No, I'm just relying on the broad propositions under section 8. Section 8 is engaged whenever a state actor interferes with something over which we have a reasonable privacy interest, so I gather that the question you're asking is about a mere demand by a state agent of a third party to hold on to the private data that belongs to the person over there. Is that an interference with their privacy? Again, 12 years ago, Parliament assumed that, if a court were to look at that, they would find that it would be an interference with their privacy.
In other words, I can't think of a body of case law where police told third parties to preserve data and then it was challenged in courts. I can't think of that. The story for me begins with the power, the preservation power, and when that was added to the code, it was added, I'm assuming, on the premise that requiring a third party to do this for the state for a law enforcement purpose is an interference that engages section 8.
Once again, stand back and ask yourself how you would feel if you were told that Telus, Rogers, etc. are preserving a record of all your movements and the people to whom you sent emails, not the content but those details? How would you feel? They're preserving it for up to a year for the purpose of potentially prosecuting you if necessary.
Maybe one answer is that it's absolutely fine, but I think most Canadians and, I think, courts are likely to say no. They would think that the mere fact that I was visiting this person on this day or talked to this person is private. That should be private. There should be no record kept of it, and that is, I think, the best explanation I can give you as to why.
