I certainly understand from the law enforcement perspective why they would want all the data they need to be available for as long as necessary, but in terms of charter protections, my opinion is informed by what I've read of European jurisprudence on this issue.
Also, it's not just that it's one year. It's one year for any type of data for any purpose: for mischief or for investigating jaywalking, for example. I'm not saying that's what they would do, but it's the fact that it's for any purpose, for any type of data, that creates a chill in people that they could be under surveillance when all of their data is being held for this long period of time.
Right now, there's nothing that constrains the retention. It's any type of data for a year, for any purpose, and I think that's what needs to be amended to make sure that it's more narrowly tailored to the type of data, the requirement and the investigative imperative.
