We don't think it respects the Supreme Court's decision at all. Proposed new section 487.0142 of the Criminal Code is very broad, referring to “all the subscriber information…including transmission data”. That can all be captured through the IP address. Furthermore, if you read the Supreme Court's decision in Bykovets—which isn't that old—properly and carefully, you see that the majority of the court viewed the IP address as a gateway.
Search and seizure doesn't work the same way anymore. Before, when police officers did a search, they showed up at the individual's home and either they found something or they didn't. Now, with the IP address, they can access just about anything about the person, medical records, what they dream about, what they post online and all kinds of other information. On top of that, the bill says that the information can be retained for a year, which is like giving authorities access to a huge data bank they can use to spy on people or find whatever information they want.