When a law is challenged and a court is asked, “Does this allow for reasonable search and seizure?”.... That's not the way they approach it. They stand back and ask, “When two Canadians are communicating in a restaurant, for example, would they think it's reasonable to assume that their conversation is private? If they are texting each other, would the reasonable Canadian assume that their texts are private?” That's the way they do it.
When this goes to the Supreme Court of Canada eventually, the question will be, “Would the ordinary, reasonable Canadian assume that the record of their texts over the past year, or the record of their movements, remains private?” in the sense that they were not recorded by the state for a law enforcement purpose, based on the potential that these random Canadians could have been committing a crime. Ask yourself that question. If you were a judge, would you think it's a stretch, or would you say, “Of course we don't want our movements recorded.”
