Thank you, Madam Chair.
For those who didn't understand, let me clarify again that I'm explaining an independent scientific study funded by the federal government. I've just been asked by members of the government about the relevance of the data or the document I'm talking about today. I'm explaining that there are inequalities in research funding and that they can only be analyzed if researchers have access to data. I can sum it up like that.
Researchers have appeared before the committee and told us that they didn't have access to data. Right now, we're debating having access to data so that researchers, or the committee's analysts, can analyze that data and then verify whether various inequalities exist, based on the various criteria, in the distribution of research funding. That's how you build public policy based on data.
I see that my colleague doesn't want us to have access to this data because it would highlight all the inequalities in research funding in Canada.
Let me continue with my important presentation, which I started today.
Data on the insight grants indicate that these disparities stem primarily from the assessment of candidates' résumés, which the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council's documentation calls “ability”.
As I was saying, professors at U3 institutions score an average of 4.88 out of 6, while candidates from non-U15 institutions score an average of 4.62 out of 6, a difference of 0.26%. Of the three assessment criteria, it's the one where the effect of the university is most pronounced.
As for the “challenge” criterion, which is based on the project evaluation, the average difference between candidates from U3 institutions and non-U15 institutions is 0.17. For “feasibility”, it's 0.12. As to the “ability” criterion, the greatest gaps are in the disciplines that tend to favour candidates from the most prestigious universities. Those are disciplines such as management, where the gap is 0.60; economics, where the gap is 0.49; philosophy, where the gap is 0.47; and political science, where the gap is 0.34. These disciplines favour the résumés of professors from U3 institutions more than in fields such as anthropology, where the gap is 0.18, geography, where the gap is 0.15, and fine arts, where the gap is 0.12.
The concentration gradient of funding is also reflected in how members of the evaluation committee perceive the importance of university affiliations across disciplines. The interviews conducted with historians, sociologists, political scientists and economists highlight the various cuts and various roles that academic hierarchies play in the evaluation process. Certain disciplines focus mainly on the evaluation of candidates' résumés, which favours researchers affiliated with prestigious educational institutions. Others focus more on the project, leaving more room for non-U3 and U15 candidates to demonstrate the strength of their application.
So it's a continuum that is visible in the way committee members, depending on their discipline, discuss the role of inequalities among universities in the evaluation process. Thus, in keeping with the position of their discipline, historians tend to reject the idea that university prestige is an indicator of quality and that grants go to professors who are affiliated with major universities. In the case of history, talent is distributed very evenly across the country. That's a good thing. The quality of historians working at any university is impressive. This is a question that researchers are asking. That's why it's great to be on these committees.
We see that people from very small institutions with very few resources are still putting forth incredible projects. That's wonderful. Those people can perform miracles with very little.
I will continue with what a historian from the U15 group said. He said he would be surprised if the success rate was significantly different among the major institutions. In the social sciences and humanities, there could be minor effects, but he would be surprised if there were a significant difference, for example, between Mount Allison University and the University of Waterloo. We know the location of this historian, who is based in Ontario. The fact is that his remarks are contradicted by the statistical results. Science is awesome, isn't it? This historian, both a researcher and a professor, is intelligent, critical and analytical. He thought something that was ultimately checked by the data and turned out to be false. That's science. In order to analyze hypotheses, we need data, which members of the government don't always seem to fully understand.
The fact is that this historian's remarks are contradicted by the study's statistical results. Overall, applicants from large institutions receive more grants for larger amounts, including in the social sciences and humanities. Nonetheless, his remarks provide an idea of the relative importance given to the prestige and size of universities by discipline when compared with the opinions of researchers in more hierarchical disciplines. Historians therefore do not consider that there is a correlation between a candidate's university affiliation and the merit of their project. Their judgment is based mainly on the content of the project, including its methodological rigour and feasibility.
At the other end of the disciplinary continuum, economists place much more weight on résumés because of the hierarchical nature of economics, which relies heavily on explicit rankings by journals, departments, sub-areas or methods and so forth, and widely shared quality indicators. Committee members therefore tend to refer to those standardized scales of merit in assessing candidates. In particular, the number and type of articles published by candidates serve as a generic measure of scientific merit. In some cases, a good résumé can even make up for the shortcomings of a project. It's really interesting.
Still in the U15 group, there is a certain economist from Alberta. That's good, because all the data here is anonymized, as requested. We know the location, the grouping and the discipline, but we don't have the names. That's why the motion calls for access to that data. This is scientific data that is validated by researchers. The request is realistic—I have it before me—because it comes from a federally funded, certified, independent researcher.
This economist said he thinks it can sometimes play a compensatory role in the case of a rather weak or questionable project, perhaps not weak, but to counterbalance potential concerns about the project's content. He believes that it may not be clearly worded, which he is not entirely convinced of, because it was expected. However, the authors published an article in Econometrica, so he's willing to give them the benefit of the doubt to some extent.
That's interesting, isn't it? The strength of a research project is also analyzed based on a researcher having published in a certain journal. That affects the merit of a researcher's project. We thought the project seemed weak, but since the researcher has already published an article in a reputable journal, we're going to give him a pat on the back and award him funding.
The discipline of economics also shows that funding is part of a much larger academic market, where prestige and resources are already distributed unequally. The role of the curriculum vitae in university recruitment combined with the fact that universities and departments are themselves ranked on their excellence—
