This is without actually believing that a crime has been committed, without swearing an affidavit saying, “I believe that a crime has been committed, and therefore, Your Honour, I get a court order.”
I would like to dispose of some of the legal arguments that the Liberals make. I'd like to get specific, if I may, with Mr. Diab.
One of the arguments that is made on section 8, which is the arbitrary seizure.... What the government is proposing to do is to seize metadata, all of it, and order that it be held for 365 days, without knowing or suggesting that any offence has been committed. However, there's some jurisprudence on section 8—arbitrary search and seizure—that suggests that “seizure” requires a production. Here, we have no production.
How do you respond to that?
