.

4:20 p.m.

Deputy Minister, Department of Citizenship and Immigration

Ted Gallivan

On the question about IRCC as a decision-maker not going with CBSA advice, it's important for the committee to know that this is in cases where there's an inconclusive finding. In other words, a case gets referred for security screening and there are clear red lights. In those cases, IRCC decision-makers will enforce the red light.

There's a second group of yellow lights, where the information is inconclusive. It's derogatory information, but it may not meet the legal standard. The latest data I have is that in 46% of the cases, IRCC agents are granting permission to enter the country despite that information.

Having come from CBSA—I testified last week—that's something I want to see very closely. I spent three and a half years at the border service, and I know it's a concern. Now that I'm in this chair, I want to understand the veracity of the 46%, but I believe that goes to the crux of the question.

Marcus Powlowski Liberal Thunder Bay—Rainy River, ON

Do I have any time left?

The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos

You have one minute.

Marcus Powlowski Liberal Thunder Bay—Rainy River, ON

Minister Anandasangaree, I know that you were involved in human rights cases before you went into politics. What concerns me a lot in the testimony we've heard today is that if you commit a criminal act in Canada, as a result you're deported from the country. I think we have reasonable trust in the legal system in Canada, but certainly, as we both know, there isn't that same level of trust in other legal systems.

I constantly wonder about that when they say that somebody has committed a crime in another country. A lot of countries have corrupt police and a corrupt judiciary. How do we know, with a person who's been convicted in a country where we don't really trust the legal system, whether we ought to be sending them back to their country?

Gary Anandasangaree Liberal Scarborough—Guildwood—Rouge Park, ON

We have some very specific laws, especially with respect to senior members of the IRGC and their association with the regime. We are much more conclusive in those cases, just because there is a decision of cabinet. They are listed as a terrorist entity. Under Canadian law, a number of them have been sanctioned. An allegation against an individual, a senior member of the IRGC, should be taken at face value.

Having said that, I think routinely the CBSA challenges the findings. That's why we have a process through the IRB whereby an individual may be able to bring their case forward. With respect to the—

The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos

I'm sorry to interrupt, Minister. I'm always sorry to do it, but we need to move on to the next slot, which is MP Au and MP Gill for five minutes, please.

4:25 p.m.

Conservative

Chak Au Conservative Richmond Centre—Marpole, BC

I'm going to share my time with MP Gill.

Ministers, you've been trying to hide behind the excuse that you cannot comment on individual cases, but something went wrong. You know that the permit was being issued to that person. This is a shame, a failure and a mistake.

Somebody has to take responsibility. Who has to take responsibility? Will somebody have to resign, yes or no?

Gary Anandasangaree Liberal Scarborough—Guildwood—Rouge Park, ON

I will say that the issuance of any temporary resident permit is not within the purview or authority of the Minister of Public Safety or any one of the agencies.

Lena Metlege Diab Liberal Halifax West—Peggy’s Cove, NS

From an IRCC perspective, these are done as a last resort for specific cases that are allowed under the IRPA.

Chak Au Conservative Richmond Centre—Marpole, BC

I will repeat my question. A mistake has been made. Will somebody be accountable? Will somebody have to resign, yes or no?

4:25 p.m.

Deputy Minister, Department of Citizenship and Immigration

Ted Gallivan

If I can, I'll make two points quickly.

First, decisions are made based on the information available. It's clear in this case that the decision made wasn't the one we wanted.

I'm the deputy minister of IRCC. I am accountable. I'm not going as far as offering my resignation by answering, but I want to make clear that I'm accountable. It happened under my watch.

I'm very motivated to tighten the controls within Canada's immigration system. I've been on the job for six weeks, and I see lots of opportunities to improve. I'm accountable, and I'm not offering my resignation today.

4:25 p.m.

Conservative

Chak Au Conservative Richmond Centre—Marpole, BC

A mistake has been made and you said that you're accountable. What steps will you take to take on that responsibility?

4:25 p.m.

Deputy Minister, Department of Citizenship and Immigration

Ted Gallivan

There are a number of changes being made across IRCC, first, in relation to visa processing—

4:30 p.m.

Conservative

Chak Au Conservative Richmond Centre—Marpole, BC

I'm talking about you personally.

The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos

I'm sorry, MP Au. If you want to split the time in half, it's the time to do so. I don't want to interfere in your sharing of the time, but two and a half minutes have passed.

4:30 p.m.

Conservative

Sukhman Gill Conservative Abbotsford—South Langley, BC

Thank you very much for that, Chak.

My colleague Rhonda asked earlier if you were ever briefed about Mr. Taj prior to him ever landing in Vancouver. You guys did not answer the question. Yes or no, were you ever briefed? Could you please answer the question?

Lena Metlege Diab Liberal Halifax West—Peggy’s Cove, NS

About who...?

4:30 p.m.

Conservative

Sukhman Gill Conservative Abbotsford—South Langley, BC

I'm asking about Mr. Taj, who landed in Vancouver. It's the case you referred to that's going on this week. You didn't know which date either.

Lena Metlege Diab Liberal Halifax West—Peggy’s Cove, NS

I'm not aware that anybody landed in Vancouver.

4:30 p.m.

Conservative

Sukhman Gill Conservative Abbotsford—South Langley, BC

I'm sorry; that's my bad. It was Toronto.

As to the IRGC agent who landed in Canada, were you ever briefed on that case prior to them landing in Toronto? It's a yes or no, for either minister. Could one of you please just say if you were ever briefed?

Lena Metlege Diab Liberal Halifax West—Peggy’s Cove, NS

The individual in question was in a plane on the way. The document was cancelled—

4:30 p.m.

Conservative

Sukhman Gill Conservative Abbotsford—South Langley, BC

So you were briefed.