We definitely do not think that it offends section 8. It's going to be up to this committee to make that decision about the standard. We're here to make sure that you have the information you need. We've tried really hard to set out the thinking. That's what we're here to do, to make sure that you have the answers to your questions.
Without repeating myself I always want to start with first principles, which is, what is the purpose of section 8? It is the balance of the state interest of law enforcement and privacy interests. Spencer was about whether we were even in the realm of section 8, whether there was a privacy interest at all. The court confirmed that we are, and that the world of policing had changed. For this type of information, they needed lawful authority. When we're drafting a bill for your consideration, we are looking at the state of the law. There are all sorts of reasonable grounds to suspect. Somebody pointed out to me earlier today one of the provisions you probably dealt with more in your career than I did, which is the reasonable grounds to suspect for a roadside breathalyzer.
