Thank you, Chair.
Ministers, I appreciate your being here.
I appreciate what you say about supporting our frontline officers. Lawful access has been called for over many years. I do think, though, that we have to be careful not to rush something through. We need to get it right. We need to balance, as parliamentarians, our duty of care that we are protecting the privacy of Canadians. My questions will be based on that. I think we have to be careful not to race to royal assent. We have to do this right.
More than a decade ago—I don't know if you're aware of this—your party warned against a bill very similar to this. It was a lawful access bill. They said it risked turning Canada into a surveillance state. Today you are advancing similar powers, but actually in a more expansive form, with Bill C-22. In fact, Mr. Francis Scarpaleggia, our current Speaker of the House, was at the time the Liberal public safety critic. He warned that similar lawful access legislation, in his words, risked “creating an Orwellian service state”.
My question for you is this: Was he wrong?
