The difference with Bill C-8, though, Minister.... If you want to get into Bill C-8, that is exactly my cautionary tale. The Liberals voted against just about every amendment that was of consequence. It was the Conservatives and the Bloc that voted for those amendments, that swayed those amendments, with the government often voting against them. Now things have changed. With all due respect, Bill C-8 is not a great example to use. That's why I'm trying to get it on the record.
I think I've made my point. You've made your point. Let's move on.
The ministerial order is one of the biggest things. One of them, as I said, is encryption; another major issue is the degree to which enforcement and definitions are left to regulation. That's one of the primary criticisms of this bill.
I look at proposed section 5, for instance. This is sweeping powers. Proposed paragraph 5(2)(b) says, “the installation, use, operation, management, assessment, testing and maintenance of any device”. Proposed paragraph 5(2)(d) says, “the retention of categories of metadata”. Minister, I get why the government wants things to be broad; it's because then you can account for things. However, should we not be defining things where we can define them? I'm pretty sure we're going to have experts who say, “Do you know what? We can define categories of metadata.” I'm sure we can define categories of metadata. Those don't change every day.
Would you be open to an amendment that says that when we're looking at taking information from people over which there's a high expectation of privacy...? I trust you would support an amendment that would define those types of things.
