I understand that. I'll tell you where I'm coming from on this. In this instance, the state or the government is compelling an action, and that action relates to information over which there is a reasonable expectation of privacy. That's why you need a warrant. The moment you say to provider A that they need to keep this, there's a reasonable expectation of privacy over what must be kept. Is everybody with me so far? Okay.
Does that not engage section 8? I might be out to lunch here, but I've been asked this question, so it's something I'm looking to explore.
