Evidence of meeting #54 for Public Safety and National Security in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was rights.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Freeman  Victim Rights Advocate, As an Individual
Mac Donald  Executive Director, Plaidoyer Victimes
Roebuck  Federal Ombudsperson for Victims of Crime, Office of the Federal Ombudsperson for Victims of Crime
Blanchette  Regional Vice-President, Quebec, RCMP–Justice–PPSC–CSC Community–PBC, Union of Safety and Justice Employees
Ménard  Regional Vice-President, Quebec, Correctional Service of Canada, Union of Safety and Justice Employees

The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos

I call the meeting to order.

Good morning, everyone. Thank you for joining us on this beautiful and sunny Monday morning. Welcome to meeting number 54 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security.

Pursuant to Standing Order 108(2), we're meeting today to review conditional releases and the responsible federal organizations.

First, I would like to welcome our two witnesses, both of whom are participating remotely by video conference. We're joined by Lisa Freeman, a victim rights advocate who is appearing as an individual. We're also joined by Karine Mac Donald, the executive director of Plaidoyer Victimes.

Good morning and welcome, Ms. Freeman and Ms. Mac Donald. You both have five minutes for your remarks.

Ms. Freeman, you have the floor.

Lisa Freeman Victim Rights Advocate, As an Individual

Good morning, and thank you.

As the daughter of a man who was murdered, my life has been brutally divided into two distinct parts, before my dad was killed and after. My father's murder didn't just take his life, it took pieces of mine, too. It stole my sense of security and safety, and I can say the very same thing about the day the parole process began to unfold. Once again, my life was divided into a before and after. My father was murdered once, but I have been forced to live the devastation of his murder over and over again.

Since the parole process began unfolding for the man who murdered my dad, I have learned three painful truths that have forever changed the way I see the justice system in this country.

First, I have learned that the words, "sentenced to life in prison" does not mean what a victim's family or the Canadian public believes they mean. They are words handed down by a judge in a courtroom and echoed in newspaper headlines and media reports. These are words that grieving families here hold on to and believe, words that offer the public a sense of safety and reassurance, reinforcing the belief that those who have committed the most heinous crimes are securely behind prison walls, no longer able to threaten the communities they have already devastated.

Second, I have learned that the security of the institution does not necessarily reflect the severity of the crime. I have learned that someone convicted of taking another person's life can be transferred to an institution with progressively lower levels of security, that restrictions can be reduced, freedoms can increase and conditions can change, even though the seriousness of their crime has never changed. My father is still gone. The circumstances of his murder have not changed, yet the circumstances of the person responsible for his death can continue to improve.

Last, I have learned why I and so many other people whose lives have been devastated by crime feel such overwhelming frustration, anger, helplessness and exhaustion while navigating the Parole Board of Canada and Correctional Service Canada. It is because the system was not designed for us; it was designed for the offender, yet we are expected to navigate an incredibly complex system, learn its rules, and understand its language.

Speaking of language, if there is anyone in this room who can help me challenge and ultimately change the misleading words used within our justice system, in particular the words, "sentenced to life in prison and no parole for 25 years", I sincerely ask that you connect with me. Words matter. Victims, families and the public alike deserve honesty, clarity and transparency from the beginning, not painful discoveries, years later, when the police are forced to issue public safety warnings urging citizens to remain vigilant because yet another dangerous offender has been released into their community.

Think about the disturbing contradiction in that. We have a system that tells grieving families and their loved ones that their killer has been sentenced to life in prison, yet years later we have the police warning the public to protect themselves because a dangerous offender is amongst them. How can we expect the public to have confidence in a system when the language used to describe a life sentence creates one expectation of life imprisonment, while the reality is something entirely different? If the public needs to be warned about the potential danger posed by someone being released into their community, then surely the public deserves to understand from the very beginning what that person's sentence actually means.

That brings me to one final question, one that every Canadian deserves to have answered. How have we reached the point in this country that someone who deliberately takes another person's life can be permitted to leave prison without an escort and spend up to 72 hours in the very communities we are supposed to be protecting?

At what point did providing opportunities for offenders begin to take precedence over the peace of mind for victims' families and the safety of the Canadian public? When Correctional Service Canada makes a decision to let convicted murderers and child killers enter the community without an escort, that decision does not exist in isolation. Its consequences extend beyond the offender, beyond the institution and beyond the correctional system itself. They reach into our neighbourhoods and our communities and, if something goes wrong, it's not simply the correctional system that bears the consequences; it's the innocent Canadians who pay the price, just as my father did all those years ago when his killer was approved for parole and their paths crossed.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos

Thank you, Ms. Freeman.

Ms. Mac Donald, you have the floor for five minutes.

Karine Mac Donald Executive Director, Plaidoyer Victimes

Mr. Chair and committee members, my name is Karine Mac Donald. I'm the director of Plaidoyer Victimes. Our organization advocates collectively for and promotes the rights and interests of victims of criminal offences and their family members across Quebec. Thank you for giving us the opportunity to contribute to this study.

The decision to release an individual must take into account a number of factors, including public safety and the individual's reintegration into society. However, it must also fully take into account the rights of victims.

Today, we would like to draw your attention to four issues surrounding the effectiveness of the rights set out in the Canadian Victims Bill of Rights, or CVBR. These rights include the right to information, the right to participate in hearings, to right to protection for victims and the right to make complaints.

First, I'll talk about the right to information. Since the adoption of Bill S‑12, the court must determine whether a victim wishes to receive information—

The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos

Ms. Mac Donald, sorry to cut in. You may be speaking a bit too quickly for the interpreters. You have a great deal to say.

11:10 a.m.

Executive Director, Plaidoyer Victimes

Karine Mac Donald

Okay. I'll slow down a little bit. However, I want to read my text in five minutes, so I'm hurrying.

Since the adoption of Bill S‑12, the court must check whether a victim wishes to receive information on the enforcement of the sentence. However, this contact information can't be passed on to the Correctional Service of Canada, or CSC, until January 7, 2027—three years later—so that the CSC can take the initiative to contact the victim. We welcome this progress, but a number of questions remain. For example, how soon will victims be contacted? How can we ensure that they will actually be reached and supported throughout the process? Do the CSC and Parole Board of Canada, or PBC, have the necessary resources to handle the anticipated increase in the number of registered individuals? On a broader level, how can we ensure that this reform will actually improve the access to information? What happens when the victim can't be reached before the release of the offender? What steps are taken and what measures are in place to ensure the victim’s safety? Access to information isn't just about receiving a notice, either. The information must also be clear and understandable. Do victims know that they can ask for the reasons behind a release application? Can they obtain explanations regarding the conditions imposed to ensure their safety?

Second, I'll talk about the right to participate in hearings. Simply allowing victims to make a statement isn't enough. They must also be given the means to truly participate in the hearings. Some victims report significant restrictions on their ability to speak. They don't always understand how their comments are used. The access to hearings also poses a challenge, particularly for people who live in remote communities—including certain indigenous communities—or who want to attend the hearings in person. Let's look at a concrete example. The Office of the Federal Ombudsperson for Victims of Crime reports that some victims were informed of a hearing only 9 to 16 days in advance. That isn't much time to make arrangements. This time frame is too short to obtain a financial advance in order to pay for a plane ticket, for example, since the request must be submitted at least 30 days before the hearing. On top of that, there are last‑minute postponements and cancellations. Victims must then reschedule their travel plans and adjust their work and family commitments, all while sometimes preparing to relive emotionally challenging experiences. We would like to invite the committee to consider ways to improve the predictability of hearings, the support provided to victims and the access to financial assistance. This issue is all the more important because, even though Bill C‑235 seeks to extend certain parole ineligibility periods, it fails to address the matter of repeated hearings. Once a person becomes eligible, parole applications may be reviewed every two to five years, sometimes for many years. For victims and their families, this means having to regularly relive the uncertainty surrounding a potential release, prepare for new hearings and sometimes speak again about the consequences of the offence.

Third, I'll talk about the right to protection. The decision to grant release must genuinely take into account the safety concerns of victims. This specifically includes geographic restrictions and no‑contact orders. Victims should also be able to understand the reasons for imposing or denying the conditions that they requested, and how compliance with those conditions will be ensured. Confidentiality is another important issue. To advocate for their protection needs, some victims must disclose highly personal information. We support the ombudsperson's recommendation to allow, under certain circumstances, a partial summary transcript of their statements.

Fourth, I'll talk about the complaint mechanism. Recognizing rights in the legislation is one thing. However, victims must also have concrete ways to ensure respect for those rights. In 2024‑25, the CSC received only 17 complaints from victims under the CVBR. This number raises questions. For example, are victims aware of the complaint mechanisms? Are these mechanisms accessible enough? Do victims trust these mechanisms and their ability to resolve a situation? We also believe that the independence and powers of these recourse mechanisms should be reinforced.

Lastly, I would say that this isn't about pitting the rights of victims against the rights of offenders. It's about ensuring that victims' rights can actually be upheld at every stage of the correctional and release process. It's also about ensuring respect for the rights of offenders upon their release. We would like to ask the committee to recommend concrete measures to ensure that the rights of victims are effectively upheld. This plays a key role in strengthening their trust in the justice system.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos

Thank you, Ms. Mac Donald.

We'll now move on to questions from the members.

Ms. Kirkland, you have the floor for six minutes.

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

Rhonda Kirkland Conservative Oshawa, ON

Thank you, Chair.

Lisa, thank you for being in our committee again. I appreciate the time that you are giving to this. Your continued advocacy on behalf of victims of violent crime is an inspiration. You didn't ask for this, and yet you've continued to advocate for other victims, as well as yourself. I know personally you've had many instances where you've helped other victims with their impact statements and other things, so I just want to thank you for that.

I know it's an issue deeply personal to our community, and you're from Oshawa, so your experience is a powerful reminder that these decisions affect real families right here at home.

Lisa, the other witness today mentioned a couple of things that brought to mind instances in your story, so I just wanted to ask you about them. You said at the end of your statement that the killer was approved for parole before he crossed paths with your father. I just wanted to clarify that.

11:15 a.m.

Victim Rights Advocate, As an Individual

Lisa Freeman

Yes, you're correct. My dad's killer was on parole for several years before he crossed paths with my dad. I don't know what crime he was on parole for. I don't know what crime he had committed because that was never disclosed to me. It was actually quite late during the parole process that I was even told that he was on parole previously, because it did not come up in the trial. That was a surprise to me and my family.

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

Rhonda Kirkland Conservative Oshawa, ON

Thank you, Lisa.

Ms. Mac Donald also mentioned roadblocks to attending hearings, and I believe you also encountered some of those.

11:15 a.m.

Victim Rights Advocate, As an Individual

Lisa Freeman

Yes, for sure, there was short notice for the hearing times and dates. As Ms. Mac Donald said, you do need to give 30 days' notice, and sometimes people cannot get the funds together to pay for accommodation and travel, so that essentially cuts them out of it. There are so many roadblocks.

As you know, I've spoken before about decisions being made without hearings even happening, so that's a massive roadblock that I've faced many times. Then there's the pressure I feel within myself to practically beg for a hearing so I can attend and represent not only myself, but my family as well.

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

Rhonda Kirkland Conservative Oshawa, ON

Was there an instance where you thought you might not be able to attend a hearing in person?

11:15 a.m.

Victim Rights Advocate, As an Individual

Lisa Freeman

I've always made an effort to attend as often as I could, and I haven't missed one. However lately, certainly in the last few years as parole unfolded, the most difficulty I've had was actually securing a hearing itself, instead of paper and in-office decisions happening, which gave everything to the offender. Of course, he's going to be there with his support team, and there's nothing for me and my family to attend.

To answer that question, what was the biggest challenge, there were three different incidents of me having to ask and beg for a hearing. When I say beg, I truly mean I had to beg for a hearing, instead of these monumental decisions of day parole and full parole being decided in the office without me being able to contribute in person my victim impact statement.

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

Rhonda Kirkland Conservative Oshawa, ON

Thank you for sharing that, Ms. Freeman.

You did mention in your statement other offenders receiving unescorted temporary absences. I would be remiss if I didn't mention what we've been seeing in Oshawa. What message do you believe it sends to families in Oshawa, particularly for those who have experienced tragedies like yours, when offenders like Darren Scott Ray, for instance, a convicted murderer, was granted unescorted temporary absences in a community where some of the classmates of the boy he murdered live? Recently, there was the case of Keith Constantin, a convicted a high-risk offender, whose release prompted public safety warnings from the police.

What message does it send to families in Oshawa, do you think?

11:20 a.m.

Victim Rights Advocate, As an Individual

Lisa Freeman

I think the message is very clear, that somehow, at some point in time, the opportunities for the offenders supersede the safety of the families. That's maybe not physical safety, because you don't know if you're going to cross paths with this person, but just that security that the family would feel that this person is put away for life in prison, wouldn't be out, and certainly wouldn't be out on an unescorted pass, a day pass or a 72-hour pass. It just is inconceivable that that would happen, yet we know it does happen. I think it happens more than the public and the families know. I know it happens more often than the public is aware of.

11:20 a.m.

Conservative

Rhonda Kirkland Conservative Oshawa, ON

Thank you.

You said in your statement that the system was not designed for victims; it was designed for offenders. We have seen that continuously to be true. You've spoken with me previously about the list of things offenders get. You're not suggesting that offenders be stripped of any rights, are you? You're simply saying that victims need to be considered. Is that right?

11:20 a.m.

Victim Rights Advocate, As an Individual

Lisa Freeman

I would never say that offenders should be stripped of their rights. I think it should be that victims of crime should have even rights. They should have even access to programs that offenders have. For people who have done nothing wrong, it's so uneven it's almost laughable.

As I said in my statement, somewhere along the line, the rights and opportunities for offenders have superseded the rights of the victims of crime. That is wrong. I don't know why it's been allowed to go this far in regard to victims having no rights.

The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos

Thank you, Madam Freeman.

Madam Sodhi, you have six minutes, please.

Amandeep Sodhi Liberal Brampton Centre, ON

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Thank you to our witnesses for being here today.

Ms. Freeman, it is nice to see you again. We spoke at the end of committee last time, but I would like to reiterate how sorry I am for everything you have been through and for the loss of your dad.

In your previous testimony before this committee, you spoke about the burden that has been placed on victims and their families to repeatedly register, request information and follow up with federal institutions to understand decisions that affect the offender who harmed them. You also emphasized that timely information can provide victims with a greater sense of both security and control.

In your opinion, what practical changes could the federal government make to ensure that victims can easily receive timely and consistent information about important developments?

11:20 a.m.

Victim Rights Advocate, As an Individual

Lisa Freeman

Thank you for your comments and your question.

I do know that regional communication officers try their best to get the information out to people. Where I work, in my role, it's the same kind of thing, but I always follow up with people to make sure they have the information, or if they have any questions I can help with, or if they have any suggestions that could make things easier. That's how I would do something like this.

I'm sure it's a very daunting job to reach out to whatever you have in your file for people that you have to reach out to, but I would make it a priority. I think that's what's lost here. Victims of crime don't feel that they are a priority. When I say that this is why it's such a frustrating process, it's because we are fully aware of that. It occurred to me during COVID—that's why it was such a frustrating time—that it's the offenders the system was designed for, not victims of crime. That really needs to be addressed. It really needs to be re-addressed, looked at and changed.

Amandeep Sodhi Liberal Brampton Centre, ON

You've also spoken about the importance of victims having a meaningful opportunity to participate in parole hearings. You just mentioned that often victims don't feel like a priority as well. From your perspective, what would a more meaningful and accessible participation process look like? What changes do you believe would make the greatest difference for victims and their families?

11:20 a.m.

Victim Rights Advocate, As an Individual

Lisa Freeman

I think the change that would make the greatest impact would be meaningful participation. I've had it said to me multiple times, “If you can't attend, or if we don't have a hearing for you, we'll have your statement in the file.” Well, that means nothing to me. A statement is just words on paper until I'm there to present it. Multiple people I've spoken to feel the same way. I think a greater effort into getting people to hearings should happen.

I think the timeline should work better for people. As Ms. Mac Donald said, people who might live remotely need more time than the 30 days' notice. That's something that people aren't just saying; that's exactly what they're experiencing. It should be taken into consideration, even if it's on a case-by-case basis.

If you know I live in a remote area and you know I have challenges getting to where I need to be because of other obligations, etc., then that should be on the victim's file. That should be considered first and foremost. Getting people to hearings—that's where their power is and that's where their control is—should be first and foremost in the mind of whoever puts all these calendars together.

Amandeep Sodhi Liberal Brampton Centre, ON

I'm going to move on to Ms. Mac Donald.

Your organization has spent more than four decades advocating for the collective rights and interests of victims of criminal offences. Looking at the federal conditional release system, where do you see the most significant gaps in the implementation of victims' rights, and what practical changes would you recommend to the committee to address them?

11:25 a.m.

Executive Director, Plaidoyer Victimes

Karine Mac Donald

A great many potential changes could be made. We spoke earlier about access to information. Bill S‑12 will indeed allow for a proactive approach. We're really happy to see this. However, it's a shame that it took three years to implement. Again, this applies only if the victim was informed of the victim impact statement and was able to check the box stating that they wished to receive the information.

The participation of victims in hearings, through the victim impact statement, is important. People feel that victims are limited in what they can say given the information redacted from victim impact statements. A victim's participation is limited solely to this statement. The victim may not speak at any other point during the hearing, even if false statements are made, for example. There may also be information that could affect the victim's safety in the future. There are certain issues of this nature regarding the rights of victims that remain unaddressed. I could list a wide range of rights.

We also have the right to protection when we talk about the conditions provided to victims. I don't know whether you saw the media coverage in Quebec about the case of a defendant who had been unlawfully at large for two months after escaping from a halfway house. The Correctional Service of Canada didn't inform the victim that the defendant was unlawfully at large. It was a serious case of domestic violence. The defendant had been sentenced to 54 months in prison. The Correctional Service told the media that it was the police's job to inform the victim. However, when we look at the legislation, the Correctional Service is actually responsible for informing the victim. It's concerning to hear that a victim might have crossed paths with their abuser on the street without having been aware of that person's release. The goal is to ensure that victims are aware of the conditions, the means of enforcing them and the conditions that haven't been met as well.

The Chair Liberal Jean-Yves Duclos

Thank you, Ms. Sodhi.

Mrs. DeBellefeuille, you have the floor for six minutes.