Yes. I have one thought to put out on the hypothetical that has been floated a number of times to justify the metadata preservation power: the kidnapping of a 14-year-old girl, her trafficking, etc.
That is an effort to recycle something like the ticking-bomb scenario of 20 years ago. We heard a lot about the ticking-bomb scenario as a justification for torture. I want to be careful here, but the idea was about taking an extreme situation and using it to justify and normalize powers that are otherwise beyond the pale.
The committee should think about whether this is happening here. We're taking an extreme scenario—something that, if it does in fact happen, is very rare and unusual—and saying that all Canadians should give up a significant amount of freedom, security and privacy to enable law enforcement to be a little more effective in this remote scenario.
