I'm going to start the answer and then pass this to my colleague Mr. Wong, because he answered your question about 2011. They set up something more akin to the international community, where it was done administratively. It didn't require a warrant from the judiciary. That might be important for you, so I'll let him speak to it. Unlike Mr. Wong, I was not here in 2011 or 2013.
To start the answer, I want us to again step back and remind ourselves and the committee that this is exactly what policy development is in the criminal law space. We think about section 8 because, as you pointed out, we have a charter. We have to be charter-compliant when we're thinking about balancing privacy rights and the needs of law enforcement.
It was a policy choice based on what we've talked about tonight: What is law enforcement seeking? What is the goal or objective of the tool? What are they trying to achieve? As we talked about earlier, these have to be calibrated when the tool is used. It's all those different factors, like the type of information being sought, when the tool is used and the nature of the privacy being intruded upon. That's how we came up with that standard.
If it assists you at all, I always like to compare. When you're looking at financial data and it's “grounds to suspect”, we think, “Well, this is a bit less than that.” If it's about a warrant to search your home, we think, “Well, that's reasonable and probable grounds. We're not going in anybody's house. We're just asking if Kim Gibner is a client of yours, yes or no.” It's those sorts of considerations we came up with for this policy.
Mr. Wong.
